‘Survivor’ castoff Josh Canfield: ‘I am devastated I am still not in the game’

Despite being one of the breakout stars of “Survivor: San Juan del Sur,” Broadway actor Josh Canfield was voted out Wednesday night by his tribe for being too much of a threat. Gold Derby sat down with Josh to talk about his fateful exit and he emotionally confessed to us, “I am devastated I am still not in the game.” Scroll down to read our entire Q&A, including who Josh would want to play him in a “Survivor” movie.

Gold Derby readers were notably shocked with Josh’s exit, as he only had 17/2 odds of going home according to our exclusive “Survivor” racetrack odds. All of our users who correctly predicted Josh’s elimination earned game points based on the odds they locked in throughout the week.

Psst: Here’s how to predict reality TV shows and win bragging rights AND prizes!

If you want to join in our prediction contest next week, simply click here or scroll down and make your first prediction using our easy drag-and-drop menu. You have until 4 p.m. PT next Wednesday to cast your votes for Episode 9, titled “Gettin’ to Crunch Time.”

Below, our Q&A with Josh.

This was the make or break week for you, Josh. If you had survived this week, a lot of fans thought that you could have won this entire game. In fact, you had #1 odds to win according to our predictions. Do you agree?

Josh: That’s a nice fantasy to have. I’ll go with you on that dream.

Talk a little bit about your relationship with Baylor. Why did you vote for her back in the very first episode?

Josh: At Tribal Council that night, John pointed at Baylor at one point and I took that opportunity to go ahead and vote for Baylor so that no one would think that I was aligned with her. I knew all the votes were going for Nadiya so my vote wasn’t actually needed. By voting Baylor, I was furthering our alliance in the game. When I got back to camp, I told John and my alliance what happened by saying, “I thought we were supposed to be voting for her since you pointed to her.” I played the dumb card. Then, I went and told Baylor the guys wouldn’t think we were in an alliance and we could go further in the game since no one would suspect it.

It seemed as though you didn’t really become a target until the tribe mix-up when you and Reed joined up together. Did the “Blood vs. Water” aspect mess up your game?

Josh: I wouldn’t say that it messed up my game, but it definitely had an impact on it. That is correct, that when the tribe swap happened, it became apparent I was at the head of the alliance and unfortunately there was no way to mask that.

At Ponderosa, did you get to meet up with anyone who was voted out before you, like John and Julie or Dale and Kelley? Or did they keep you isolated because you were on the jury?

Josh: The jury members are kept separate.

What’s the first thing you ate after being eliminated?

Josh: Peanut butter!!!

Were they any memorable moments from your time on the island that didn’t make it to air?

Josh: There were a lot of fun campfire chats at night. Also, a lot of fun clamming on the beach with different people.

Any scary animal encounters?

Josh: We had a snake at Coyopa’s camp on the roof. I almost stepped on a snake when I thought it was a stick. A baby skunk kept wandering around at Hunahpu and it would freak us all out.

As a “Survivor” fan, are you proud that you made it to jury? Or are you heartbroken that you’re not still in the game?

Josh: Both!! I am devastated I am still not in the game, but I’m grateful I still have a hand in the game and get to vote for the sole Survivor!

Talk a little about Julie’s decision to quit last week. What was she thinking?

Josh: Julie’s quit was really disappointing and frustrating for everyone. No one wants to be on a season with a quitter. It mars the season a little bit. I think Julie was thinking that she would rather be with John than be out here with us any longer. I don’t think she was enjoying the game anymore and I think she was just over it.

Who would you want to play you in the “Survivor” movie? I vote for Neil Patrick Harris.

Josh: I mean, if we’re going for fantasy, I want Brad Pitt to play me, of course! Let’s go right to the top! However, he may be juuuuust slightly older than me so I guess I’ll change to Zac Efron!

Thanks Josh!

‘Survivor’ quitter Julie McGee: Did John Rocker support her wacky decision? (Podcast)

Visit the “Survivor” prediction center where you can forecast everything from who’s going home next, to which castaways will win the Reward/Immunity challenges, to who’s going to Exile Island, to whether or not a hidden Immunity idol will be played. Get our weekly questions right and you could find yourself on our leaderboards.

Show us that you have what it takes to win the cutthroat reality competition here at Gold Derby and win our prizes, including a chance to have your questions answered by the eliminated castaways each week.

We are forecasting everything from the results on reality TV shows like “The Amazing Race,” “Dancing with the Stars” and “Project Runway” to the body count on “The Walking Dead” to the winners of the Oscars, Golden Globes and Grammys. Click on any box to bring up that event and get started.

To vote for who think will win, drag contestants over from the left to the right and arrange them in your predicted order of finishing. For example, if you think Jeremy will win Season 29, make sure you put him in first place. You can continue to update and change your predictions throughout the week, just click “Save Predictions” when you’ve settled on your choice.

‘Survivor’ predictions slugfest: Why did Julie quit? Will Jeremy win? Is Alec crazy?

Every time someone logs their predictions, the racetrack odds of the contestants are automatically updated. If the majority of users think Jeremy will win, that means he’ll have the best odds and will go to the front of the pack. Conversely, the castaways who don’t receive many votes of confidence have the worst odds and will go to the bottom of the pile.

The standard bet for each question is 100 points, which are wagered against the odds you locked in when you saved your predictions. However, for each TV episode you are given one special 200 point bet that you can use strategically to gain more points.

Here’s how racetrack odds work. If you bet 100 on something that has 50/1 odds and you end up being correct, you will receive 50 x 100 points, which equals 5,000 points. You’ll also get your original 100 points back, for a total of 5,100 points.

Watch all of our ‘Survivor’ Slugfests:
#29.00 ‘Preshow Smackdown’ | #29.01 ‘Suck It Up and Survive’
#29.02 ‘Method to This Madness’ | #29.03 ‘Actions vs. Accusations’
#29.04 ‘We’re a Hot Mess’
| #29.05 ‘Blood is Blood’
#29.06 ‘Make Some Magic Happen’
| #29.07 ‘Million Dollar Decision’

Get started by making your prediction as to which of the remaining players will end up as the winner of “Survivor” using our easy drag-and-drop menu below our recent Editors’ video slugfest.

More News from GoldDerby