At the 1954 Oscars, Grace Kelly pulled off a shocking Best Actress win for “The Country Girl,” besting comeback-kid Judy Garland in the musical remake of “A Star is Born.”
This year, Nicole Kidman could follow in Kelly’s footsteps by portraying the movie star-turned-princess in “Grace of Monaco.” The film, directed by “La Vie en Rose” helmer Olivier Dahan, will be released by The Weinstein Co. on Dec. 27, the very day that Oscar nominations open.
Weinstein films have won Best Actress for two years running: Meryl Streep in “The Iron Lady” (2011) and Jennifer Lawrence in “Silver Linings Playbook” (2012). Streep, who co-starred with Kidman in "The Hours" which won the latter her only Oscar in 2002, is a strong Best Actress contender this year for "August: Osage County," which Weinstein will unspool in November.
Kelly’s victory over Garland is viewed as one of the biggest upsets in Academy history, but looking back, was it really a neck-and-neck race?
At 25, Kelly was an up-and-coming ingénue who had contended for Supporting Actress the previous year for "Mogambo" (she lost to Donna Reed for "From Here to Eternity").
In the same year as “The Country Girl,” Kelly also had starring roles in Alfred Hitchcock’s “Rear Window” and “Dial ‘M’ for Murder,” as well as “Green Fire” and “The Bridges of Toko-Ri.” Here was a star in the making if ever there was one.
Garland, meanwhile, was coming back from a very long, very public battle with breakdowns, bankruptcy, and substance abuse. “A Star is Born” reminded Hollywood of what a tremendous talent she was, and a Best Actress win would be her ultimate vindication.
On Oscar night, Garland was in the hospital recuperating from the premature birth of her son, Joey, and a camera crew was waiting outside the window for the perfectly made-up mother to accept her reward.
Though both actresses had taken home Golden Globes, the odds were tipped heavily in Garland’s favor. When the envelope was opened, however, Kelly’s name was called, leaving Garland with a brave smile for the cameras. Soon after her win, Kelly married Prince Rainier, relinquishing her title as Hollywood’s princess to become Monaco’s.
On paper, “Grace of Monaco” looks like the perfect vehicle for Kidman to nab her second Best Actress trophy -- it’s a biopic that combines Old Hollywood lore with European royalty. How could voters not eat that up?
Kidman would be the second person in history to win for portraying a real-life Oscar winner; Cate Blanchett prevailed in the supporting race in 2004 for playing four-time Best Actress champ Katharine Hepburn in “The Aviator."
It’s still way too early to tell, but these are the kind of stories that make the Oscar race so much fun to follow, whether it’s 1954 or 2013.
Win $1,000 predicting the Oscars
Win $100 Amazon gift certificates predicting the guild awards, Razzies and other kudos
Read more about entry and rules here. Make your initial Oscar predictions now. Change them later as often as you wish up until Oscar Day. Below, meet our past winners of recent award prediction contests.
Oscar Nominations: New York state resident Tim Kressner (gufa54) won $1,000 for reaping the highest percentage (78%) when predicting Academy Award noms. Watch our video chat with him here and learn his strategy for making picks. See the leaderboard here. See Kressner's predix here.
Golden Globes (Film): Mario Gomez, a med studen in Mexico, won our contest with the highest percentage of correct picks (86%) and highest point score (2,693). See our video chat with him here. Two other contestants also scored 86%: lulo1989 and eastwest. Tom O'Neil reaped best Experts' score. David Schnelwar had top score among our Editors. See the leaderboard here to see if you made the top tier.
Critics Choice Nominations: Bryce H scored an impressive 83% when sizing up 20 categories. That was one percentage point ahead of our smartest Editor, Daniel Montgomery. Our top Expert was also one of our Editors, Paul Sheehan, who reaped 74%. To see how you performed, check out our leaderboard plus the score section of your account page.
Golden Globe (Film) Nominations: Jonathan was our top User, reaping a staggering 86% when forecasting the lineup of 10 categories. That put him six percentage points ahead of our best Expert -- Scott Mantz (Access Hollywood) -- and eight ahead of our leading Editor, Daniel Montogomery. Did you made the cut on the leaderboard score breakdown?
Los Angeles Film Critics Association Award Winners: Christian aced all rivals, scoring 82%. That was almost 20 percentage points ahead of our top Expert (Edward Douglas of ComingSoon ) and Editor (Matt Noble), both of whom earned scores of 64%. Christian foresaw that surprise screenplay win for "Before Midnight." See leaderboard.