[POLL] ‘Dancing with the Stars’: Who really gave best performance on ‘Most Memorable Year’ night?

On Oct. 11, the remaining nine couples on “Dancing with the Stars” shared their most memorable years with viewers. This is usually the week where most stars recieve their highest scores and have the relief of no elimination and that’s exactly what happened. Here’s how the judges ranked the contestants:

James Hinchcliffe – 29
Marilu Henner – 27
Terra Jole – 27
Jana Kramer – 26
Laurie Hernandez – 25
Calvin Johnson – 24
Ryan Lochte – 24
Maureen McCormick – 24
Amber Rose – 24

Photo Gallery: Every winner of ‘Dancing with the Stars’ to date

Now here’s how I’d rank the competitors:

1. James Hinchliffe & Sharna Burgess (Tango)
Most Memorable Year: 2015 (when he survived car crash at Indy 500)

I’m shocked week after week by how fluid he is with each dance. I thought he had great posture, the choreography was full of content and he had the right amount of drama and attack needed for the tango.

Score: 29 out of 30 — Much deserved! James has now cemented himself as the dark horse in this competition.

2. Terra Jole & Sasha Farber (Contemporary)
Most Memorable Year: 2013 (the passing of her father)

Like James, Terra has also impressed me week after week. I love how committed she is to each dance and doesn’t dwell on her limitations as a little person to get her sympathy votes from viewers. By far her best performance of the season.

Score: 27 out of 30 — I agreed with the judges on this.

Photo Gallery: ‘DWTS’ Top 10 BEST Pro Dancers Ever

3. Jana Kramer & Gleb Savenchko (Contemporary)
Most Memorable Year: 2016 (the birth of her daughter)

In the last few weeks Jana has been overshadowed by several other competitors, but this week was her breakthrough. We finally got to see a different side of her as opposed to the sexy and sultry performances she showed us in the first couple of weeks. Hopefully, this performance will inspire Gleb to create more memorable routines for Jana.

Score: 26 out of 30 — I felt that she deserved all nines.

4. Marilu Henner & Derek Hough (Viennese Waltz)
Memorable Year: 1978 (the year her mother passed away and also the year where she booked her audition for “Taxi”)

Like Jana, Marilu needed a breakthrough week. I thought the routine was beautiful, and I agree with the judges that she looked like a different person on the dance floor.

Score: 27 out of 30 — Once again I agree with the judges.

Photo Gallery: ‘DWTS’ Top 10 WORST contestants ever

5. Laurie Hernandez & Val Chmerkovskiy (Paso Doble)
Memorable Year: 2016 (winning a gold and silver medal at this year’s Olympic Games in Rio)

I agree with judge Carrie Ann Inaba that the opening was a bit too provocative considering how young Laurie is (she’s 16). I’m not sure if it was the song choice or the pressure getting to Laurie, but the routine lacked the energy and attack required for the paso doble. The good news for her is she needed a week where she’s not on top to show viewers that she’s not always perfect so they don’t tune out or turn against her.

Score: 25 out of 30 — I agree with the judges.

6. Calvin Johnson & Lindsay Arnold (Jazz)
Memorable Year: 2012 (the year that he broke Jerry Rice’s single-season record for receiving yards)

I love how enthusiastic Calvin is with each routine every week. But like Julianne Hough and Carrie Ann mentioned, Calvin’s movements need to be much bigger, especially with a jazz routine.

Score: 24 out of 30 — The judges were pretty spot on with this score.

[POLL] ‘Dancing with the Stars’: Is Laurie Hernandez the show’s best-ever gymnast?

7. Ryan Lochte & Cheryl Burke (Contemporary)
Memorable Year: 2008 (Olympic Games in Beijing where he won his first Individual Gold Medal)

Like Derek Hough, Cheryl is great at understanding her partner and choreographing routines that make them shine. Since week one Ryan has seen his scores slowly move up week after week. His contemporary routine was his best so far. I was surprised to see how emotive he was throughout the dance.

Score: 24 out of 30 — Much deserved. His best dance yet.

8. Maureen McCormick & Artem Chigvintsev (Foxtrot)
Memorable Year: 1985 (the year she married her husband)

To me, the routine was a bit slow and reminded me more of a waltz. I think with her being the first performer of the night and being one the weaker dancers left, she may be in trouble next week.

Score: 24 out of 30 — I think she was over-scored. She deserved all sevens.

[POLL] ‘Dancing with the Stars’ past winners: Who’s the best female champion?

9, Amber Rose & Maks Chmerkovskiy (Samba)
Memorable Year: 2013 (the year her son Sebastian was born)

Amber Rose has to be one of the biggest disappointments for me this season. She hasn’t found that one dance she needs to break out from the pack. With this routine I saw that she knew all of her steps, but lacked the personality needed to sell the dance.

Score: 24 out of 30 — I disagreed with the judges on this one. Luke Maureen she deserved all sevens.

Elimination Prediction: I predict that Maureen and Artem will be sent home. The fact that they went first and their performance wasn’t as memorable puts them in greatest jeopardy of being eliminated.

Who do you think gave the best performance on “Most Memorable Year” night. Vote in our poll below, and predict what will happen next week. Gold Derby readers just like YOU often turn out to be our smartest prognosticators, so it’s important that you give us your predictions. You can continue to update and change your forecasts throughout the week, just click “Save” when you’ve settled on your choices. You’ll compete to win a $100 Amazon gift certificate, bragging rights and a place of honor on our leaderboard. Our racetrack odds change as you make your predictions, just as they do when you bet on the Emmys, Oscars, Golden Globes and more. Be sure to read our contest rules and sound off on the season of “Dancing with the Stars” in our reality TV forum.

More News from GoldDerby

Loading