September 28, 2014 at 9:03 pm #162284
Obviously I’m not talking about Mo’Nique. She was the deserving winner. But the rest of the line-up could’ve been soooo much better.
The double set of nominees, Anna Kendrick and Vera Farmiga should’ve been replaced by the far superior performances of Diane Kruger and Melanie Laurent, in a far superior movie.
The Nine spot should’ve gone to much better Marion Cotillard
And the last spot should’ve gone to another co-star of a Best Actor nominee: Julianne Moore!
Now that would have a hell of a line up!
Discuss!September 28, 2014 at 9:40 pm #162286
Monique did tower above her competition, but the Up In The Air girls were deserving nominees. Cruz was fine, but it felt repetitive and one dimensional, although watchable all the same. Gyllenhaal was mediocre, but I”ve seen worse. Moore was quite good, but a win would have been too much, given how short the role was. Never saw Inglorious Bastards though.September 28, 2014 at 9:47 pm #162287
My nominees that year
Mo’Nique – Precious
Vera Farmiga – Up in the Air
Julianne Moore – A Single Man
Melanie Laurent – Inglorious Basterds
Betty White – The ProposalSeptember 28, 2014 at 10:25 pm #162288
I personally consider Melanie Laurent the lead of IB (she’s actually my personal winner…). In supporting I would have nominated Cotillard, Kendrick, Kruger, Moore and Monique with Monique taking it.September 28, 2014 at 10:25 pm #162289
I personally consider Melanie Laurent the lead of IB (she’s actually my personal winner…). In supporting I would have nominated Cotillard, Kendrick, Kruger, Moore and Monique with Monique taking it.September 29, 2014 at 4:19 am #162290
I don’t think I’ve seen enough movies from 2009 to make a definitive lineup, but I’ll tell you one thing.
Teri Hatcher in Coraline = ROBBED.September 29, 2014 at 5:51 am #162291
– Moore deserved a nomination.
– Cruz did absolutely nothing in that movie other than look beautiful. Biggest wasted spot ever.
– I adore Vera Farmiga and it makes me really happy she has an oscar nomination, but I was very underwhelmed by her in this.
– Laurents omission is ridiculous, just ridiculous.
– Kendrick was reall really great, but I wonder, had there been better competition I might have skiped on her nomination.September 29, 2014 at 6:28 am #162292
I personally consider Melanie Laurent the lead of IB (she’s actually my personal winner…). In supporting I would have nominated Cotillard, Kendrick, Kruger, Moore and Monique with Monique taking it.
While her role is impactful, her storyline is almost entirely apart from the rest of the movie. She is in the beginning and end, but otherwise separated. It’s kind of a De Niro in the Godfather performance. You could argue he was a lead, but he was considered supporting.
Come participate in this year's Goldderby Rankings! http://www.goldderby.com/forum/movies/2017-goldderby-rankings/September 29, 2014 at 6:30 am #162293
Marion was the lead for her movie but I understand why people would say supporting but she campaigned for lead and was nominated at the Globes for Lead. If anyone from Nine should have been nominated for Nine I would have picked Judi Dench as the comic relief of her movie. Kendrick earned her nomination Farmiga was a nice one but nothing amazing. Gyllenhaal deserved her nomination but she was definitly lead. My 5 with knowing Cotillard is lead would have been:
Anna Kendrick “Up in the Air”
Maggie Gyllenhaal “Crazy Heart”
Paula Patton “Precious”
Mariah Carrey “Precious”
September 29, 2014 at 6:33 am #162294
Yes, if two supporting actresses from the same film were going to be nominated, it should have been the two from Inglourious Basterds instead of the two Up in the Air ladies. But I guess all 4 could have gotten in if you remove Maggie Gyllenhaal and Penelope Cruz. Still, Melanie Laurent’s snub in particular is really sad.September 29, 2014 at 7:38 am #162295
My personal choices were:
1. Mo’Nique, ‘Precious’
2. Melanie Laurent, ‘Inglourious Basterds’
3. Marion Cotillard, ‘Nine’
4. Anna Kendrick, ‘Up In The Air’
5. Vera Farmiga, ‘Up In The Air’
Close Calls (EDIT: I forgot Ms. Moore! Corrected it.):
6. Diane Kruger, ‘Inglourious Basterds’
7. Julianne Moore ‘A Single Man’
8. Paula Patton, ‘Precious’
9. BeyoncÃ© Knowles, ‘Cadillac Records’
10. PenÃ©lope Cruz, ‘Nine’September 29, 2014 at 9:17 am #162296
I don’t think they are “the worst”. Everyone’s opinion is different. I just started to get into my Oscar interest after the 2009 nominees came in, so I don’t know who was in contention before, but I thought Natalie Portman deserved a nomination for Brothers.
FYC: Ready Player One. Sound Editing, Sound Mixing, Visual Effects, Original Score, Production Design, Director and BEST PICTURE (make it happen Oscars!!)September 29, 2014 at 9:19 am #162297
Mo’Nique winning makes up for most (if not all) of the deficiencies of this category. There are far worse supporting actress lineups than this one. But if I were to change this category up, I’d start by switching Penélope Cruz for Marion Cotillard for “Nine” if someone had to be nominated there. I would have only nominated Vera Farmiga from “Up in the Air” (nothing against Anna Kendrick). Maggie Gyllenhaal would have been so out for “Crazy Heart.” Replace her with either Julianne Moore for “A Single Man” or Samantha Morton for “The Messenger.” Then I’d have to have one of the ladies from “Inglorious Basterds” included. Mélanie Laurent had the more substantive role, but Diane Kruger surprised me more (and would continue to surprise me with her acting chops later on television with “The Bridge”). I think in the end, Laurent’s role was more iconic, so I’ll go with her of the two. Moore was probably number six on the real ballot due to status/name recognition, Cotillard campaigned in lead, and the “IB” ladies being lesser known. On another day, I might have swapped Cotillard with Morton.
Marion Cotillard, “Nine”
Vera Farmiga, “Up in the Air”
Mélanie Laurent, “Inglorious Basterds”
Mo’Nique, “Precious: Based on the Novel Push by Sapphire” (WIN!)
Julianne Moore, “A Single Man”September 29, 2014 at 9:23 am #162298
Anna Kendrick, Up In The Air
Vera Farmiga, Up in The Air
Mélanie Laurent, Inglorius Basterds
Julianne Moore, A Single Man
How it should have been imo.September 29, 2014 at 10:04 am #162299
Actually I thought the best supporting actress of 2009 apart from Mo’Nique was the late Susanne Lothar in The White Ribbon. Haven’t seen Nine or Crazy Heart (but I’ve seen a clip of Day-Lewis in the former, and boy was he terrible); both Farmiga and Kendrick were deserving.
My personal lineup from what I’ve seen:
Vera Farmiga Up in the Air
Anna Kendrick Up in the Air
Susanne Lothar The White Ribbon
Julianne Moore A Single Man
Melanie Laurent is borderline lead in Inglourious Basterds, I think.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.