Kelly Clarkson Vs. Pink

[kingofrapmusic17Participant Joined: Aug 2nd, 2013 Topics: 100 Posts: 727 View Predictions]

#403908

Who’s the better entertainer (sales, popularity, etc.)? I did this because of similar voices, music production, etc.

Reply

[Tyler The Awesome GuyParticipant Joined: Nov 19th, 2011 Topics: 355 Posts: 6691 View Predictions]

#403910

Clarkson is in my mind more talented, even though P!nk is really, really good too.

ReplyCopy URL

[Final2Participant Joined: Apr 4th, 2013 Topics: 80 Posts: 2951 View Predictions]

#403911

I don’t get this one. They’re two different to compare.

ReplyCopy URL

[smurty11Participant Joined: Sep 7th, 2014 Topics: 15 Posts: 628 View Predictions]

#403912

I agree with Final2, they are very different artists. It would make more sense to compare her to Avril or Christina.

But what the hell:
P!nk has been around longer, but Clarkson has the better voice. Kelly is more consistent with singles, albums and songwriting than P!nk.
I also think P!nk has as much versatility as Kelly’s. Just look on Youtube and you’ll understand what I mean.

She’s also never had a well-received album other than M!sundastood, Kelly’s had consistently well-received albums and singles.

ReplyCopy URL

[GucciMember Joined: Nov 7th, 2010 Topics: 12 Posts: 12658 View Predictions]

#403913

Kelly Clarkson is the better vocalist.  However, P!nk is the better artist and songwriter with the much stronger catalog of music.

ReplyCopy URL

[Boidiva02Participant Joined: May 24th, 2011 Topics: 177 Posts: 3445 View Predictions]

#403914

I think Kelly has probably has the bigger sales and is likely considered more popular; but I think Pink is the better entertainer.   Kelly IMHO is sort of manufactured whereas Pink seems to be a genuine artist with creative instincts.        Overall, I think Pink is probably the more verstatile performer.   Kelly is sort of one-note.

ReplyCopy URL

[Boidiva02Participant Joined: May 24th, 2011 Topics: 177 Posts: 3445 View Predictions]

#403915

Boidiva02 wrote:

I agree with Final2, they are very different artists. It would make more sense to compare her to Avril or Christina.

She’s also never had a well-received album other than M!sundastood, Kelly’s had consistently well-received albums and singles.

That is a fallacy.  “I’m Not Dead” was fairly well received; as was “The Truth About Love”.   Both got very strong critical response.     

ReplyCopy URL

[PoweRParticipant Joined: Sep 27th, 2011 Topics: 74 Posts: 3618 View Predictions]

#403916

P!nk is better than Kelly Clarkson. And P!nk has more acclaimed/generally liked albums than Kelly does.

ReplyCopy URL

[Nawaha86Participant Joined: Sep 24th, 2013 Topics: 7 Posts: 696 View Predictions]

#403917

This is probs the hardest 2 you couldve put H2H for me as they my 2 favourite artists of the past 10yrs…….where do u begin with each?????

P!NK–probs the best entertainer ive seen in a long time when it comes to her concerts, whilst her earlier albums may not have been “critically acclaimed” they arew good albums with some of the best songs not being released as singles. IMO i feel like she has stayed true to who she is as an artist and her songs are diverse (listen to the newalbum she has done under You+Me)

 

KELLY–since becoming more her own person and not being being what American Idol wanted her to be i feel like she is up there as one of the greatest femal artists of all time….albums/songs have had mixed reviews throughout her career but the one thing she holds over every other artist in history is the fact she i the only artist to win  BEST POP VOCAL ALBUM twice in their career, she has lso shown her diversity by crossing over and enjoying success on the country charts

ReplyCopy URL

[vinnyParticipant Joined: May 20th, 2011 Topics: 7 Posts: 38564 View Predictions]

#403918

Both have killer voices so they tie there. Both have great catalogs of music so they tie there. Kelly gets this for me because she is so versatile though.

ReplyCopy URL

[RadioGAGAheadParticipant Joined: Sep 25th, 2011 Topics: 0 Posts: 878 View Predictions]

#403919

P!nk is the better artist with the more consistent catalog, but I’d go with Kelly Clarkson. I like her voice better and I think her hits are more iconic. 

ReplyCopy URL

[smurty11Participant Joined: Sep 7th, 2014 Topics: 15 Posts: 628 View Predictions]

#403920

^^^exactly, P!nk never had a blockbuster, iconic song like Since U Been Gone (on Rolling Stone’s 500 best songs ever) or a blockbuster album like Breakway was for Kelly.

ReplyCopy URL

[IckyParticipant Joined: Jun 28th, 2012 Topics: 22 Posts: 4607 View Predictions]

#403921

World wide popularity and relevance Pink definitely outruns Clarkson. Clarkson had one huge album and one truly iconic song. Since then she’s established a solid following but she’s not on that level anymore.

As far as personal preferences I kinda like both without being a legit fan of either. Pink never really took a step forward artistically after Missundazstood, though I overall prefer her singles to Clarkson. 

ReplyCopy URL

[GraemeONeilParticipant Joined: Jul 16th, 2014 Topics: 7 Posts: 1028 View Predictions]

#403922

GraemeONeil wrote:

P!nk is the better artist with the more consistent catalog, but I’d go with Kelly Clarkson. I like her voice better and I think her hits are more iconic. 

This.

I love them both. Pink takes more risks in her music. In her last couple of albums, she’s truly had some outstanding (non-single) songs. Kelly has unfortunately played it VERY safe since her label crucified her with “My December”, but Kelly’s singles have been better than Pink’s.
They both are outstanding artists doing their best in the pop game (i.e. they both could be way better than they are, but they have to stay within the pop constraints). 

ReplyCopy URL