Who sang ‘Beauty and the Beast’ song better: Angela Lansbury or Emma Thompson? [POLL]

We’ll admit it. This poll is cruel. Asking “Beauty and the Beast” fans to name whose rendition of the classic title song is better — Angela Lansbury‘s 1991 version or Emma Thompson‘s 2017 tune — is like asking Josh Gad‘s Lefou to pick his favorite Golden Girl. But nevertheless, we invite you to vote in our “Beauty and the Beast” showdown poll below and then sound off in the comments section defending your choice.

Sign up to get Gold Derby’s free newsletter
with experts’ latest predictions and breaking news

Lansbury’s iconic 1991 rendition of the love ballad sung by teapot Mrs. Potts prevailed at the Oscars and the Golden Globes for Best Song for musician Alan Menken and lyricist Howard Ashman. The Broadway legend sang a portion of the song on the 1992 Academy Awards telecast before Celine Dion and Peabo Bryson came out to finish the performance (watch above).

Thompson took over the role of Mrs. Potts in the 2017 remake and belted out the popular ballad during the film’s waltz sequence (listen below). The song won’t be eligible for the 2018 Oscars as it’s no longer an original tune, but there are three new songs that could contend for awards consideration: “Evermore,” “How Does A Moment Last Forever” and “Days in the Sun.”

Dish ‘Beauty and the Beast’ with Hollywood insiders in our notorious forums

The “Beauty and the Beast” live-action remake is a bonafide blockbuster, breaking past the $770 million mark worldwide on Thursday over the course of only two weeks. That impressive total puts this 2017 version far ahead of the 1991 animated Disney classic, which made $425 million in all, or about $725 million when you account for inflation.

Oscar champ Bill Condon (“Gods and Monsters”) directs the current version that stars Emma Watson as Belle and Dan Stevens as the Beast. While the box office is to be commended, the critics’ reviews haven’t been nearly as successful, with a score of 74 at Rotten Tomatoes and 64 at MetaCritic. Vote in our “Beauty and the Beast” song poll now.

20 thoughts on “Who sang ‘Beauty and the Beast’ song better: Angela Lansbury or Emma Thompson? [POLL]

    1. She has a Beautiful voice. The song sounded amazing. I can’t explain how I felt when she sang the song but she gave me goose bumps thats for sure#!!
      Awesome job!

    2. I agree. I don’t get the 75% for Lansbury. She was way off-key, and at times she wasn’t even singing so much as talking/giggling. She may have had a good (Broadway-style voice in her prime, but she was way past it when she sang this. Thompson was actually hitting the notes, and her high notes were unexpectedly nice.

    1. It is a difficult choice, but I think I have to go with Angela. ???? The two renditions are both superb, but being the original, there is a warmth in Angela’s version that is not quite matched in Emma’s version.????????????

  1. Angela Lansbury not only sang the song beautifully, she added her incomparable acting ability enabling one to picture Mrs. Potts as she did it.

  2. Angela Lansbury no question and should never have been one! Some things are embedded in your memories and newer versions just hold a candle to it.

  3. My preference is for Angela Lansbury’s version, but I really thought Emma Thompson did her justice, so it was a hard choice for me. Controversial opinion, I know.

  4. This is a song that really demands a sincere heart. Angela has this in spades. Emma is a terrific professional, but her offering lacks heart. Nostalgia. Depth. Too detached to touch.

  5. Angela made it sound so homely… she giggles all the time.. so sweet. it was so peaceful. Her voice gave so much of warmness. So like a grandma.Even her character was like one. Her song perfectly fit her character and as well Belle’s. But in 2017, Emma made it like a fairy tale.It was so beautiful,enchanted and elegant.Perfectly fit Emma Watson’s character. Just both voices!

  6. Angela Lansbury has an operatic music background , And ,She DID sing the song as a mother who would sing for someone who she really loves and watches over him. Grammie Bonnie

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More News from GoldDerby

Loading