Emmy nominations: The good (Amy Schumer), bad (Gina Rodriguez snub) & ugly (Katy Perry)

For the awards-obsessed editors of Gold Derby, the Emmy Awards nominations are like every Christmas, birthday and wedding all rolled into one. We eagerly await the announcement of every name, celebrate our savvy predictions while bemoaning those snubs and surprises that show us up. Below, our collective thoughts on the highs, lows and WTF moments of Thursday’s big reveal. 

Join the fierce fights over the Emmys going on
right now in the Gold Derby message boards

GOOD
Four nominations for Amy Schumer as a writer, director, producer, and actor in “Inside Amy Schumer.” Daniel Montgomery

Loving “Late Show with David Letterman” and “Parks and Recreation” returning for their final seasons. Chris Beachum

Game of Thrones” cleaned house with a leading 24 nominations, cementing its position as the show to beat for the Best Drama Series crown. Also, a best-ever showing for “American Horror Story” (this season was “Freak Show”) at 19 nominations suggests voters may not be afraid of horror/fantasy after all. Marcus Dixon

Veep” continue their upward assult on that comedy series prize, taking their most ever nominations, including the previously elusive best directing nod. Matt Noble

Pamela Adlon finally nominated for her stellar recurring guest role in “Louie.” She has deserved to win it once or twice already. Daniel Montgomery

Jane the Virgin” didn’t get completely shut out. It did score a very deserved nomination for it’s awesome narrator, Anthony MendezRalph Galvan

Niecy Nash has been a comedic gem on television for years, going back to her days as Deputy Raineesha Williams on “Reno 911!” so it’s really nice to see her get recognized for her performance on “Getting On.” Charles Bright

American Crime” exceeded expectations. Thrilled to see surprise supporting nominations for Richard Cabral and Regina King, and a writing nod for Oscar-winner John Ridley. Daniel Montgomery

A really pleasant surprise to see “Parks and Recreation” back in the comedy series lineup; and with “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt” also breaking into the race it means we have both Tina Fey and Amy Poehler at the Emmys. Matt Noble

BAD
Your performance is universally hailed by critics. You win a Golden Globe for Comedy Actress and pick up both Critics Choice and Television Critics Assn. bids for your comedic chops YET the Emmys snub you Gina Rodriguez just because you’re on the CW. Shame TV Academy. Shame on you. Ralph Galvan

Two of the best performances of the year — Lois Smith (“The Americans”) and Lorraine Toussaint (“Orange is the New Black”) — were snubbed. Hmm, and here I thought the Emmys were supposed to honor the best of TV? Marcus Dixon

Mad Men” had a good day but it was a shame to see some of their stalwarts like John Slattery, Kiernan Shipka and January Jones land nominations. Also a true Emmy crime that no supporting stars ever got recognised from “Parks and Recreation.” Matt Noble

Lack of nods for Ellie KemperNathan Lane (twice), Nick Offerman, and Bill PaxtonChris Beachum

I love Margo Martindale and Khandi Alexander but nominating both of them for Drama Guest Actress (for “The Americans” and “Scandal” respectively) for appearances that don’t even last more than two or three minutes is just not right. Charles Bright

UGLY
Katy Perry has more Emmy nominations this year than “Looking,” “Rectify,” “The Affair,” and “Justified” — COMBINED Daniel Montgomery

After last year it was somewhat expected but to see our Emmy host Andy Samberg get left out again for his great lead role in “Brooklyn-Nine Nine” is terrible. Matt Noble

Three of my favorites — “The Americans,” “Justified,” and “The Comedians” — with no major nominations. Chris Beachum

Merritt Wever (“Nurse Jackie”) and Lorraine Toussaint (“Orange is the New Black”), two of the finest supporting ladies from the Emmy eligibility period not making it into the race for Comedy and Drama Supporting Actress respectively. Both gave the performances of their careers so far and the fact that they are absent from their categories makes those races all the less stellar. Charles Bright

There is obviously “Modern Family” fatigue now more than ever but that was no reason to snub one of the best episodes the series has ever produced: ‘Connection Lost’ in both writing and directing. Just crazy. Ralph Galvan

The Last Man on Earth” was nominated for Best Actor (Will Forte), Best Directing and Best Writing (for its pilot), but the Emmys couldn’t find room for it in the Best Comedy Series category? I demand a re-vote! Marcus Dixon

Will “Modern Family” win a record sixth time as Best Comedy Series? Make your predictions for that category below using our easy drag-and-drop menu. Average Gold Derby users just like YOU turn out to be our smartest prognosticators, so it’s important that you give us your predictions. Your picks influence our User racetrack odds, which also factor into our official combined odds.

Make all of your Emmy predictions and you could win a place of honor on our leaderboard, a starring role in next year’s Top 24 Users (the two dozen folks who do the best predicting this year’s Emmy winners), and one of three contest prizes: $500 for first place, $300 for second place, and $200 for third place. Prizes will be bestowed as gift certificates to be redeemed at Amazon. See our contest rules for more info.

More News from GoldDerby

Loading