Who do you guys think should have won?
1. Joe Pantoliano
2. Michael Imperioli
3. John Spencer
4. Bradley Whitford
5. Victor Garber
Pants deserved it. Imperioli, Whitford, and Spencer all won for better seasons and episodes.
But Imperioli had more screentime than Pants.
Joe Pantoliano best season was season 3 (2001 Emmys).
Michael Imperioli won in the right year (2004).
In 2003 Richard Schiff was the best among The West Wing men. Of course Emmy voters don’t watch the shows they nominate, and they nominated Spencer and Whitford.
My pick would have been not nominated Neal McDonough for Boomtown.