SAG Awards nominations: Good (Tatiana Maslany), bad (Matt Bomer) & ugly (‘Good Wife’ cast snub)

It seems like a long time ago since the Emmyss, so hooray for another batch of TV kudos for our awards-obsessed editors of Gold Derby. Now that the Screen Actors Guild Award nominations have been unveiled, here are our collective thoughts on the highs, lows and everything in between for the SAG announcement. 

Related: Complete list of 2014 SAG Awards nominations

GOOD
Tatiana Maslany (“Orphan Black”) and Uzo Aduba (“Orange is the New Black”) break into the Female Drama and Comedy races. I can’t decide which is more awesome so I’ll just call this a tie. And then there was the nomination for William H. Macy (“Shameless”) – well done, SAG TV. – Ralph Galvan

SAG voters have been remarkably boring over the last few years, but this year they at least tried to mix it up, especially in its Female Actor categories. Tatiana Maslany! Uzo Aduba! Viola Davis! I’m also surprised to see a re-invigorated Homeland still in the nominees list, even though many have written it off. – Rob Licuria

I’m really glad to see both “Orange is the New Black” and “Veep” nominated for their casts. Both shows have magnificent ensembles and it is always great to see the whole group get some collective recognition. – Charles Bright

I am beyond excited to see the veteran Richard Jenkins for “Olive Kitteridge“, who gave an incredible performance (alongside co-star Frances McDormand, who is also deserving but expected). Welcome back, Amy Poehler! – Chris Beachum

Viola Davis has been one of my favorite actors for the last 10 years, so it’s exciting to see her not only given a great showcase role on “How to Get Away with Murder,” but recognized for it immediately in the cutthroat Best Drama Actress race. – Daniel Montgomery

True Detective” being snubbed for a TV Drama Ensemble nomination was the right move by SAG. The show was not known for its ensemble, but rather its two stars who did end up reaping noms: Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson. – Marcus Dixon

Related: SAG Awards snubs include Kerry Washington, Jessica Lange, Martin Freeman

BAD
Poor Matt Bomer. What does he have to do to get his well deserved hardware for his transformative and heartbreaking performance on The Normal Heart? That category in particular is missing a few names that made me look twice. Fail. – Rob Licuria

No, “The Crazy Ones” wasn’t his best role, but it would have been nice to see Robin Williams receive a nomination as a tribute to the late comedian. – Daniel Montgomery

I hate not seeing Allison Tolman (“Fargo”), Jeff Daniels (“The Newsroom“), or anybody from “Mad Men” or “The Americans” (especially Matthew Rhys) – Chris Beachum

As wonderful as it is seeing Uzo Aduba (“Orange is the New Black”) receive a nomination, it’s unfortunate that other newbies couldn’t get their time in the spotlight. Where is predicted winner Jeffrey Tambor (“Transparent”), scene-stealer Clive Owen (“The Knick”) or comeback kid Lisa Kudrow (“The Comeback”)? – Marcus Dixon

What does Jeffrey Tambor have to do to get some proper recognition from his peers? Not only was he predicted to get nominated for TV Comedy Actor for his role in “Transparent” but he was predicted to win the award as well. But alas, Tambor was not nominated for his amazing performance. Do the nominating members of SAG really expect us to believe that the same old antics of Eric Stonestreet (“Modern Family“) and Jim Parsons (“The Big Bang Theory“) were more deserving of recognition than Tambor’s groundbreaking work? – Charles Bright

Allison Janney is a proven favorite amongst her peers (see: six Emmy awards) but she couldn’t even squeeze past some “her again?” nominees to land a nomination for her hilarious work in “Mom”? Bad, SAG. Just … bad. – Ralph Galvan

Related: Forums posters rant and rave about SAG nominations

UGLY
Name recognition still rules at SAG. Everyone rightly adores Maggie Smith (“Downton Abbey“) and Ellen Burstyn (“Flowers in the Attic“), but does anyone think they gave better performances than Keri Russell (“The Americans“), Lizzy Caplan (“Masters of Sex“), or Allison Tolman (“Fargo“)? – Daniel Montgomery

I feel like I say this every year, but the fact that there is no ensemble prize for TV Movie/Miniseries is a mystery that needs to be rectified ASAP. Please? – Marcus Dixon

Once again, SAG has shown that when it comes to the television categories, there needs to be a complete overhaul in terms of how those honors are bestowed. The fact that there are absolutely no supporting categories is bad enough since it forces someone like Uzo Aduba (“Orange is the New Black”) to compete against people who dominate an entire series like Julia Louis-Dreyfus (“Veep”). But it gets even worse when you see that there’s no prize for the cast of a TV movie or miniseries. Please address this SAG and preferably sooner rather than later. – Charles Bright 

I like seeing the new blood in the Comedy Ensemble category but how can any TV Ensemble award not nominate the best ensemble in all of TV: the cast of “Shameless”? In what was the shows best season to date the actors each stepped up their game with difficult and captivating individual storylines which they displayed impeccably each episode. I’m glad for the Macy nom but this is more than a one man show (if anything it’s criminally ignored Emmy Rossum’s show). – Ralph Galvan

You know it’s coming: The Good Wife deserves better than a single nomination for SAG catnip (and thoroughly deserving) Julianna Margulies. It’s the best show on TV. It’s the best ensemble on TV. Period. It’s hard to quibble with what is in the list – all worthy ensembles. But it stings to see such a great show forgotten, especially after another strong start to season six and the last half of its hallmark season five. – Rob Licuria

More News from GoldDerby

Loading