Are long-closed shows truly cursed at the Tonys?

Most Tony pundits are quick to write off the hopes of a nominee if the show has been closed for a while. But is that really a fair assumption to make?

Productions that closed just weeks before the Tonys are still fresh in the minds of voters. For example, in 2007 “The Coast of Uptopia” won a record seven Tonys on June 10, four weeks after shuttering on May 13. But if we focus just on productions that were closed for a good while prior to Tonys night, yes, it seems like they had little chance of triumphing. Below are a few of the exceptions. The Tonys are usually awarded in the first half of June each year.

BEST MUSICAL OR PLAY WINNERS

“The Life and Adventures of Nicholas Nickleby,” Best Play: closed January 3, 1982.

“Travesties,” Best Play: closed March 13, 1976.

“Hallelujah, Baby!,” Best Musical: closed January 13, 1968.

PERFORMANCE WINNERS

Julie White, Best Actress (Play), “The Little Dog Laughed”: closed Feb. 18, 2007.

Michele Pawk, Best Featured Actress (Play), “Hollywood Arms”: closed Jan. 5, 2003.

Patricia Routledge, Best Actress (Musical), “Darling of the Day”: closed Feb. 24, 1968.

Dolores Gray, Best Actress (Musical), “Carnival in Flanders”: closed (after six performances) Sept. 12, 1953.
 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *