SAG Award nominations: Forum posters rave about Rami Malek, ‘Straight Outta Compton’ & rant about snubs

rami malek straight outta compton helen mirren

The SAG Award nominations sparked strong responses in our forums — their reactions from the gamut from “all over the place” to “WTF” to “shocked.”

The nominees who elicited the most passionate reactions were surprise film contenders Sarah Silverman (“I Smile Back“), “Straight Outta Compton” and Helen Mirren (“TrumboandWoman in Gold“), and fan-favorite Rami Malek (“Mr. Robot“) on the TV side.

Read below to find out what our forum posters thought, then click here to join them in debating the TV nominations and click here to dish the film ones.

SAG Awards 2015: Complete list of nominations


CAROL-CHANNING: No nominations for the THREE supposed Supporting Actor “frontrunners.” Tremblay is winning that sucker. And once he wins one televised award, WATCH OUT. The cast of “Straight Outta Compton” is coming to snatch the wigs of the cast of “Spotlight.” I’m still not taking “Trumbo” too seriously as a contender. It has “Hitchcock” written all over it. A period piece about Hollywood with two actors who actors love … I should have known actors would have eaten it up.

MladenVukcevic: This was all over the place… Heavens, Mirren got three nominations? And for “Woman in Gold”? Silverman? Over God knows how many performances? This was a hoot. They were far more inside the box when it comes to TV.

surpriselover: WTF! Supporting Actor might not have much overlap with the Oscars. How is “Trumbo” the most nominated film? This is a very weird list of nominees. If I were the majority of these nominees I wouldn’t start planning my Oscar outfit!

RakocijaMarko: This awards season is getting more confusing every day. My predictions all fell apart in just a few minutes. This is my worst result ever. I had 1/5 in two categories.

DamianWayne: I’m legit shocked neither Keaton or Ruffalo made it [into Supporting Actor for “Spotlight”]. “Straight Outta Compton” in Ensemble is AWESOME! Sarah Silverman over Jennifer Lawrence. LMAO. Bye “Joy.”

Eddy Q: Looks like there’s a strong push for black-themed films with “Beasts of No Nation” and Straight Outta Compton, maybe in response to #OscarsSoWhite last year. I suspect there’ll be a strong Oscar-SAG disconnect this year.

CordellMartin: Glad to see the nods for Idris Elba (people should take him seriously for the Oscar nod), “Straight Outta Compton,” Leonardo DiCaprio, and Cate Blanchett. I wished that Michael B. Jordan & Sylvester Stallone would’ve gotten some love. Hopefully the Globes fix that.

SAG Awards nominations mystery solved: Just who decided these?


NateDoggg: These longform categories are even more astounding to me with this final nomination list. No “Show Me a Hero” at all? Liotta over Paxton [for “Texas Rising“]? And not even a nomination for David Oyelowo? Queen Latifah should easily romp to a win in her category.

Sasha: They should just stop with TV categories. Get rid of them for good. They’re absolutely useless and have no value.

Jw79bull: Damn no Taraji P. Henson!? WTF? She’s been nominated EVERYWERE and they shut her out here? I know season two has been a mess, but she was ON FIRE during the fist season, which came out earlier in 2015.

DamianWayne: Rami Malek is the only exciting thing happening here.

24Emmy: “Key & Peele” scored an ensemble nom? Uh, what. Explain please.

leothescorpio: Really happy for Malek and “Key & Peele”, but I am not happy that they shut out Oscar Isaac & Taraji P. Henson — and nothing for American Crime, really!?

Atypical: Jon Hamm winning Drama Actor is all that matters here. These nods are leagues better than the film nominees this year.

Subscribe to Gold Derby Breaking News Alerts & Experts’ Latest Oscar & Globe Predictions

Make your SAG Awards winner predictions starting with Best TV Comedy Ensemble to the right or at the bottom of this post and earn a place of honor on our leaderboard and a starring role in next year’s Top 24 Users (the two dozen folks who do the best predicting last year’s SAG champs). You can predict all nine TV categories (comedy, drama, movie/mini, stunts) for this event.

As some of our Users turn out to be our smartest prognosticators, it’s important that you give us your predictions. Your picks influence our Users racetrack odds, which also factor into our official combined odds.

Mr. Robot” photo credit: USA Network

“Straight Outta Compton” photo credit: Universal Pictures

“Trumbo” photo credit: Bleecker Street

More News from GoldDerby