Blog: News & Views

'12 Years a Slave' came thisclose to winning New York Film Critics Circle

By Paul Sheehan
By Paul Sheehan
Dec 04 2013 07:11 am

New York Film Critics Circle Awards winners entertainment news 13579086

New York Post scribe Lou Lumenick spilled the beans on the complicated voting at Tuesday's meeting of the New York Film Critics Circle. As he notes, "the circle uses an arcane voting system for its multiple ballots."

The Best Picture race required five ballots to find a winner ("American Hustle) while Best Director needed four before Steve McQueen ("12 Years a Slave") prevailed.  Both lead and supporting actress contests went three rounds before Cate Blanchett ("Blue Jasmine") and Jennifer Lawrence ("American Hustle") came out on top as did Foreign Language Film ("Blue is the Warmest Color"). However, the male acting races (Robert Redford, "All is Lost" and Jared Leto, "Dallas Buyers Club") and animated feature ("The Wind Rises") were decided on just the second ballot. 

Before getting to the breakdown of this year's vote, it is important to understand what happens in each round of balloting. 

Round One (proxies allowed)
Members make a single choice.

Rounds Two & Three (no proxies)
Three choices with three points for first, two for second, and one for third. 
Winner must be ranked somewhere on majority of ballots.

Round Four (no proxies)
Three choices with three points for first, two for second, and one for third. 
Majority rule dropped.

Round Five (no proxies)
If there is a tie in Round Four, a run-off.

Lou broke down the results of this year's balloting, noting that some members left during the marathon five-hour voting. 

Round One 
No winner

Round Two
"12 Years a Slave": 34 points
"American Hustle": 32 points

Round Three (original vote discarded as it included proxies)
"American Hustle": 38 points
"12 Years a Slave": 30 points
"Gravity": 16 points
"Nebraska": 16 points

Round Four (winner need not appear on majority of ballots)
"American Hustle": 38 points
"12 Years a Slave": 38 points
"Gravity": 17 points
"Her": 17 points

Round Five Tiebreaker (straight vote)
"American Hustle": 14 members
"12 Years a Slave": 12 members

Round Three
Steve McQueen ("12 Years a Slave"): 37 points
Alfonso Cuaron ("Gravity''): 30 points
David O. Russell ("American Hustle"'): 26 points

Round Four
Steve McQueen ("12 Years a Slave"): 47 points
Alfonso Cuaron ("Gravity''): 32 points
Spike Jonze ("Her''): 31 points

Round Two
Cate Blanchett ("Blue Jasmine"): 44 points 
Adèle Exarchopoulos ("Blue is the Warmest Color"): 30 points 
Amy Adams ("American Hustle"): 29 points 

Round Three
Cate Blanchett ("Blue Jasmine"): 47 points 
Amy Adams ("American Hustle"): 40 points
Adèle Exarchopoulos ("Blue is the Warmest Color"): 34 points 

Round Two
Luptia Nyongo ("12 Years a Slave"): 46 points
Jennifer Lawrence ("American Hustle"): 40 points
June Squibb ("Nebraska"): 34 points

Round Three
Jennifer Lawrence ("American Hustle"): 40 points
Luptia Nyongo ("12 Years a Slave"): 39 points
June Squibb ("Nebraska"): 27 points

Round Two
"Blue is the Warmest Color":  37 points
"The Past":  23 points
"The Great Beauty": 23 points 

Round Three
"Blue is the Warmest Color": 40 points
"The Past":  32 points
"The Great Beauty": 20 points 

Round Two
Robert Redford ("All is Lost"): 44 points
Chiewetel Ejiofor ("12 Years a Slave"): 27 points
Oscar isaac ("Inside Llewyn Davis"): 27 points

Round Two
Jared Leto ("Dallas Buyers Club"): 49 points
Michael Fassbender ("12 Years a Slave"): 24 points
James Franco ("Spring Breakers"): 24 points

Round Two
"The Wind Rises": 52 points
"Frozen": 33 points
"Monsters University": 15 points

What do you think is going to win Best Picture at the Oscars? Vote below using our easy drag-and-drop menu. 


Follow Gold Derby
Click Here


Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Hot Links from the Web
Inside Track: Emmy Voting

EXCLUSIVE: See the episodes
submitted to Emmy judges
by actors and TV series

Every actor submits only one sample episode, which will be judged by other actors (ranging from 25 to 75 per category jury) between July 28 and August 14. TV series submit six, which will be split into three pairs to be distributed randomly to about 300 voters. We now have uncovered every single title submitted for the 2014 races. CLICK HERE FOR THE EPISODES

We analyze the pros and cons
of episodes submitted by actors
to Emmy judges

Who submitted well? Click links below to read our in-depth analysis of each actor's episode entry. 

Dylan Baker ("The Good Wife")
Beau Bridges ("Masters of Sex")
Reg E. Cathey ("House of Cards")
Paul Giamatti ("Downton Abbey") 
obert Morse ("Mad Men")
Joe Morton ("Scandal")

Kate Burton ("Scandal")
Jane Fonda ("The Newsroom")
Allison Janney ("Masters of Sex")
Kate Mara ("House of Cards")
Margo Martindale ("The Americans")
Diana Rigg ("Game of Thrones")

Steve Buscemi ("Portlandia")
Louis C.K. ("SNL")
Gary Cole ("Veep")
Jimmy Fallon ("SNL")
Nathan Lane ("Modern Family")
Bob Newhart ("The Big Bang Theory")

Uzo Aduba ("OITNB")
Laverne Cox ("OITNB")
Joan Cusack ("Shameless")
Tina Fey ("SNL")
Melissa McCarthy ("SNL")
Natasha Lyonne ("OITNB")


Photo Galleries: Oscars, Emmys, ...
Emmy Nominees: Video Interviews
Subscribe to our free news service