Did ‘Frozen’ melt enough hearts to earn Best Picture nomination at Oscars?

Brrrr … are the Oscars about to give “Frozen” the cold shoulder in the Best Picture race?

Frozen” is expected to win both the Golden Globe and the Oscar for Best Animated Feature according to predictions made by Gold Derby’s Experts, Editors and Users. So why isn’t this Disney flick a more serious contender for Best Picture at the Academy Awards?

As it stands now, “Frozen” has leading 15/8 odds at the Oscars for Best Animated Feature, but lowly 100/1 odds for Best Picture. Perhaps the movie’s biggest detriment to playing in the big leagues is the Academy’s long-held penchant for overlooking animated films. They made an effort to right this wrong back in 2001 with the creation of the Animated Feature category, but otherwise animated films have been largely neglected in other categories.

It’s true, over the past 85 years of Oscar ceremonies, a whopping 503 films have been nominated for Best Picture, with only three of those being animated: “Beauty and the Beast” (1991), “Up” (2009) and “Toy Story 3” (2010). No animated film has ever won.

Those last two animated nominees came from the mega-hot Pixar Animation Studios, while “Frozen” (like “Beauty and the Beast”) was produced by classic Disney. Pixar has its own horse in the race this year, “Monsters University,” that isn’t tracking nearly as well as “Up” or “Toy Story 3” did.

It should be noted that “Frozen” features a dual-female perspective from two sisters, played by Idina Menzel and Kristen Bell. That may be a drawback amongst Academy voters, 70% of whom are male with an average age over 60. Contrast that with male-dominated “Up” and “Toy Story 3” — the former about a crotchety old man and the latter appealing to the elderly voters who pine after the play things of their youth.

“Beauty and the Beast” remains the only female-centric animated flick to ever be nominated for Best Picture. Last year’s “Brave” (2012) couldn’t make the final cut despite winning Best Animated Feature, nor could other female-skewing ‘toons like “Coraline” (2009), “The Princess and the Frog” (2009) and “Persepolis” (2007).

“Frozen” is a critical and box office hit, with a score of 74 at Metacritic and an astounding $300 million in domestic ticket sales. (It’s also my three-year-old niece’s favorite movie, if that means anything.) In other words, if there’s one animated film this year that could join the ranks of “Beauty and the Beast,” “Up” and “Toy Story 3,” it would be “Frozen.”

The main competitors that hope to dethrone “Frozen” for Oscar’s Best Animated Picture race include “The Wind Rises” (3/1 odds), “Monsters University” (6/1 odds), “Despicable Me 2” (9/1 odds) and “The Croods” (9/1 odds).

The film also has a song in contention at this weekend’s Golden Globes ceremony in the Best Original Song category — “Let It Go” — that’s tracking in first place in our predictions. Watch the music video below, performed by Menzel, then vote for Best Animated Feature using our easy drag-and-drop menu.

7 thoughts on “Did ‘Frozen’ melt enough hearts to earn Best Picture nomination at Oscars?

  1. I think GoldDerby only added it to its list of Best Picture contenders within the last few days, but I’ve seen ordinary folks elsewhere suggesting a Best Picture nomination since before it even opened. I suspect the experts aren’t tuned in because (a) it’s animated and (b) it’s not Pixar. I have this weird dream that somehow the Academy will nominate both “Frozen” and “Blue is the Warmest Color”, just so the pundits will wonder how on earth they could count *both* Disney animation *and* lesbian erotica among the year’s top films! 😀

  2. Now that he mentioned it and considering the fact that Frozen was magnificent (I’ve seen it three times now), I could now root the film for a Best Picture nomination. Just as long as the Academy doesn’t shut out an animated film in the category again, like what they did to WALL-E in 2009.

  3. WHY DIDN’T FROZEN GET A BEST PICTURE NOMINATION? Best animated film in over 20 years, maybe of all time, and still none?

  4. I think Frozen should win the best picture award because, Frozen is the first film ever that shows deep human emotions & expresses real love between royal sisterhood.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *