Combined Kate Hepburn’s and Liz’s 2 wins because of the uneven amount thanks to the ’68 tie.
I voted for Elizabeth Taylor for Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?….close call over Hepburn and Smith.
#1-Elizabeth Taylor (Woolf?)
#2-Katharine Hepburn (Winter)
#5-Anne Bancroft (deserving win, but would’ve voted for Hepburn)
#6-Julie Christie (deserving win, would also consider Andrews, Eggar, and Hartman)
#7-Barbra Streisand (should have solely been Hepburn)
#8-Julie Andrews, Mary Poppins (interesting case; iconic charming performance and I adore her…debatable, could give to Bancroft or Stanley)
#9-Patricia Neal, Hud (close call over her, Wood, and Roberts)
#10-Elizabeth Taylor (Butterfield 8…would’ve voted for Shirley MacLaine)
5. Smith (shoulda been Fonda)
6. Taylor – 66 (shoulda been Lynn Redgrave)
7. Hepburn – 68 (see Streisand above!)
8. Andrews (shoulda been Bancroft)
9. Hepburn – 67 (shoulda been Evans or Bancroft)
10. Christie (shoulda been Andrews)
11. Taylor – 60 (shoulda been MacLaine)
1. Taylor, Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
2. Loren, Two Women (My #1: Wood, Splendor in the Grass)
3. Hepburn, Lion in the Winter
4. Streisand, Funny Girl (I love the tie, but I would’ve vote only for Streisand)
5. Bancroft, Miracle Worker (My #1: Hepburn, Long Day’s Journey Into Night)
6. Smith, Prime of Miss Jean Brodie
7. Christie, Darling (My #1: Andrews, Sound of the Music)
8. Andrews, Mary Poppins (My #1: Loren, Marriage Italian-Style)
9. Neal, Hud (My #1: Caron, L-Shaped Room)
10. Taylor, BUtterfield 8 (My #1: MacLaine, The Apartment)
11. Hepburn, Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner (My #1: Evans, The Whisperers)
in this order…
1. taylor- virginia woolf?
2. streisand- funny girl
3. bancroft- the miracle worker
4. hepburn- the lion in winter
5. smith- the prime of miss jean brodie
6. christie- darling
7. loren- two women
8. hepburn- guess who’s coming to dinner
9. andrews- mary poppins
10. taylor- butterfield 8
Having to pick between Taylor in VIRGINIA WOOLF? and Hepburn in LION IN WINTER is torture. I’ll say Hepburn simply because the LION IN WINTER is my favorite film.