TV hall of famer Bob Newhart can finally be called an Emmy Award winner. After six losses that spanned more than half a century, he prevailed at Sunday’s Creative Arts ceremony as Best Comedy Guest Actor for an apperance on “The Big Bang Theory.”
Following a standing ovation, he tearfully accepted the award from Margo Martindale (“The Americans“), stating, “This is my seventh shot at this. … I just love this very much.” He thanked the producers and cast of the Best Comedy Series nominee that showcased him in the role of former children’s show host Professor Proton.
Newhart will return for another guest shot on that program, shooting an episode in October. He would not divulge the plot or designs for that segment in his backstage interview.
Gold Derby predicted he would prevail over four-time champs Louis C.K. and Justin Timberlake (“Saturday Night Live“), past category winner Bobby Cannavale (“Nurse Jackie“) as well as Will Forte (“30 Rock“) and Nathan Lane (“Modern Family“).
Newhart’s big break on TV came at the 1960 Emmy Awards. As Tom O’Neil recounted in his 2000 book “The Emmys,” the comedy team of Mike Nichols and Elaine May backed out of the ceremony because of an “inappropriate” skit and the young comedian was drafted, filling in with routines about the Navy and Russian leader Nikita Krushchev‘s trip to Washington. His appearance boosted sales of his disc “Button Down Mind” and he went on to win three Grammy Awards a few months later: Album of the Year (beating Frank Sinatra and Nat King Cole), Best New Artist (besting Leontyne Price), and Best Comedic Performance.
Two years later, his short-lived variety show “The Bob Newhart Show” prevailed at the Emmys as Best Humor Program over “The Andy Griffith Show,” “Car 54, Where Are You?,” “Hazel,” and “The Red Skelton Show.” However, because Newhart was not a producer of the program, he did not collect an Emmy. He lost his bid for Best Comedy Writing to “The Dick Van Dyke Show.”
His long-running 1970s series “The Bob Newhart Show” (same title but a situation comedy set in Chicago) reaped four Emmy nominations but none for Newhart. Lead actress Suzanne Pleshette collected two noms and the show itself was up for Best Comedy Series in 1977 (defeated by “The Mary Tyler Moore Show”).
Newhart was nominated as Best Comedy Actor for his next long-running program “Newhart” three times. He lost in 1985 to Robert Guillaume (“Benson”) and followed that with two defeats to Michael J. Fox (“Family Ties”) in 1986 and 1987.
The Vermont-based “Newhart” would set an Emmy record for futility with an overall 25 losses. Among those defeats were multiple bids for supporting players Julia Duffy, Tom Poston, and Peter Scolari plus two Best Comedy Series defeats to “Cheers” (1983, 1984).
The Academy inducted Newhart into its TV Hall of Fame in 1993. Other honorees that year were newsman John Chancellor, producer/host Dick Clark, host Phil Donahue, game show producer Mark Goodson, soap opera creator Agnes Nixon, and actor/producer Jack Webb. His friends Tim Conway, Dick Martin, and Don Rickles were part of the tribute.
His fifth Emmy nomination came in 2004 as Best Drama Guest Actor on “E.R.” He lost that race to William Shatner (“The Practice”). He reached the half dozen mark in 2009 with an unexpected nomination for Best TV Movie/Miniseries Supporting Actor for “The Librarian: Curse of the Judas Chalice.” He was defeated by Ken Howard (“Grey Gardens”).
Will “The Big Bang Theory” win Best Comedy Series? Use our easy drag-and-drop menu below to make your predictions.