James Maslow scored 25 out of 30 from "Dancing With the Stars" judges on Monday night for his salsa dance with partner Peta Murgatroyd, which tied him for the lead with ice dancers Meryl Davis and Charlie White. Carrie Ann Inaba was certainly smitten, describing his routine, in which Murgatroyd ripped open his shirt, as one of the show's sexiest numbers before giving him a nine out of 10.
But did he really deserve those high marks, or is he coasting on sex appeal?
Eye candy has done well on the show before, with top-three finishes by hunks like Corbin Bleu, William Levy, and Gilles Marini. Will Maslow make it just as far or fizzle out?
Watch his salsa routine below and then respond in our poll. Then, to predict next week's results, log in to your free Gold Derby account, click on the "Dancing with the Stars" button, and answer our weekly questions.