Emmy episode analysis: Gerald McRaney (‘This Is Us’) could win overdue trophy as grief-stricken widow

After a long career on television in acclaimed dramas like “Deadwood” and “Justified,” as well as headlining the long-running series “Simon & Simon” and “Major Dad,” Gerald McRaney has finally received overdue recognition at the 2017 Emmys. His first career nomination comes in the Drama Guest Actor category for his role on NBC’s “This Is Us,” which received a total of 11 nominations, including Best Drama Series for its debut season.

McRaney is nominated for his recurring role as Dr. Nathan Katowski, an elderly widower who delivers the children of Rebecca and Jack Pearson (Mandy Moore and Emmy nominee Milo Ventimiglia). His performance in the episode “The Big Day” has been submitted to Emmy voters. Watch our recent interview with Gerald McRaney.

In the lead-up to the birth of Rebecca and Jack’s children, Dr. K is shown struggling with the death of his wife. Even though she has been gone for over a year, he still talks to her at the dining room table, and still keeps all of her possessions in their home. Later, when his son and daughter-in-law encourage him to move on, he lashes out at them, threatening to never speak to them if they ever broach the subject again. He then brings flowers to his wife’s grave, and tearfully confesses that he’s not sure if he can, or even wants, to go on without her.

After the birth of the Pearson children, Dr. K suddenly realizes that he has to make a new start, and he gets rid of his wife’s belongings, telling her that he believes she would want him to move on. Will “The Bid Day” help McRaney win his first Emmy Award? Let’s examine the pros and cons:

PROS

McRaney gets to display a wide range of emotions in this episode. We see him struggle to function on his own, yet we understand his anger when he chastises his son for telling him to move on. In the heartbreaking scene at the cemetery, we see a man who seems to be contemplating suicide rather than go on without his wife. McRaney’s tearful breakdown is all the more impactful when you consider that he has often played the heavy throughout his career, and the deep emotion in his performance reveals a range that we often have not seen in his previous work.

Grief and loss are universal emotions, and as a result, McRaney’s performance almost demands the audience’s sympathy. Despite not being a central character in the series, Nathan becomes a character you root for, and none of that would be possible without McRaney’s beautifully modulated work.

The Drama Guest Actor category in particular often rewards veteran actors such as Paul Winfield, James Whitmore, William Shatner, Joe Morton and John Lithgow. And after 40 years of consistent good work on television, Emmy voters may feel that McRaney is long overdue for recognition.

SEE 2017 Emmy nominations list: See all the nominees

CONS

McRaney faces competition from two other “This Is Us” actors, Denis O’Hare and Bryan Tyree Henry. With three nominees from the same show in this category, the possibility of vote-splitting could siphon away crucial votes from McRaney.

This is a category that likes to reward big performances. Despite the emotional subject matter, McRaney’s performance may be seen as too interior for Emmy voters who might prefer to reward a larger, broader performance.

Be sure to make your Emmy predictions so that Hollywood insiders can see how their TV shows and performers are faring in our Emmy odds. You can keep changing your predictions until just before winners are announced on September 17. And join in the fierce debate over the 2017 Emmys taking place right now with Hollywood insiders in our TV forums. Read more Gold Derby entertainment news.

More News from GoldDerby

Loading