‘America’s Got Talent’ 2017: Fans are livid Puddles Pity Party was eliminated — Do YOU agree?

“America’s Got Talent” 2017 fans are livid that Puddles Pity Party was eliminated on last week’s live results show. Of the thousands of people who voted in our recent poll, a whopping 86% said that the sad clown is “absolutely phenomenal.” To compare, 8% responded that they “liked him” while 6% of haters voted they’re “glad that he’s gone.” Do you agree with the majority of “AGT” fans who want Puddles to return to the reality TV show?

The singing clown was X’ed by judge Simon Cowell during his performance of “Royals” by Lorde on last week’s Quarterfinals 1 episode. Simon’s red X clearly influenced America’s vote, as Puddles failed to secure enough fan votes to make it through to the next round. “I just felt I couldn’t get in your world tonight for some reason,” Cowell explained to the teary-eyed clown.

Should the “Americas Got Talent” judges give Puddles another shot by making him the next wild card act? Below, see a sampling of readers’ comments who expressed their opinions about Puddles Pity Party, and then sound off with your thoughts at the bottom of this post.

Marlene Williams: “I think Puddles achieved so much more with exposure than just winning a Vegas contract. He will not be looking for work!”

Eileen Cook-Yemmo: “I was disappointed that Puddles was eliminated. Like Simon I don’t like clowns, but I felt differently about Puddles. He was very talented with his singing.”

Lisa Reese: “1000% agreed. BRING PUDDLES BACK.”

Mollie Gibbs-Garner: “Puddles is a modern day Barry White if you ask me. My Husband and I were blown away when he first appeared on ‘AGT’ because we thought everyone already knew who Puddles was! We have been true fans for a while now.”

mjmiriam: “I’m sad, I love Puddles!!!!! But I have to say that I didn’t like his choice of song. I also felt it was hard to connect with him.”

Susan Blanc: “Bring back puddles..Simon never liked him from the start..he has an aversion to clowns..this man has anot amazing voice.”

Be sure to make your predictions so that the contestants can see how they’re faring in our racetrack odds. You can keep changing your predictions until just before the live shows air every Tuesday on NBC. You’ll compete to win bragging rights and a $100 Amazon gift certificate. See our contest rules and sound off with other fans in our reality TV forum. Read more Gold Derby entertainment news.

More News from GoldDerby

Loading