2014 Goldderby Rankings

Home // Forums // Movies // 2014 Goldderby Rankings

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 120 total)
Created
3 years ago
Last Reply
3 years ago
119
replies
2135
views
29
users
40
21
10
  • ETPhoneHome
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jan 3rd, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175022

    Hello all,

    For the past few years, we’ve had this annual event, the Goldderby rankings, ordinarily organised by pacinofan. After trying to contact them and noticing that it’s been a while since they’ve posted anything on the forums, I decided to start this, and when/if they come back, I will hand the reins over to them. I just want to make sure this event gets carried on, so here it is!

    In case you don’t know, the Goldderby Rankings are based on the grades provided by users for all the films that came out in the past year, compiled into a top 10 list based on an average given to each film. Past winners include: “Persepolis”, “WALL-E”, “The Hurt Locker”, “The Social Network”, and “Her”.

    The film grades will be awarded points in the following way:

    A+ = 5
    A = 4.5
    A- = 4
    B+ = 3.75
    B = 3.5
    B- = 3
    C+ = 2.75
    C = 2.5
    C- = 2
    D+ = 1.75
    D = 1.5
    D- = 1.25
    F = 1

    Each weekend, the grades will be calculated, and on Sunday, I’ll reveal a running top 10 list. The event will close on February 28th, and the results will be announced on March 1st, giving everyone over a month to see as many films as they can. Grades can be posted in this thread or PM’d to me. This event is open to all Goldderby members who have joined before 2015, or who have posted at least 50 times on the site (which should be fairly easy to get in the next month if you’re not already there).

    A film must have at least 5 ratings in order to appear on the rankings, and I do ask that if you are adding ratings to your list, you either post it to the thread, or somehow mark the change in your post, to ensure I don’t miss it. That’s it, so get to viewing and send in those lists!

    Reply
    ETPhoneHome
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jan 3rd, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175024

    To demonstrate, here are my rankings:

    22 Jump Street – B+
    3 Days to Kill – C+
    300: Rise of an Empire – B-
    Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good Very Bad Day – B-
    The Amazing Spider Man 2 – C+

    American Sniper – B-
    A Million Ways to Die in the West – C+

    Begin Again – A-
    Big Eyes – B+
    Big Hero 6 – B+
    Birdman – A-
    Boyhood – A

    Calvary – B
    Captain America: The Winter Soldier – A-
    Dawn of the Planet of the Apes – A-
    Devil’s Knot – B
    Divergent – B
    The Double – A-
    Draft Day – B
    Edge of Tomorrow – B+
    Elsa and Fred – B
    Enemy – A

    The Fault in Our Stars – B-
    Foxcatcher – B
    Frank – A+
    Fury – B+
    Godzilla – B+
    Gone Girl – A-
    The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies – C
    Horns – A-
    How to Train Your Dragon 2 – A-

    The Grand Budapest Hotel – A+
    Ida – B-
    The Imitation Game – B+
    The Immigrant – B-
    Interstellar – B+
    The Interview – C+
    Into the Woods – B
    Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit – B-
    John Wick – A-
    The Judge – B-
    Land Ho! – F

    The Lego Movie – A 
    Let’s Be Cops – D+
    Lucy – B-
    Maleficent – B-
    The Maze Runner – B+
    Mommy – A-
    The Monuments Men – C-
    My Old Lady – B-
    Neighbours – B+
    Nightcrawler – A+
    Noah – C

    Non-Stop – B+
    Nymphomaniac Vol. 1 – B+
    Ouija – C-
    The Railway Man – B
    Robocop – C+
    Selma – A
    The Skeleton Twins – B
    Snowpiercer – A
    St. Vincent – A-
    Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles – D
    The Theory of Everything – A
    Transcendence – C-
    Trans4mers: Age of Extinction – C-
    The Trip to Italy – A-
    Under the Skin – C
    X-Men: Days of Future Past – A
    What if? – B
    Whiplash – A+ 

    ReplyCopy URL
    vinny
    Participant
    Joined:
    May 20th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175025

    I tried to see as many movies as I could this year but none were A+ to me. Only one F  though so thats good.

      Paranormal Activity: The Marked Ones – C
    Whiplash – B+ 
    The Judge – B
    Gone Girl – A
    Annabelle – A
    Inherent Vice – B
    Fury – B+
    Interstellar – A
    Big Hero 6 – A
    The Book of Life – A
    Ouija – D
    American Sniper – B+
    Selma – A
    Dumb and Dumber to – F
    Hunger Games Mockingjay part 1 – B+
    Wild – B+
    Into the Woods – B+
    Exodus – C+
    The Hobbit 3: A
    The Interview – C
    Night at the Museum 3 – C+    
    Horrible Bosses 2 – B  
    Big Eyes – B+ 
     St. Vincent – B    
    HTTYD2 – A
    X-Men Days of Future past – A
    The Fault in Our Stars – A
    Blended – C
    Foxcatcher – A
    Malefient- C
    A Milion Ways to Die in the West – C
    22 Jump Street – B-
    Jersey Boys – B-
    Transformers AOE – D
    Tammy – C+
    Guardians of the Galaxy – A
    The Purge Anarchy – A
    Lucy – A
    Magic in the Monnlight – B
    Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles – C+
    Get On Up – A
    the Expendables 3 – D
    The 100 foot journey – B+
    The Giver – B
    Lets Be Cops – A
    Birdman: A
    The November Man – C
    The Boxtrolls – C+                      
    The Monuments Men – B
    Mr. Peabody and Sherman – B+
    3 Days to Kill – C+
    Winter’s Tale – D
    Endless Love – D
    Pompeii – D
    300 Rise of an Empire – C
    The Grand Budapest Hotel – A
    Noah – C
    Neighbors – C
    Need for Speed – B
    Muppets most wanted – B+
    Captain America: The Winter Soilder – A
    Rio 2 – A
    Sabotage – B
    Veronica Mars – B                
    Non-Stop – B
    That Awkward Moment – C+
    Robocop – D
    The Lego Movie – B+    
    Jack Ryan: Shadow Recruit – B
    Devil’s Due – B
    Divergent – B
    Draft Day – B
    The Quiet Ones – B
    Transendence – D
    The Amazing Spiderman 2 – B
    Heaven is Real – B
    The Other Woman – D
    Brick Mansions – B+
    Million Dollar Arm – B+
    A Haunted House 2 – D
    Godzilla – C
    Walk of Shame – C 
    Ride Along – C+
    Love Is Strange – B+
    Wish I Was Here – B
    Boyhood – A
    I, Frankenstein – C       
    The Legend of Hercules – B
    The Nut Job – B-
     The Drop – B
    tHE mAZE runner – A
    A Walk Among the Tombstones – C
    The Theory of Everything – A
    The Imitation Game – A    

    ReplyCopy URL
    Cheshire
    Participant
    Joined:
    Nov 16th, 2012
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175026

    “Life Itself”– A
    “The Grand Budapest Hotel”A
    “Into the Woods”
    – A

    “Gone Girl”
    – A-
    “The Imitation Game”
    – A-
    “Dawn of the Planet of th Apes”
    – A-
    “Noah”
    – A-
    “The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 1”
    – A-
    “Maleficent”– A-
    “Muppets Most Wanted”
    – A-
    “X- Men: Days of Future Past”– A-
    “Captain America: The Winter Soldier”
    – A-

    “Foxcatcher”– B+
    “Big Hero 6”
    – B+
    “22 Jump Street”
    – B+
    “The Book of Life”– B+
    “How to Train Your Dragon 2”– B+

    “Interstellar”
    – B
    “The LEGO Movie”
    – B
    “Guardians of the Galaxy”– B

    “American Sniper”
    B-
    “Under the Skin”
    – B-

    “Exodus: Gods & Kings”– C+
    “Labor Day”
    – C+
    “The Fault in Our Stars”
    – C+
    “The Amazing Spider- Man 2”– C+

    “Godzilla”
    – C 

    “The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies”
    – C-
    “Sabotage”
    – C-

    “That Awkward Moment”
    – D+
    “Divergent”– D+

    “Pompeii”
    – D

    “The Legend of Hercules”
    – D-

    “Let’s Be Cops”
    – F
    “A Haunted House 2”
    – F 

    ReplyCopy URL
    Josh Labron
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jun 27th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175027

    Some of 2014’s films till haven’t been released over here in the U.K. yet (and some I just never got around to seeing). But these are all the ones I’ve seen so far.

    Dawn Of The Planet Of The Apes – A 
    The Theory Of Everything – A 

    Birdman – A-
    Captain American: The Winter Soldier – A- 
    Gone Girl – A-
    Guardians Of The Galaxy – A-
    Interstellar – A- 
    Pride – A- 
    The Boxtrolls – A- 
    The Drop – A- 
    The Hunger Games: Mockingjay – Part 1 – A- 
    The Imitation Game – A- 
    X-Men: Days Of Future Past – A 

    American Sniper – B+
    Into The Woods – B+  
    Neighbors – B+ 
    Paddington – B+ 
    The Fault In Our Stars – B+ 
    The Guest – B+

    22 Jump Street – B 
    Maleficent – B 
    The Hobbit: The Battle Of The Five Armies – B 
    The Inbetweeners Movie 2 – B
    The Maze Runner – B  
    What If – B 

    Earth To Echo – B-  
    Edge Of Tomorrow – B- 
    Occulus – B- 
    The Amazing-Spiderman 2 – B- 

    Tammy – C 

    Jack Ryan: Shadows Recruit – C- 

    Transformers: Age Of Extinction – D 

    ReplyCopy URL
    babypook
    Participant
    Joined:
    Nov 4th, 2010
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175028

    I didnt keep up with my film list this year. I stopped about a third of the way through. I’ll do my best to participate, remember everything I’ve seen, and get back to you.

    Thanks for taking pacinofan’s initiative ETPH.

    ReplyCopy URL
    Josh Labron
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jun 27th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175029

    Add:

    B+ – The Grand Budapest Hotel 

    ReplyCopy URL
    babypook
    Participant
    Joined:
    Nov 4th, 2010
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175030

    Here’s my list. I’ll fill in the rest in the next few days.

    The Monkey King, C

    Monuments Men C

    Noah B

    The Lego Movie A

    Divergent C

    RoboCop C+

    Under the Skin A-

    Snowpiercer A

    Grand Budapest Hotel A

    Pompeii C+

     

    300 Rise of an Empire B-

    Non-Stop C+

    Le Week-end B+

    Mr Peabody and Sherman B-

    Cesar Chavez B

    Dom Hemingway B-

    Ernest and Celestine B+

    Enemy A-

    Gabrielle A-

    Winter’s Tale C-

     

    Paranormal Activity: The Marked Ones D

    Sabotage B

    The Railway Man C+

    Amazing Spiderman C-

    Transcendence C-

    Captain America A-

    The Wind Rises A

    Heaven is For Real C-

    Brick Mansions B-

    Bears B+

     

    Rio 2 B

    3 Days to Kill B+

    Oculus B-

    Jerusalem A-

    (Bad) Neighbours C+

    Mistaken for Strangers B

    Godzilla B

    Palo Alto B

    The Immigrants B+

    X-Men: Days of Future Past A-

     

    The Grand Seduction A

    Chef B

    I Origins B+

    The Purge:Anarchy C-

    How to Train Your Dragon 2 B+

    A Million Ways to Die in the West B-

    22 Jump Street B

    Belle A

    A Most Wanted Man A

     

    Dawn of the Planet of the Apes B+

    Hercules B- (but I’m penning in Joseph Fiennes for a Razzie)

    Words and Pictures B-

    Lucy B+

    Wish I was Here C+

    Kick B+

    The Other Woman D

    And So it Goes C+

    Life Itself A

    Edge of Tomorrow A

     

    Maleficent B

    Sex Tape D-

    Joe B+

    Only Lovers Left Alive B

    For A Woman A-

    Fed Up A

    Under the Skin A

    Get On Up A-

    Guardians of The Galaxy A+

    Boyhood A+

     

    The Giver C

    The Hundred-Foot Journey B

    Old Boy C+

    Predestination A+

     

    ReplyCopy URL
    AMG
    Participant
    Joined:
    Sep 20th, 2012
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175031

    Gone Girl = A+
    The Theory of Everything = A+

    Interstellar = A
    Unbroken  = A
    Whiplash = A

    Birdman = A-
    The Imitation Game = A-
    Nightcrawler = A-

    Big Hero 6 = B+
    Boyhood = B+
    Fury = B+
    Wild = B+

    American Sniper = B
    A Most Violent Year = B
    Begin Again = B

    How To Train Your Dragon 2 = B-
    The Inbetweeners 2 = B-
    Pride = B-
    The Skeleton Twins = B-
    St Vincent = B- 
    Still Alice = B- 

    22 Jump Street = C
    Cake = C
    Dawn of the Planet of the Apes = C
    The Disappearance of Eleanor Rigby: Them = C
    Edge of Tomorrow = C
    The Fault in Our Stars = C
    The Homesman = C
    Two Days, One Night = C

    The Amazing Spiderman 2 = C- 
    The Drop = C-
    Into The Woods = C-
    The Judge = C-
    Mr Turner = C-

    What If = D+

    Foxcatcher = D
    The LEGO Movie = D

    The Grand Budapest Hotel = D- 

    Noah = F

    ReplyCopy URL
    DominicCobb
    Participant
    Joined:
    Nov 12th, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175032

    Glad to see someone picking this up. Thanks ETPH.

    Here’s what I’ve seen so far: 

    Interstellar A+

    The Grand Budapest Hotel A
    Whiplash A
    Boyhood A
    Birdman 
    A
    Inherent Vice A
    Gone Girl A
    The Lego Movie A

    Wild A-
    The Imitation Game
     A-
    Selma A-
    Dawn of the Planet of the Apes A-
    Snowpiercer A-
    Foxcatcher A-

    Under the Skin
     B+
    The Double B+
    Nightcrawler 
    B+
    Ida B+
    Blue Ruin B+
    Noah
     B+
    Guardians of the Galaxy B+
    Captain America: The Winter Soldier B+
    X-Men: Days of Future Past B+
    Locke B+
    Enemy 
    B+

    22 Jump Street B
    The Raid 2 B
    Filth B
    Fury B
    Top Five B

    The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies 
    B-
    Big Hero 6 
    B-
    The Theory of Everything 
    B-
    Neighbors
     B-
    Willow Creek B-

    Robocop
     C+
    Godzilla C+

    American Sniper 
    C
    Unbroken 
    C

    The Amazing Spider-Man 2 C-
    Cuban Fury C- 

    ReplyCopy URL
    Tyler The Awesome Guy
    Participant
    Joined:
    Nov 19th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175033

    Below is a list of all the films Tyler the Awesome Guy has seen in 2014 and a rating of what I thought of the film. If a film is off the list, it’s likely that I decided to not see it.

    The Amazing Spider-Man 2 D+
    American Sniper B+
    Begin Again B
    Big Hero 6 C+
    Birdman A+
    The Boxtrolls B-
    Boyhood A+
    Captain America: The Winter Soldier C-
    Citizenfour B+
    Dawn of the Planet of the Apes B+
    Divergent D
    Edge of Tomorrow B
    The Fault in Our Stars B+
    Force Majeure B+
    Foxcatcher B+
    Fury C
    The Giver B
    Godzilla D+
    Gone Girl B+
    The Grand Budapest Hotel A
    Guardians of the Galaxy B
    Hercules B
    The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies C
    The Homesman C+
    How To Train Your Dragon 2 A
    Ida B
    The Imitation Game B
    Inherent Vice B-
    Interstellar A-
    Into the Woods B-
    The Judge C-
    The LEGO Movie B+
    Leviathan B
    Life Itself B-
    Maleficent C-
    The Monuments Men C-
    A Most Violent Year B
    Mr. Peabody & Sherman C
    Mr. Turner C
    Neighbors B
    Night at the Museum: Secret of the Tomb B-
    Nightcrawler B+
    Noah D
    Obvious Child C+
    The Penguins of Madagascar B-
    Planes: Fire & Rescue D
    Rio 2 C
    St. Vincent B
    Selma B
    Snowpiercer B-
    Song of the Sea B+
    Still Alice C+
    The Tale of Princess Kaguya B
    Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles C-
    The Theory of Everything B
    Transformers: Age of Extinction D-
    Two Days, One Night B
    Unbroken B
    Under the Skin B-
    Virunga B+
    Whiplash B+
    Wild B
    X-Men: Days of Future Past B+ 

    ReplyCopy URL
    ETPhoneHome
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jan 3rd, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175034

    Thanks for submitting your rankings everyone! I’ve tabulated the results so far, and we already have 27 films with enough grades to be on the final list. The results are also very close, so it could all change with just a few more ballots. Great start.

    ReplyCopy URL
    AviChristiaans
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jul 26th, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175035

     
    Manakamana A+
    Winter Sleep A+

    Song of the Sea A
    The Badadook A
    Birdman A
    Two Days One Night A
    The Strange Little Cat A
    Goodbye To Language A

    The Overnighters A-
    Calvary A-
    Wild
    A-
    American Sniper A-
    The Immigrant A-
    Beloved Sisters A-
    The Tale of Princess Kaguya A-
    Leviathan A-

    Norte, The End Of History B+
    Guardians of the Galaxy B+
    Wild Tales B+
    Ida B+
    B+
    Selma B+
    Whiplash B+
    Nightcrawler B+
    Obvious Child B+
    How to Train Your Dragon 2 B+
    Unbroken B+
    Interstellar B+
    Snowpiercer
    B+
    Virunga B+
    Only Lovers Left Alive B+
    Life Itself B+
    Mr Turner B+ 

     


    Chef B
    The Grand Budapest Hotel B
    The Raid 2 B
    Fury B
    The Imitation GameB
    Gone Girl B
    Under the Skin B
    Top Five B
    Nymphomaniac Vol. 1 B
    Foxcatcher

     

    Dawn Of The Planet Of The Apes B-
    The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies B-
    The Theory of Everything B-
    Boyhood B-
    Big Hero 6 B-
    The Fault In Our Stars B-

     

    Maleficent C+
    Robocop
    C+
    Godzilla C+
    Noah C+
    Neighbors
    My Old Lady C+

    The Amazing Spider-Man 2 Cuban Fury C-

    The Interview F

     

    ReplyCopy URL
    ETPhoneHome
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jan 3rd, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175036

    Just confirming a couple things that I’m assuming:

    Babypook, I’m assuming ‘The Immigrants’ is in fact The Immigrant, and not some film I haven’t heard of?

    AviChristiaans, I’m assuming that you’re giving Neighbors a C+, given its position in the block?

    Not trying to nitpick, I just want to make sure I’m being as accurate as possible!

    ReplyCopy URL
    Josh Labron
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jun 27th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #175037

    I saw Boyhood today, so I’m adding:

    Boyhood – A-  

    ReplyCopy URL
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 120 total)
Reply To: 2014 Goldderby Rankings

You can use BBCodes to format your content.
Your account can't use Advanced BBCodes, they will be stripped before saving.

Similar Topics
Alex Meyer - Aug 18, 2017
Movies
Andrew D - Aug 17, 2017
Movies