Uh, oh: Is ‘Homeland’ in trouble at Golden Globes?

Although “Homeland” won Best TV Drama at the Globes for each of its first two seasons, the Showtime series may not be able to pull off a three-peat this year if critical reaction to the current run of episodes is anything to go by. 

While USA Today critic Robert Bianco gave the third season four stars, more reviews were along the lines of this pan by New York Times scribe Alessandra Stanley who said that the show “doesn’t just stretch credulity, it tries patience.” Its Metacritic score — which rose from 91 for season one to a jaw-dropping 96 for the sophomore season — has plummeted to 77.  

And that was before the fourth episode aired on Oct. 20, with a twist ending that left critics calling for the show’s head. [SPOILERS AHEAD

That episode concluded with the revelation that Carrie’s (Claire Danes) recent hospitalization and her public shaming by Saul (Mandy Patinkin) were part of a plan to coax a terrorist out of hiding.

Critics howled at this twist. Tim Goodman wrote a scathing column in the Hollywood Reporter, condemning it as “lazy and dangerous” and concluded “It might just be easier to watch ‘Homeland’ with the understanding that the greatness in season one was a fluke and expectations should be adjusted accordingly at this point.” Tv.com’s Tim Surrette called the twist “garbage” while Maureen Ryan (Huffington Post) dubbed it “truly awful.”

The Golden Globes were the first kudos to fete “Homeland,” with both the show and Danes winning in January, 2012. At that fall’s Emmys, it won Best Drama Series and writing while Danes and co-star Damian Lewis claimed the lead acting prizes. It then swept the January 2013 Globes, with repeat wins for the series and Danes and a first trophy for Lewis. However, at the recent Emmys, Danes won again as did the writers but the series lost to “Breaking Bad” while Lewis was bested by Jeff Daniels (“The Newsroom”). 

The upcoming editions of the Globes and SAG Awards (Danes won there last year) will give us clues as to how it might fare at next year’s Emmys. Lewis is reportedly only in five episodes this season, so he may not even qualify for consideration. 

Our current odds for the Globes have the series in second place (at 4 to 1) behind the final season of “Breaking Bad” with odds of 19 to 10. That AMC show lost its only Globes bid for Best Drama to “Homeland” last year. “Bad” star Bryan Cranston is favored to finally win TV Drama Actor on his fourth bid with Lewis in third behind Kevin Spacey (“House of Cards”). However, Danes is predicted to prevail for a third time.

This same scenario is likely to play out at the SAG Awards as well

What do you think will win Best TV Drama at the Golden Globes. Vote below using our easy drag-and-drop menu.

5 thoughts on “Uh, oh: Is ‘Homeland’ in trouble at Golden Globes?

  1. Breaking Bad deserves every recognition it can get. Best show of all time. Meanwhile Homeland, once one of the best shows on tv, is decaying heavily in quality. In my opinion, it should not even get nominated for its third season so far.

  2. Homeland went from MUST SEE to barely watchable. I cannot stand the story line with the daughter of Brody. And how many times can one watch Clair Dane’s repetitve histronics (masked as Bipolar …ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ. Not having Brody in but one spisode doesn’t help matters either. In my opinion, there is too much good TV on Sundays to bother with Homeland.

  3. Hating on Homeland seems like the new hipster thing to do, so yeah, it might be in trouble with the Globes. I still love it though, and I think it’s better than anything out there on broadcast networks. I loved Breaking Bad, but all the attention it gets kind of annoys me. I think I’m starting to root for Masters of Sex to win. And I’m fairly positive at this point that Lizzy Caplan is going to nab best actress.

  4. I watched the first season of Homeland on demand because of all the raves and I couldn’t be bothered to continue on to season 2. I like Claire Danes but her character is sooo annoying that I wanted to punch her in the face everytime she came on screen and Damien Lewis isn’t very appealing. If Homeland has really gotten as bad as most are saying, I hope it doesn’t steal a spot from a worthier contender.

  5. I personally think the show runners of Homeland were intimidated by the outstanding final episode of “Breaking Bad”, and just did not put all they could in the season. There was a waste of time on the Dana Story for the first part, and they did not use the best actors in the entire season. If they lose it all, it is their fault. They had the making of something great in TV history, but they dropped the ball. Just a waste of talented actors from Mandy, Rupert, Morena, Damian, and I could go on and on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *