Dustin Hoffman wins this for me. I loved Robert Preston in Victor/Victoria too. I haven’t seen the others
My gut says Hoffman but my brain says O’Toole. Gotta go with Hoffman
O’Toole is grand, but this is one of my favorite Hoffman performances. Tootsie is just fantastic.
1. Dustin Hoffman
2. Peter O’Toole
3. Robert Preston
4. Al Pacino
5. Henry Winkler