Emmys outrage: What snubbed stars had the episodes to win? Tatiana Maslany, Sarah Michelle Gellar …

The Emmys are unique among award shows in that nominees have to submit sample episodes to a panel of judges in order to win their prizes. And history has shown that the system works. Lesser known character actors like Zeljko Ivanek (“Damages“), Christian Clemenson (“Boston Legal”) and Margo Martindale (“Justified“) can thwart A-list rivals because voters actually have to watch their performances.

If ‘Game of Thrones’ and Jon Hamm don’t win Emmys, our forum posters QUIT!

But nominations are still determined by a popular vote, so just getting a foot in the door is often the hardest part for stellar performers. One of the heartbreaking aspects of watching the Emmys is those times when we witness the snub of an actor who we know could have won if only they had been nominated, because we know they had the episode to do it.

We asked our forum posters who they think would have won if only they’d been nominated. CLICK HERE to join the discussion, and read some of their sample comments below. Then check out our photo gallery at the bottom of this post of some of the best performances that never got a chance to compete for Emmys.

Halo_Insider: “How I Met Your Mother‘s” last season was obviously not good, but Cristin Milioti‘s performance was pitch-perfect, and she would have made for a heck of an Emmy player with “How Your Mother Met Me” as a submission. Corey Stoll gave the greatest performance in the “House of Cards” first season, and I think he could have done well with “Chapter 11” (or even  “Chapter 5”).

WaltEagle: Idris Elba [for the episode “Middle Ground” from “The Wire”] – Supporting actor goes lead for his final episode. Reflects on past, freaks out a bunch, lots of dialogue, tragic ending.

AK1111: Parker Posey, Best Guest Actress in a Comedy Series for “Louie‘s” season three episode “Daddy’s Girlfriend, Part 2.” It was called the best acting on TV by many, and it was acting at its finest.

SamEckmann: Melissa McBride (“The Walking Dead“) will likely be snubbed AGAIN this year, despite giving one of the greatest performances on television. She has several great tapes this year, but I think “Consumed” would be the one to net her the win.

Gabriel: I really feel like Peter Sarsgaard had an unbeatable tape for “The Killing” [in 2014: “Six Minutes”]. Well, actually I guess no matter how terrific his performance was, Aaron Paul would have probably won anyway due to riding the wave of [‘Breaking Bad‘s’] big send-off at the Emmys, but as excellent as Paul was, Sarsgaard’s performance was in a different league.

Sasha: Sarah Michelle Gellar, “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” (“The Body” and some other episodes from seasons 2, 3 and 6). Tatiana Maslany, “Orphan Black” (actually any episode would do the trick).

BenitoDelicias: Jessica Walter (“Arrested Development“) could’ve won with “Queen B.” That was an outstanding episode for her.

Who deserves to win Best Drama Actress this year? Discuss in our forums

Make all your Emmy predictions and you could win a place of honor on our leaderboard, a starring role in next year’s Top 24 Users (the two dozen folks who do the best predicting this year’s Emmys line-up), and one of three contest prizes: $500 for first place, $300 for second place, and $200 for third place. Prizes will be bestowed as gift certificates to be redeemed at Amazon. See our contest rules for more info.

Average Gold Derby users just like YOU often turn out to be our smartest prognosticators, so it’s important that you give us your predictions. Your picks influence our User racetrack odds, which also factor into our official combined odds.

The Top 24 Users did the best at predicting last year’s Emmy nominations (78.55%) when competing against Gold Derby’s Editors (77.68%), all Users (74.78%) and the Experts (74.64%). Which group will be victorious this year?

Register/log in to your account (or create an account with one click using Facebook, Twitter, or Google) so you can compete to predict the Emmys, “Big Brother,” “So You Think You Can Dance,” “Survivor” and more.

More News from GoldDerby

Loading