Will Billy Crystal and Josh Gad’s ‘The Comedians’ take down ‘Modern Family’ at the Emmys?

The Comedians” is a hilarious expose of the TV biz. Billy Crystal and Josh Gad are brilliant. Finally, a show that could take down “Modern Family” at the Emmys!

This FX program premiering on April 9 before “Louie” is the funniest new show I have seen in recent years. And it has special appeal to TV academy members of all ages since it’s about a veteran comedy legend and a rising young star battling over their own TV variety series.

It reminds me of three-time Best Comedy Series champ “30 Rock” if crossed with “The Larry Sanders Show” and maybe “Curb Your Enthusiasm” (appropriate since Larry Charles has directed several episodes of that Larry David laffer and this new show). Those programs all made fun of television and the entertainment industry, just like other Emmy favorites like “The Dick Van Dyke Show,” “The Mary Tyler Moore Show,” “Murphy Brown,” “Seinfeld,” and “Frasier.”

Related: Click here to chat about ‘The Comedians’ in our forums

The pilot episode of “The Comedians” has Crystal as himself trying to convince FX (with a pretend president played by FX regular Denis O’Hare) to let him have his own show. The only way they will pick it up is to have upstart Gad as his sidekick for “The Billy and Josh Show.” Other regulars include Stephnie Weir as their producer, Matt Oberg as their head writer, and Megan Ferguson as a production assistant.

Through the first few episodes Crystal and Gad don’t get along at all, but are forced to team up. They don’t miss a chance to goose each other. Gad even tells Crystal how excited his grandparents were when they found out who his TV partner would be.

The third episode, “The Red Carpet,” is outstanding and should be on the radar for directing and writing nominations from Emmy voters. Crystal might even submit that one himself as Best Comedy Actor, trying to add to his six past trophies.

The fourth installment, “Celebrity Guest,” features two (count them TWO) EGOT winners: five-time Emmy champ Mel Brooks and composer Robert Lopez (who worked with Gad on “Frozen”).

The fifth episode, “Go for Gad,” is a real showcase for Gad in the race for Best Comedy Supporting Actor. All throughout the first nine episodes that I have previewed, including this one, he has many moments of being kidded about his career, “The Book of Mormon,” his popular character Olaf in “Frozen,” and lookalike actor Jonah Hill.

Crystal is constantly reminded of his age, his catchprase “You Look Mahvelous” from “Saturday Night Live,” the nine times hosting the Oscars, “When Harry Met Sally,” “Forget Paris,” “Analyze This,” “The Princess Bride,” and even beating David Letterman on “Battle of the Network Stars” in the 1970s.

That’s what is impressive about “The Comedians” — Crystal and Gad are fearless about making fun of themselves. Nothing is off limits. There are tons of inside jokes in a rapid-fire pace that makes you want to watch again just to catch what you missed.

Related: Discuss Emmy comedy categories in our fun forums

But it’s not all complete fun and mischief. There are some moments here and there of sympathy and reflection as the two comics get to know each other better. The episode “Billy’s Birthday” later in the season especially combines a nice mix of pathos and humor.

Start making your Emmy predictions below using our easy drag-and-drop menu for Best Comedy Series. You’ll also find many other Emmy categories in our predictions center, where you could win $1,000. And the 24 Users with the best scores advance to a team to compete against our Experts and Editors next year. Meet the guy who won our contest to predict the Emmys last year — and learn how he did it and how you can be our next Gold Derby superstar. Register/log in to your account so you can also compete to predict “The Walking Dead,” “Survivor,” “The Amazing Race,” “Dancing with the Stars, “American Idol” and more.

More News from GoldDerby

Loading