Our take on ‘American Idol’ smackdown: Harry Connick Jr. vs. Quentin Alexander

Harry Connick Jr. vs. Quentin Alexander: Whose side do you take in the “American Idol” smackdown heard round the world? Scroll down to see our fiery forum posters sound off on the controversy. Hurry — make your predictions for next week’s episode and you could win our prize of a $100 Amazon gift certificate. It’s fun and easy, so start now by scrolling down and predicting who will be eliminated next.

American Idol’ recap: Did you predict ‘wack’ elimination of Joey Cook?

Here are some of the comments from our “American Idol” forum as the smackdown was happening Wednesday night. (If you missed the live confrontation between Harry and Quentin, watch the video at the very bottom of this post.)

Atypical: Live television drama! Goodness.

Ryan Lapierre: Quentin shut up. What a classy person.

Tyler The Awesome Guy: I will take a guess and say that Quentin will be going home because of his little dispute after his first performance.

JB: Wow, “Idol” was full of drama tonight. That exchange between Harry and Quentin was super uncomfortable (most uncomfortable thing on the show since Sanjaya!) and rather annoying. Going Home: Quentin (He shouldn’t have opened his mouth and apparently Rayvon wins all the twitter battles, lol)

vinny: Liked the first [song] but that second one was “wack.” Also, apology was nice but I sorta feel like his thought process was “Damn, I messed up.” The other contestants that were safe must have been like “Dude WFT.” But more importantly, it was good drama. In short, Quentin pretty much screwed himself over.

Troy: I don’t watch “American Idol” anymore, but saw the clips from last night. The Quentin guy seems like an arrogant prick. Connick was right to say what he did — it’s a competition. Get your emotions in check because nobody would even be talking about you if it weren’t for “Idol” (there are far more talented singers/performers than him in any given local band in any given American town). Hopefully he gets the boot next week.

Atypical: I’ll never fault Quentin for having his emotions as he was having them. I could see how he wanted to defend and clarify himself against Harry Connick Jr., who can be very smug and douchey on panel. If Quentin had to say something on the air like that, it should have been confined to his remarks made with Ryan after his performances. Coming back on stage like that for a stare down with Harry was cray and of course would paint him in the “angry black man” light and pretty much seals up his elimination next week regardless of what he actually does in terms of performances. Sad.

Gucci: Honey, Quentin’s little outburst will get him eliminated next week. Harry Connick Jr. is a total douchebag.

Tyler The Awesome Guy: For all those Quentin haters I say, listen, actually listen to his singing voice. He is arguably the most talented of the boys except for Clark, and I think his little outburst was the result of being in the lights and cameras and drama and the crowds of the most stressful stage in reality-competition singing series. He just cracked under the pressure.

BenitoDelicias: That was pretty crazy. I think both men were very very wrong in what they did and what they said. Quentin was pretty ridiculous in general and Harry’s comment alone would’ve been enough to put people against Quentin. Of course it wasn’t Harry’s intention, but misinterpretation of the comment or not, I hate that Harry did that thinking he’s going to go all macho defending his dear “Idol” institution in front of everybody. He had to know it could ruin Quentin very easily.

Agree or disagree with our users’ comments? Join the discussion and lend us your own thoughts!

‘American Idol’ predictions: 3 singers who can actually win

Congratulations to our user TWTaylorHooper for winning this week’s episode contest. If eligible, this reader will win a $100 Amazon gift certificate thanks to reaping 80% accuracy and a 9,354 point score when predicting Top 7 Week. See contest rules.

TWTaylorHooper’s winning predictions were that Joey would be eliminated, that Rayvon Owen would earn the Idol Fan Save (for the third week in a row), that Jennifer Lopez would have “goosies” and that Harry Connick Jr. would not mention a singer’s “intonation.” He only missed out on predicting whether Keith Urban would give a standing ovation, which he did.

Joey was actually ranked third in Gold Derby’s predictions to go home with final odds of 12/1 (click on the left-hand chart for the episode’s full odds). However, TWTaylorHooper put his 500 point bet on that prediction when Joey had even lower odds of 16/1, thus reaping whopping 8,000 points. That’s why it’s advantageous to keep coming back to Gold Derby to see if the odds of your picks have gotten better or worse throughout the week.

Which singer will be eliminated next? Be sure to visit our predictions center and make/update your forecasts before voting closes Wednesday at 5 p.m. PT. The user with the highest prediction accuracy and most points will win a $100 Amazon gift certificate.

‘American Idol’ poll: What’s your favorite Nick Fradiani performance? (Cast your vote)

Where do you fall on our overall Season 14 leaderboard?

For the entire season so far, JB is still in first place with 62% prediction accuracy. As for JB’s winner prediction, he tells us, “I’d say Clark has this season in the bag. At this point, it’s a race for second place with Jax in the lead.”

Next up on our leaderboard is Phoenix in second place with 58% accuracy, followed by our frequent contest winner Denton in third place with 53%. Amikala is fourth place with 51%, while Povalles rounds out our Top 5 with 49%. Click here to see where you score on our overall season leaderboard.

Can YOU beat these frontrunners to win our prizes? Then be sure to take part in our “American Idol” prediction contest. We’re giving away $100 Amazon gift certificates to our weekly winners plus at season’s end. The deadline for each episode is Wednesday at 5 p.m. PT.

Our current overall leader JB correctly predicted Qaasim Middleton‘s exit in Top 8 Week. However, he missed calling Joey’s elimination this week (see complete predix), proving that it’s possible to do well in our contests without getting everything right.

Remember that coming out on top doesn’t just mean answering that week’s questions correctly. You also have to use your three big bets (500 points and two of 200 points) strategically to score the most game points. If you bet on a longshot who pulls off an upset, you can really rack up the points, so don’t take them for granted.

To vote for who think will go home next on “American Idol,” drag contestants over from the left to the right and arrange them in your predicted order. For example, if you think Nick will be eliminated, make sure you put him in first place. You can continue to update and change your predictions throughout the week, just click “Save Predictions” when you’ve settled on your choice.

Who will win ‘American Idol’? See exclusive predictions

Average Gold Derby users just like YOU often turn out to be our smartest prognosticators, so it’s important that you give us your predictions. You can change them later as often as you like.

We are forecasting everything from the results on TV shows like “The Voice,” “Survivor,” “Dancing with the Stars,” “American Idol” and “The Amazing Race” to the winners of the Emmys (Primetime and Daytime) and Tonys.

Get started by making your prediction as to which singer will go home next using our easy drag-and-drop menu below. And be sure to sound off on the current season of “American Idol” in Gold Derby’s reality TV forum.

11 thoughts on “Our take on ‘American Idol’ smackdown: Harry Connick Jr. vs. Quentin Alexander

  1. I just don’t understand you people. Ryan Seacrest asked Quentin what was on his mind and he did. For cornick to say what he said was definitely inappropriate. I applaud Quentin for going back and clarifying for the misinterpretation. I bet all of you who are saying this are white and just don’t understand how standing up for yourself works.

  2. So no one on this site sees it from Quentin’s standpoint. Were you even trying to listen to this brother or hear him out even after he explained himself. Harry is the one who called him out and being totally disrespectful but I guess you guys missed all that. As the other commentor said, most of you if not all are white and not give any credit for this man standing up for himself, it’s very sad and typical.

  3. I am a complete Quentin fan…but I know politics and he screwed himself royally. They had to keep Rayon after his disrespect for the process. I can’t stand Rayon but gotta keep a black man which proved Quentin is out next week.

  4. I don’t think Quentin is going Home. Poll results from other sites were clearly with team Quentin. I, personally thought Harry was out of line and he was disrespectful. Play it over- watch Keith’s initial reaction. Even, Keith thought Harry was “whack”. Harry has poor interpersonal skills and still poorer listen comprehension. 90% of the audience found Quentin clear. Harry is a dumba$$ with a penchant , for opening his mouth before engaging his brain. Don’t forget HCJ was a far cry from a household name, prior to his judgeship on AI. Oh, and BTW Simon would have asked questions first.

  5. Before this show, I had never heard of Harry Connick, Jr. I gave him a good listen most of this season, until the night he fought with Quentin. I completely understood where Quentin was going with his comment. Then when Harry made his comment about “the hand that feeds you,” I was so disappointed. That comment was designed to be hurtful, not helpful, as a judge on this show should be. Please get a different judge, someone who will not attempt to derail a talented performer’s career before they even begin. Shame on you, Harry.

  6. I completely understand Quentin. American Idol is whacked! It’s funny to me how Quentin can be slain and almost assured not to make it next week just because he said what was on his mind. White America speaks again…I’m so glad Quentin corrected Ryan when he tried to imply Quentin appeared to want to attack Harry. I’m so sick of this stereotypical BS; American Idol is a racist show anyhow, not surprising being on Fox! They string the black talent along for as long as they can and then they’re eliminated. Quentin, you definitely have a career and I’m sure you’ll get picked up by a label that understands true black artistry.

  7. Harry is the one that’s wack. “Harsh Harry” is always yapping on & on about his need to be totally honest with the contestants & demanding they show more emotions. Well, I loved Quentin’s brutal honesty & real emotion!!! I loved how he selflessly stood up for his friends Joey & Rayvon!!! I loved how he refused to let Harry define his words. This has got to be the most sincere, candid & truthful moment in Idol’s history …ever! Loved it!!! Loved it!!! Wow!!! Quentin got ALL of my votes this week on American Idol!!!
    I wish more people in this industry had as much empathy & compassion for others as Quentin displayed, instead of always thinking selfishly about satisfying their own enormous egos. He stood up for his friends & spoke truth to power, even at the risk of his own standing in the competition. That’s not being “thin skinned” or having a “tantrum.” That’s the very definition of bravery, sensitivity & being a hero. “Harsh Harry” could take lessons from this kid. That’s why ALL of my votes went to Quentin this week & only him!!!
    Harry Connick Jr. should have know better than to escalate a situation like this. But experience & prudence are not the same things. “Harsh Harry” interjected himself into a conversation that was clearly not his own & made an awkward situation even more uncomfortable. This is obviously not the action of a wise, thoughtful, caring, helpful judge or mentor. If young Quentin’s neophyte response is due to the shock & hurt of seeing his close friends up for elimination & his inexperience & immaturity in this biz. Then certainly Harry’s abrasive, curt response & poor timing sent the wrong lesson from a seasoned performer.
    Harry is a smug, little drama queen. He refuse to clap for the contestants. He won’t stand for the contestants. He nitpicks the smallest, pettiest thing about their performance. He’s trying real hard to play the role of “professor perfect” on Idol. Yet he’s no great singer himself. But I’m sure when he performs, he craves the same applause & the same ovation that he denies his fellow artists. How do you spell vain, pompous, egotistical hypocrite?
    ALL of my votes went to Quentin Alexander this week. Every single last one of them!!! ‪#‎QuentinAlexander‬, ‪#‎voteQuentin‬, #vote4quentin, ‪#‎voteQuentinAlexander‬, #teamQuentin, #teamQuentinAlexander.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More News from GoldDerby