Why do so many directors reap writing nominations at Oscars?

By Chris Beachum
By Chris Beachum
Feb 05 2013 04:50 am
See Chris's
Oct 05 2015 22:35 pm
Get Gold Derby's free news alerts and predictions

Five of this year's 10 writing nominees at the Oscars also directed their films. This follows the trend with 55 of the 100 nominees from 2002 through 2011 also being helmers.

Why are scribes so enamored of directors?

Could it be that the writers regard them as auteurs bringing their visions to the silver screens? Or are they a little intimidated by the leaders on the set? Maybe it is simply because the adapted and original screenplay categories are the places to honor them when they have no shot at claiming a Best Director or Best Picture trophy. 

And perhaps it all just comes down to simple math. The writers branch has 377 members making the magic number of #1 votes just 63. While one can belong to only branch of the academy, anyone who has contended for a writing award is eligible to take part in the nominations process. That means a whole slew of directors can cast ballots for the writing nominees. (The academy as a whole votes for the winners.)

Last year, both writing categories were claimed by their film's helmers: Woody Allen won Best Original Screenplay with "Midnight in Paris" while Alexander Payne (along with co-writers Nat Faxon and Jim Rash) prevailed in Best Adapted Screenplay for "The Descendants."

In the past decade, almost half of the writing victories (nine of 20) were by directors who either wrote their scripts solo or with co-writers. In addition to Allen and Payne, there were: Pedro Almodovar ("Talk to Her," 2002), Sofia Coppola ("Lost in Translation," 2003), Peter Jackson ("The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King," 2003), Michel Gondry ("Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind," 2004), Payne ("Sideways," 2004), Paul Haggis ("Crash," 2005), and Joel and Ethan Coen ("No Country for Old Men," 2007).

For the current Oscar showdown in Best Adapted Screenplay, director Benh Zeitlin and co-writer Lucy Alibar contend for "Beasts of the Southern Wild" while helmer David O. Russell has a bid for "Silver Linings Playbook." Both men are also nominated for Best Director. Our odds have Russell in third at 9/2, while Zeitlin and Alibar are trailing in last place at 9/1. The category is led by Tony Kushner ("Lincoln") at 9/5, followed by Chris Terrio ("Argo") at 13/5. The fourth slot is held by David Magee ("Life of Pi").

Three directors are nominated for Best Original Screenplay this year: Michael Haneke for "Amour" (who also has a directing bid), Quentin Tarantino for "Django Unchained," and Wes Anderson with co-writer Roman Coppola for "Moonrise Kingdom." The category frontrunner is Mark Boal ("Zero Dark Thirty") at 12/5, followed in second place by Tarantino at 14/5, then Haneke at 3/1, Anderson and Coppola at 6/1, and finally John Gatins ("Flight") at 10/1.

Related News
Make your Emmy & reality TV predictions.
Win prizes: $100 to $1,000.
pop up close


Make Your Predictions: Win Prizes

MAKE YOUR PREDICTIONS HERE & NOW: Win prizes, compete against experts, fans and your friends

WIN weekly prizes: Predict "Dancing with the Stars," "Survivor," "The Amazing Race" and "Project Runway." Win $100 Amazon Gift Certificates.

Predict Oscar winners: Claim bragging rights, top spot on our leaderboards and a place of honor in next year's Top 24 Users (see what this year's are predicting HERE).

CLICK HERE TO GET STARTED. We'll send you personal notifications of your scores.


Hot Links from the Web

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Photo Galleries: Oscars, Emmys, ...