Florence and the Machine (‘High as Hope’) reviews: Is it the ‘most rewarding’ album yet from the English band?

The English rock band Florence and the Machine has returned with their fourth studio album, “High as Hope,” which was released on June 29. What do the critics have to say about by the latest from the group led by the full-throated Florence Welch? And will it win them their first Grammy?

The reception has been generally positive. It has a MetaCritic score of 72 based on 7 reviews. That’s only a few ticks below their previous efforts: their 2009 debut “Lungs” scored 79, followed by “Ceremonials” (2011) with 75 and “How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful” (2015) with 77.

Many reviewers are truly high on “Hope,” describing it as “the realization of a singular talent” and “the most rewarding” album yet from the band thanks to Welch’s “magnificent emoting” and “intimate lyrics.” But a few other critics are more ambivalent, saying that “transcendent moments are “few and far between” and that Welch should tone down the “grandiosity” of her signature style and “sweat the small stuff more often.”

But the response has been more positive than not, so could this finally be their ticket to the Grammy stage? Florence and the Machine have been nominated seven times before but have yet to win. They broke out in 2011 with a nom for Best New Artist. Then in 2013 they returned with a pair of bids: Best Pop Album (“Ceremonials”) and Best Pop/Duo Group Performance (“Shake it Out”).

In 2016 they scored their biggest haul with four nominations: Best Pop Album (“How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful”), Best Pop Duo/Group Performance (“Ship to Wreck”), and Best Rock Performance and Best Rock Song (“What Kind of Man”). In-between Welch earned a nomination for Best Dance Recording in 2014 for “Sweet Nothing,” her collaboration with EDM artist Calvin Harris.

Do they finally deserve their turn in the winner’s circle after almost 10 years? Check out some of the reviews below, and discuss this and more with your fellow music fans here in our forums.

Neil McCormick (The Telegraph): “Florence Welch’s wonderful fourth album marks the realization of a singular talent … Now, at 31, with her most intimate and revealing set of songs, Welch has refined a sound so uniquely her own it really couldn’t be mistaken for the work of any other artist.”

Annie Zaleski (Spin): “But despite this vocal power, her albums to date with Florence and the Machine have often relied on bombast instead of substance … That’s changed on ‘High As Hope,’ the most rewarding Florence and the Machine full-length yet. Welch reinforces her magnificent emoting with contemplative, intimate lyrics.”

Josh Goller (Slant): “‘High As Hope’ does make room for more nuanced meditations on resiliency, as on ‘Hunger’ when she describes seeing the kind of beauty that, for a moment, makes her ‘forget to worry.’ But these transcendent moments, which explore the evolution of Welch’s personal mythos, are too few and far between.”

Alexis Petridis (The Guardian): “These songs are allowed significantly more room to breathe than those on her previous albums … It gives the distinct impression that there is a different artist somewhere within Florence Welch, struggling against the desire for grandiosity and the kind of big musical statements that have powered her career. ‘High as Hope’ suggests she should sweat the small stuff more often.”

Be sure to make your Grammy predictions so that Hollywood record executives and top name stars can see how their music is faring in our Grammy odds. Don’t be afraid to jump in now since you can keep changing your predictions until just before nominations are announced. And join in the fierce debate over the 2018 Grammys taking place right now with Hollywood insiders in our music forums. Read more Gold Derby entertainment news.