Will ‘The Normal Heart’ sweep Emmys like ‘Angels in America’ did?

HBO’s “The Normal Heart” premiered on May 25, right under the wire of the Emmys’ eligibility cut-off (May 31), so it’s well positioned to take the awards by storm. But will it dominate as decisively as “Angels in America” did 10 years ago?

Ryan Murphy: Why I burned to do ‘The Normal Heart

The two projects have a lot in common: both of these HBO dramas address the early years of the AIDS crisis in New York City, and both are adapted from Tony-winning stage productions, with screenplays by the original authors (Tony Kushner penned “Angels” for stage and screen while Larry Kramer wrote “Normal Heart”).

“Angels” pulled off an overwhelming sweep of the Emmys, winning 11 in all including Best Miniseries, Movie/Mini Writing and Directing, and all four acting races. At the time, it tied the record of “Eleanor and Franklin” for the biggest haul ever for a movie or miniseries, though that was eclipsed by “John Adams” with 13 wins in 2008.

Could “The Normal Heart” match that total? It’s bolstered by strong critical acclaim – scoring 85 on MetaCritic and earning a leading five nominations at the Critics’ Choice Awards – as well as the 1.4 million combined viewers it drew for its two premiere-night airings. Those are far from “Game of Thrones“-level numbers, but it’s a solid showing for a film with such grim subject matter.

‘Normal Heart’ red carpet photos: Matt Bomer, Angelina Jolie, Mark Ruffalo

It’s possible the film could win all of its telecast categories: TV Movie, Movie/Mini Writing and Directing, and Movie/Mini Actor, Supporting Actor, and Supporting Actress. That’s six.

But what about Creative Arts categories? It could be a strong contender for Casting, Picture Editing, Score, and Makeup for its harrowing depiction of the ravages of AIDS, though the contemporary drama may lack the showy details to win more visual categories like Art Direction and Cinematography. Nevertheless, that’s a plausible 10 awards if all goes well for the Ryan Murphy-directed drama.

Jump into the red-hot Emmys debate in our fiery forums

The biggest hurdle for “The Normal Heart” may be the unusually deep field of longform programs it’ll be competing against. Movies and miniseries have surged during the past television season, including “Fargo,” “The Trip to Bountiful,” “Dancing on the Edge,” “Sherlock,” and “Luther,” to name a few, so it might be difficult for any one program to sweep.

Currently, “The Normal Heart” is the strong favorite in our combined predictions to win Best TV Movie (15/8 odds), while its actors face tough competition on all fronts. Lead star Mark Ruffalo ranks a close second to Billy Bob Thornton (“Fargo”) for Movie/Mini Actor. Matt Bomer is challenged in the Movie/Mini Supporting Actor race by frontrunner Martin Freeman (“Sherlock: His Last Vow“). And Julia Roberts will have to take down Kathy Bates (“American Horror Story: Coven“) for Movie/Mini Supporting Actress.

Bomer and Roberts’s parts won Tonys for John Benjamin Hickey and Ellen Barkin, respectively, in the 2011 stage version, so those roles are already proven winners. Will their success, and the success of the play as a whole, transfer to the small screen?

Follow Gold Derby on FacebookTwitterInstagram, Tumblr, iTunes and YouTube

Predict Best TV Movie below using our easy drag-and-drop menu. 

10 thoughts on “Will ‘The Normal Heart’ sweep Emmys like ‘Angels in America’ did?

  1. It would be a travesty if Matt Bomer is beaten by Martin Freeman. The performances aren’t in the same league, and Freeman always tends to pretty much play to type.

  2. Is Martin Freeman Submitted in supporting category for Sherlock or for Fargo?.. If Sherlock then he has no chance ….the award will go to Bomer…Sherlock is usually not considered a “big” frontrunner…

  3. Any production that makes you laugh, cry, and get very very angry is a shoo in for a shower of Emmys. Fargo is quirky, well acted, and intriguing though starting to wear thin. The Normal Heart was great theater with a purpose.

  4. I hope both Bomer and Ruffalo win. They both did an outstanding job in such an important film. Julia was good too. I think the entire cast did a nice job of telling the story. I think Fargo is great, but I really am hoping The Normal Heart takes this.

  5. I’m really crossing my fingers for The Normal Heart to score big at the Emmys, and especially for the actors (Bomer, Ruffalo, Roberts, etc.) to score nominations for their tremendous work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *