Oscars 101: Best Picture nominations ballots counted differently than rest

After hearing from the key regional film critics’ groups and then the SAG, Globes and Critics’ Choice voters, it is a good time to revisit the system by which the Oscars determine the Best Picture nominees. Alas, the process is not as simple as one would hope. 

Academy members won’t merely cite their favorite films on a blank ballot that they complete online or ship back to the accountants at PricewaterhouseCoopers by Jan. 8. Rather, they will rank up to five films on ballots which are then counted by a complicated method. So, take a deep breath, as we dive into the Oscar pool. 

While nominees in most of the other races are determined by the traditional system of preferential ballot that winnows the contenders down to a final five, the Best Picture finalists are arrived at by a separate system of tabulation.

There will be between five and 10 nominees for Best Picture. To reap a bid, a film has to be one of the top choices of at least 5% of the members taking part in the nomination phase. To illustrate how this system works, let’s look at last year’s race when there ended up being nine nominees.

 All 6,124 members of the academy get to fill in nomination ballots for Best Picture and are asked to list up to five films. 

Last year, a record number of the then 6,028 members took part in the process. So, let’s assume that 90% submitted their ballots; that would make for 5,425 ballots in all and 5% of this total is 272 votes.

There are three ways to get to 272:

– be listed first on a ballot;
– be listed second on a ballot with a film in first place so popular it triggers the surplus rule; or
– be listed second on a ballot with a film in first place that is tops with less than 1% of voters. 

Ballots are sorted by the first choice and only those films listed at the top of at least one ballot remain in play.

The maximum number of Best Picture contenders is 10. In our scenario, the initial threshold for a nomination is set at 494 votes (5,425 divided by 11 and rounded up). If each of 10 films reached this cut-off, they would account for 4,940 ballots, making it mathematically impossible for an eleventh film to get the requisite 494 first-place votes. 

The surplus rule is applied to all films that are listed first on at least 10% more ballots than the initial threshold required for a nomination. (For other categories, this trigger is set at 20%). The rationale for this rule is so that someone can vote for a hugely popular picture without fear that their ballot doesn’t matter. 

In our scenario — where the threhold is 494 first-place votes — the surplus rule would apply to those films which received at least 543 first-place votes. Each of those ballots is apportioned as follows: a share goes to the first-place film such that it reaches the initial nomination threshold and the remaining share goes to the second-place film if it is still in play (otherwise to the next film on the list that is still in play). 

UPDATED: Experts’ Oscars predictions in 22 categories

Of our 27 Experts predicting the Oscars last year, 21 had “12 Years a Slave” in first place. Let’s assume it was tops on 25% of the ballots returned; that would give it 1,356 first place votes. It only needed 494 first-place votes to reach the initial threshold so each ballot was apportioned with .36 of the vote going to “12 Years” and .64 to the second-place film if it was still in play (otherwise to the next film listed which is still in play). Those fractional votes were the equivalent of 862 ballots in all. 

Five of our Experts ranked “American Hustle” in first place. Let’s assume it made the grade with 15% of the voters; that would give it 814 first place votes. That total also triggered the surplus rule with .61 of the vote going to “American Hustle” and .39 to the second-place film if it was still in play (otherwise to the next film listed which is still in play). Those fractional votes were the equivalent of 320 ballots in all. 

Which films were likely to be listed second on those ballots that trigger the surplus rule? Did voters who loved “12 Years a Slave” like “Gravity” almost as much? Were those fans of “American Hustle” also enamored with “The Wolf of Wall Street”?

Those films that have less than 1% of the ballots following the surplus rule redistribution (in our scenario, that would be 55 ballots) are out of the running. These ballots are redistributed to the next film listed which is still in play (i.e., they will not be shifted to other films with less than 1% support found lower down on these ballots). 

The counting is over at this point and all those films with at least 5% of the total ballots cast (in our scenario, 272 ballots) were the Best Picture nominees. 

Among them, our 27 Experts were predicting 15 different films to be nominated for Best Picture

Of those contenders with the broadest support, six — “American Hustle,” “Captain Phillips,” “Gravity,” “Her,” “Nebraska” and “12 Years a Slave” — made the grade with all of our Experts.

These half dozen films all ended up reaping Best Picture nominations leaving, at best, four slots open. 

“The Wolf of Wall Street” got 26 votes and “Dallas Buyers Club” earned 24 votes. Both also landed in the Best Picture lineup, which had nine contenders in all.

The big surprise was “Philomena,” which had only racked up nine votes among our Experts but scored a Best Picture bid over “Saving Mr. Banks,” which had made the cut with 21 of them. “Saving Mr. Banks” must have failed to cobble together the 5% needed for a nom by a combination of first-place votes and second-place positioning behind films that triggered either the surplus or minimal rule. 

See latest Oscar rankings when Experts’ predictions are combined

While the Best Picture winner is determined by a version of this preferential system, the winners of the other races are those that top the popular vote — i.e, a voter picks just one of the nominees and the Oscar goes to the that nominee with the most votes.

What are your Oscar predictions? Make your picks now — click here — or scroll down to predict the Best Picture champ using our easy drag-and-drop menu. Best predictions will win $1,000 prize. And the 24 Users with the best scores advance to a team to compete against our Experts and Editors next year. See who’s in our current Top 24 and their early Oscar predictions. Meet the guy who won our contest to predict Oscar nominations last year — and learn how he did it and how you can be our next Gold Derby superstar. Register/log in to your account so you can also compete to predict the Golden Globes, Grammys, “The Walking Dead,” “AHS: Freak Show” and more.

More News from GoldDerby