The awards pedigree of the talent involved in this IFC release is top-notch. Writer/director Richard Linklater shared in two screenplay Oscar bids with his "Before" trilogy leads Julie Delpy andEthan Hawke. Hawke features in "Boyhood" as the father of Coltrane's character while Emmy champ Patricia Arquette ("Medium") plays his mother.
Logan: It opened brilliantly in five theaters this weekend, and it has Cynthia Schwartz on its campaign now. I'd consider it to be a factor in Picture, Director, Screenplay, Supp. Actress (Arquette), and - though perhaps less likely - editing.
ibbster: Judging from the critical response, surely it's going to sweep the major critics prizes. That metacritic score is unprecedented for a new American release with that many reviews counted. And I have to imagine that the directors branch is itching to give Linklater a nomination here.
DominicCobb: This could perform like the Tree of Life I think.
MalickFanboy: This seems like "Her" all over again. Best case scenario, it wins screenplay. The end.
vinny: This WILL be an Oscar contender in many catagories. I kinda am hoping for a best actor nomination as well.
"Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 2" (2011)
"Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 2" certainly deserved to be nominated for Best Picture, according to two key measures. Film critics loved it (87 score at Metacritic) and film-goers too (highest-grossing film of 2011 with $381 million in U.S. ticket sales). However, all serious Oscarologists knew that academy members would shrug it off because voters almost always treat kid-centric films as, well, kid's stuff.
Take, for example, "Billy Elliot" and "Home Alone" in past years -- both got overlooked for Best Picture too. Yes, "Toy Story 3" recently got nommed for the top Oscar, but only when the list was expanded to 10 entries. The first two installments got skunked when only five films could be nominated.
Daniel Radcliffe is keenly aware of this bias too. "I don't think the Oscars like commercial films, or kids' films, unless they're directed by Martin Scorsese," he recently growled to reporters. "I was watching 'Hugo' the other day and going, 'Why is this nominated and we're not?' I was slightly miffed."
Keep reading: Click the right-pointing arrow beside the photo above.