Rob Licuria: Good, bad & ugly of SAG film noms

By Rob Licuria
By Rob Licuria
Dec 16 2010 21:52 pm
0
0
Email this to a friend
close
Get Gold Derby's free news alerts and predictions

The Screen Actors Guild voting panels -- each composed of 2,100 randomly selected SAG members from across the United States -- tend to nominate the usual suspects, though sometimes throw up a surprise or two with "out of left field" head scratchers. So, as we review the actors included and excluded by the Screen Actors Guild Thursday, remember a nomination doesn't necessarily guarantee you a spot in the coveted top five at the Oscars, nor does a perceived snub doom you to oblivion. 

The Good
The strong showing for both "Black Swan" and "The Kids Are Alright" is encouraging. Those supporting nods for Mila Kunis and Mark Ruffalo cement their places in the running for the ultimate prize next month (i.e. an Oscar nomination). Jeremy Renner is also a welcome addition, especially given that "The Town" was nowhere else to be seen on the SAG roster. Renner and Kunis (and even John Hawkes for "Winter's Bone") were rarely discussed by the pundits and bloggers as genuine contenders in the months leading up to the awards season, so it is nice to see them break through as strong contenders.

The Bad
The consensus on the almost complete snub of "Inception" appears to be that it isn't an actor's film. I hoped for nominations (at the very least) for Leonardo DiCaprio and Marion Cotillard, and boil the almost complete snub of the film down to a general bias against sci-fi and action films, as the film only appears in the blockbuster-friendly Stunt Ensemble category. Two other notable exclusions are Andrew Garfield ("The Social Network") and Mark Wahlberg ("The Fighter"), made all the more stinging by the fact that voters saw the films and loved their costars enough to include them in their respective categories. As Nathaniel Rogers points out, the Ensemble category is deeply flawed when so many worthy actors are left out of their respective cast lists because of quirks in the rules governing that category.

The Ugly
SAG voters, "you've done some bad things, sweetie." I am very disappointed that there wasn't enough support among the voting panel for Jacki Weaver ("Animal Kingdom"). After wins and nominations by various critics groups and the Globe nod earlier this week, Weaver was on a roll, and appeared to have locked herself in as a probable Oscar nominee. Time will tell whether this is just a speed-bump on the way to the Kodak. I am also wondering whether Oscar voters will follow SAG's lead or go their own way (as they are entitled to do when voting) and bump Hailee Steinfeld up to the Lead Actress race (in the same way Keisha Castle-Hughes was at the 2003 Oscars for her lead role in "Whale Rider"). The Lead Actress lineup is extremely competitive, but Steinfeld belongs there. Who is she "supporting"?

Photo: Marion Cotillard and Leonardo DiCaprio in "Inception" (Warner Bros.)


 
Related News
Make your Oscars & reality TV predictions. Win prizes.
pop up close

Advertisement

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Inside Track: Oscar Predictions

Oscars predictions

Earliest Oscars Predictions Ever

Our Oscarologists are busy updating their predictions as they see more and more contenders. Make your early picks now -- click here -- and change them later as the derby heats up.

Odds   View %  
Experts
1 BoyhoodBoyhood
9/2
2 UnbrokenUnbroken
13/2
3 BirdmanBirdman
15/2
4 The Imitation GameThe Imitation Game
8/1
5 Gone GirlGone Girl
12/1
6 FoxcatcherFoxcatcher
12/1
7 The Theory of EverythingThe Theory of Everything
12/1
8 InterstellarInterstellar
14/1
9 The Grand Budapest HotelThe Grand Budapest Hotel
33/1
10 SelmaSelma
50/1
See complete statistics by Clicking Here
Hot Links from the Web
Photo Galleries: Oscars, Emmys, ...
Latest Forum Posts
Gold-Derby's top 10 Bands-Duos-Grou..
This is soooo hard. Much more difficult than the female/male artists lists. Damn..
Official Brooklyn Nine-Nine Season ..
I thought this was a great premiere, and it reminded me of how much I like this ..
Revival of "The Best Little Whoreho..
This is probably a choice that people will think is kinda crazy but what about B..
Subscribe to our free news service

Advertisement