According to a source in the audience, when "Hugo" screened at the Academy last Friday it was missing a key visual effect shot. That report lines up with the version shown to the press last Saturday at L.A. Live with director Martin Scorsese in attendance for a Q&A session.
"Hugo" is the first 2011 release to screen at the Academy unfinished, and the decision to do so may be a damning one since the film is a contender for the Best Visual Effects Oscar.
The shot in question opens the film. A single take zooms through the distant train station where the film is set and moves from the tracks and loading area to the station's interior. People walking alongside trains appear as faceless, ill-defined figures. An Academy member present for the screening gave his initial impression saying, "I thought it was an animated film." Once the shot pulls into the station interior, actual actors distinguish that the film is indeed live-action.
For members of the Academy's visual effects branch, "Hugo" may have put itself at a disadvantage by screening unfinished. Deadline's Pete Hammond noted the peculiarity of the date of the film's Academy screening since it does not officially open until November 23. The film faces strong foes including "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2," "Rise of the Planet of the Apes," "Transformers Dark of the Moon," and "The Tree of Life" in the Best Visual Effects race.
The rules for the visual effects category were changed earlier this year. There will be 10 finalists rather than seven to screen clips for branch members who will then determine the five final nominees. If "Hugo" can make it to the bake-off, it could showcase the finished opening shot Academy members did not get to see.
Don’t miss important Oscars news and predictions – Get free Gold Derby updates
These are the guys you need to beat to win our prizes for best 'Survivor' and 'Amazing Race' predictions
Now you can predict these events at Gold Derby: ACM & MTV Movie Awards, Emmy & Daytime Emmy nominations, "Survivor," "American Idol" and "Dancing with the Stars."
Below: Leaderboards of our current weekly champs. There is still time for YOU to pull ahead of these folks before end of TV season. Make your predix now.