Emmys rule hour-longs ‘Glee,’ ‘Jane the Virgin’ and ‘Shameless’ can compete as comedies

The confusion caused when the Emmys introduced new classifcation critieria last month — with hour-long shows deemed to be dramas and half hours considered comedies — has lessened with the first rulings by a review committee. Returning hour-longs “Glee” and “Shameless” and newcomer “Jane the Virgin” will be allowed to enter as comedies. At least two-thirds of the nine-person panel (five industry leaders and four appointees from the Board of Governors) approved their petitions. Still to come is a decision on another 60-minute show, “Orange is the New Black,” which won three of its 12 Emmy bids on the comedy side last year. 

Given that “Glee” has always been looked on as a laffer and was even nominated for Best Comedy Series for its first and second seasons (2010, 2011), that decision was a foregone conclusion. 

Shameless” had submitted as a drama for its first three seasons but found little love from the Emmys, other than three consecutive bids for Drama Guest Actress for Joan Cusack. Last year, it was allowed to contend as a comedy and Cusack picked up another guest bid while William H. Macy reaped a Best Comedy Actor nomination. While he lost that race to Jim Parsons who won up his fourth award for “The Big Bang Theory,” he did prevail at the recent SAG Awards. That win might have been what tipped the laugh meter in its favor. 

Likewise, “Jane the Virgin” was nominated for Best TV Comedy/Musical at the Golden Globes in January and newcomer Gina Rodriguez won TV Comedy/Musical Actress. She could well ride the wave affection for her and the show to victory, much as “Ugly Betty” star America Ferrara did in 2007 for the first season of that hour-long adaptation of a telenovela. 

We hadn’t moved any of these shows over to the drama side in our predictions center. If you had been waiting for clarification from the academy before making your predictions, get started now by forecasting Best Comedy Actress below using our easy drag-and-drop menu. 

Best predictions will win $1,000. And the 24 Users with the best scores advance to a team to compete against our Experts and Editors next year. Meet the guy who won our contest to predict the Emmys last year — and learn how he did it and how you can be our next Gold Derby superstar. Register/log in to your account so you can also compete to predict “The Walking Dead,” “Survivor,” “The Amazing Race,” “Dancing with the Stars, “American Idol” and more.

3 thoughts on “Emmys rule hour-longs ‘Glee,’ ‘Jane the Virgin’ and ‘Shameless’ can compete as comedies

  1. That sounds like it will be very helpful to William H. Macy. I’m glad. I love Shameless, and I wish they would recognize Emmy Rossum for her terrific performance on that show as well. I almost kind of wish Orange is the New Black would go drama instead. I think their actresses would have a much better chance of winning in the supporting and guest categories if they did. Season two had some great dark stuff going on in it. They might do well with nominations in comedy, but I don’t think they could win over there because their submissions aren’t going to be comedic enough. Their tapes would work a lot better as dramatic submissions. Just my personal opinion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More News from GoldDerby