Best Tony Awards experts: Thom Geier (EW), Gold Derby’s Tom O’Neil & Paul Sheehan

Fifteen Tonys Experts entered predictions at Gold Derby and three earned the biggest bragging rights: Thom Geier (Entertainment Weekly) and Gold Derby’s own Tom O’Neil and Paul Sheehan scored 85%; only one user among almost 500 total predictors scored better.

Join the fierce fight about the Tony Awards
going on right now in our notorious message boards

Those three Experts missed only four categories out of 26, including three that all the experts got wrong: Play Revival, Play Direction, and Play Featured Actress (Sophie Okonedo), which were all awarded to underdog “A Raisin in the Sun.”

Geier, O’Neil, and Sheehan also missed Sound Design of a Musical, predicting “Hedwig and the Angry Inch” instead of winner “Beautiful.” Only one Expert got that right: David Sheward (TheaterLife), who scored 66% overall.

See how you did predicting the 2014 Tony Awards

The next three Experts scored 81%: Wayman Wong (Talkin Broadway), Doug Strassler (NY Press), annd Matt Windman (amNY).

Three others scored 74%: Michael Musto (, Harry Haun (Playbill), and Scott Feinberg (Hollywood Reporter).

Andy Humm (Gay USA), Brian Lipton (Cititour), and Melissa Bernardo (Entertainment Weekly) correctly predicted 70% of categories.

David Sheward (TheaterLife) and Susan Haskins (Theater Talk) were right 66% of the time, while Andy Lefkowitz (Theatermania) scored 62%.

Collectively, the Experts ruled our Tony predictions with a 74% average, beating our Users (67%) and Editors (63%).

Tony winners: ‘Gentleman’s Guide,’ Neil Patrick Harris, Bryan Cranston

85% CORRECT (22 of 26)
Thom Geier (Entertainment Weekly)
Tom O’Neil (Gold Derby)
Paul Sheehan (Gold Derby)

81% CORRECT (21 of 26)
Wayman Wong (Talkin Broadway)
Doug Strassler (NY Press)
Matt Windman (amNY)

74% CORRECT (19 of 26)
Michael Musto (
Harry Haun (Playbill)
Scott Feinberg (Hollywood Reporter)

70% CORRECT (18 of 26)
Andy Humm (Gay USA)
Brian Lipton (Cititour)
Melissa Bernardo (Entertainment Weekly)

66% CORRECT (17 of 26)
David Sheward (TheaterLife)
Susan Haskins (Theater Talk)

62% CORRECT (16 of 26)
Andy Lefkowitz (Theatermania)

Follow Gold Derby on FacebookTwitterInstagram, Tumblr, iTunes and YouTube

More News from GoldDerby