October 22, 2012 at 8:44 am #540478
Thoughts on who should have won?October 22, 2012 at 9:12 am #540480
I thought at the time, Vanessa and Judy were easily the best and either
shouldve won… I still do..
but Marisa wasn’t all that bad….I still feel that something was fishy
with her win…October 22, 2012 at 8:56 pm #540481
By far Judy Davis gets my vote. However it’s nots so bad about Tomei’s victory, she was a knock out in MY COUSIN VINNY. Redgrave was tremendous as always. Plowright was very good, but if she had to have one nomination in her career I wish it would have been for I LOVE YOU TO DEATH 2 years earlier. Richardson, I thought was better in THE CRYING GAME in 1992. I usually find her way over the top and DAMAGE fits that description for me.October 23, 2012 at 9:12 am #540482
I loved Marisa Tomei in My Cousin Vinny. She was hilarious, and strong, and heartbreaking in a scene or 2. She brought Mona Lisa Vito to live and stole the movie. True, the movie itself wasn’t great, but that performance staying just this side of over the top was awesome.October 23, 2012 at 1:41 pm #540483
This was actually really hard.
Marisa Tomei’s Oscar is legendary and still has detractors but I don’t begrudge her the win. She was definitely the heart and soul of that movie, which the movie was good and definitely a lot of fun but definitely not a masterpiece, and I can’t think of many other Supporting Actress winners recently who have had their performance quoted this much. I think she should have won for In the Bedroom and/or The Wrestler but I definitely think her win here was still deserving.
Joan Plowright is one of my favorites but JayDF was right in that she was snubbed two years earlier for I LOVE YOU TO DEATH.
Miranda Richardson is definitely a mannered actress but I love her dearly. She is definitely more remembered for The Crying Game these days instead of DAMAGE, but I still think that she was great in all three of her films that year, along with Enchanted April. Personally, had she won, I wouldn’t have cared though I would give her my vote in 1994.
Vanessa Redgrave is able to do so much with so little (Julia, Atonement, and then we have her work here in HOWARDS END, which is very good in her brief screentime.
Despite all of this, I think now I would vote for Judy Davis…that year’s critical darling and she continues the trend of Woody Allen writing killer Supporting female roles. She was easily the best thing about that movie, which isn’t one of my favorites by Allen, but she steals the show hook, line, and sinker.October 23, 2012 at 2:43 pm #540484
Marisa Tomei hands down.October 23, 2012 at 3:19 pm #540485
All of them are fabulous imo. So difficult, but I’d go with Judy Davis. She’s one of a kind.October 23, 2012 at 10:19 pm #540486
Judy Davis for god’s sakes!! Richardson is a close second. The others three don’t come any close.October 28, 2012 at 4:20 pm #540487
Why is it that on one hand GoldDerby posters write about how unfair the Academy is to fail to honor comedic work with the same vigor as dramatic performances and then bitterly complain about the few comedic victories (i.e. Marissa Tomei in My Cousin Vinny or Judy Holiday in Born Yesterday) in Oscar history?October 28, 2012 at 4:31 pm #540488
I dunno OnTheAisle. Because, we’re a bunch of freaking idiots? Lol.October 28, 2012 at 6:37 pm #540489
I dunno OnTheAisle. Because, we’re a bunch of freaking idiots? Lol.
Yet another pet peeve: Why does BabyPook irritate me with a slam to Sally Field’s mental acumen on one forum and then have me chuckling on another? There is a reason BP is one of the few I have friended here .November 2, 2012 at 2:16 pm #540490
OnTheAisle; the day that I said I think Sally is an “idiot”, it was boring around here and I wanted to stir things up and spark outrage and conversation. I was thinking of slamming Obama as well, just to stir things up.
Since that time, I have regretted it; although I may do it again. I’ve done it before and made statements I dont mean (about actors). Sally Field has been entertaining me for decades. I have literally seen all of her film work, as well as Sybil, where she is incredibly good. I expect her to be good in Lincoln. Seeing her receive a nomination assuming she’s worthy, would make me happy. Although, I think the odds are against her for a win.
There. My confession.November 2, 2012 at 2:44 pm #540491
^Thats brilliant!November 4, 2012 at 5:03 am #540492
Why is it that on one hand GoldDerby posters write about how unfair the Academy is to fail to honor comedic work with the same vigor as dramatic performances and then bitterly complain about the few comedic victories (i.e. Marissa Tomei in My Cousin Vinny or Judy Holiday in Born Yesterday) in Oscar history?
Because they won against such strong opposition.
I love the fact that both Marisa and Judy won for comedy roles but when they are up against the likes of Judy/Bette/Gloria at their very best the wins don’t seem so deserved, comedy or not.November 5, 2012 at 5:54 pm #540493
I love Judy, Joan and Vanessa, but I voted for Miranda, who has that harrowing scene toward the end of the movie.
Not a fan of MCV, which mistakes stereotypes for wit. Any of the other nominees should have taken that Oscar home.