Will Directors Guild Awards give us clearer picture of Oscars?

Following Sunday’s tie by “Gravity” and “12 Years a Slave” at the PGA Awards and the win by “American Hustle” of Best Ensemble at Saturday’s SAG Awards, we can be fairly certain that one of these three will win Best Picture at the Oscars?

But which one?

We might have a better sense this Saturday when the Directors Guild of America reveals their winner. After all, in the 65-year history of these kudos, the guild choice has helmed the academy’s pick for Best Picture 52 times, including last year when Oscar-snubbed Ben Affleck won with the DGA while “Argo” went on to take the top Academy Award. 

This 80% success rate at predicting the Best Picture champ eclipses that of both the PGA (17/24 -71%) and SAG (9/18 — 50%). 

The 13 exceptions to the DGA rule (and three of these also number among the seven instances where the DGA champ did not also win Best Director at the Oscars) were:

1948 — DGA to “A Letter to Three Wives” and Best Picture to “Hamlet”

1951 — DGA to “A Place in the Sun” and Best Picture to “An American in Paris”

1952 — DGA to “The Quiet Man” and Best Picture to “The Greatest Show on Earth”

1956 — DGA to “Giant” and Best Picture to “Around the World in 80 Days”

1967 — DGA to “The Graduate” and Oscar to “In the Heat of the Night”

1968 — DGA to “The Lion in Winter” and Best Picture to “Oliver!” (Carol Reed won Best Director as well)

1981 — DGA to “Reds “and Best Picture to “Chariots of Fire”

1985 — DGA to “The Color Purple” and Best Picture to “Out of Africa” (Sydney Pollack won Best Director as well)

1989 — DGA to “Born on the Fourth of July” and Best Picture to “Driving Miss Daisy”

1995 — DGA to “Apollo 13” and Best Picture to “Braveheart” (Mel Gibson won Best Director as well)

1998 — DGA to “Saving Private Ryan” and Best Picture to “Shakespeare in Love”

2000 — DGA to “Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon” and Best Picture to “Gladiator”

2005 — DGA to “Brokeback Mountain” and Best Picture to “Crash”

But could this year mark the 14th exception? 

All of our Experts save for Sasha Stone (Awards Daily) are predicting Alfonso Cuaron (“Gravity“) will win the DGA award. However, none of the Experts is predicting his picture to take the top Oscar.

Rather, 14/18 Experts expect “12 Years a Slave” will win Best Picture. That disparity explains why Stone is backing the DGA bid by that film’s helmer, Steve McQueen. Four Experts favor “American Hustle for Best Picture, which was directed by DGA nominee David O. Russell

Who do you think is going to win the Directors Guild of America award? Vote below using our easy drag-and-drop menu.

4 thoughts on “Will Directors Guild Awards give us clearer picture of Oscars?

  1. This is gonna be real interesting as DGA is like the fork in the road of the race, either it can go to russell like SAG and effectively end the BP race, or it can go to Cuaron and there may be split, which I doubt after the PGA tie, or Gravity could win BP.

  2. There seems to be some clear love for ‘American Hustle,’ so I’m going to make a crazy prediction (as I have in previous posts) that ‘Slave’ and ‘Gravity’ will split the vote, and David O. Russell will win the DGA.

  3. The SAG win for Hustle is almost meaningless. Gravity was hardly going to win that award seeing it’s ‘ensemble’ was only two actors. Cuaron will win the DGA, and the Oscar will be between it and 12YAS.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *