Emmy spotlight: ‘Modern Family’ deserves a return to Best Comedy Series race with its best season in years

After “Modern Family” won a record-tying five consecutive Emmy victories for Best Comedy Series (a feat previously accomplished by “Fraiser,” produced by “Family” creators Christopher Lloyd and Steven Levitan), the laffer soon fell out of favor with voters, dropping out of the main categories entirely last year. But it deserves a return to the race for its 10th season, the best since the show’s glory days.

For years, there wasn’t an eligible Emmy category “Modern Family” didn’t compete in, let alone win. In addition to its series victories, the show would regularly take home prizes for writing, directing and acting for Ty Burrell (2011 and 2014), Eric Stonestreet (2010 and 2012) and Julie Bowen (2011 and 2012), racking up 21 trophies out of 67 bids. Yet its fortunes began to dip in the sixth season, where it went from receiving double-digit nomination tallies to just six. That dipped down to four in year seven, three in year eight and just one in year nine (for Half-Hour Sound Mixing). So to say the bloom has faded from this rose is putting it mildly.

SEE Emmys 2019 exclusive: 20th Century Fox Television and Fox 21 Television Studios categories for ‘This Is Us,’ ‘Rent,’ ‘Modern Family’ and more

Yet just when you thought “Modern Family” was down for the count, it returned with its best season in years. Part of that has to do with the development of the Dunphys’ eldest daughter Haley (Sarah Hyland). As the child actors have grown older, the show has struggled to find a direction to send them in, be it college, relationships or careers. So it’s surprising to find Hyland standing out as the season’s MVP with an arc involving her marriage to boyfriend Dylan (Reid Ewing) and the birth of twin babies in the emotional finale.

There’s more heartfelt and hilarious storylines this year, most notably a Halloween episode revolving around the unexpected death of Claire (Bowen) and Mitchell’s (Jesse Tyler Ferguson) mother, DeDe (Shelley Long). It’s yet another example of the shows unique ability to blend laughter and tears in equal measure, and proves once again it’s at its best when bringing this diverse ensemble together to deal with some of life’s many complications.

SEE ABC Studio’s 2019 Emmy FYC mailer: Voters are watching these specific episodes of ‘Black-ish,’ ‘Grey’s Anatomy,’ ‘Jimmy Kimmel Live’ and…

Of course, there’s plenty of great material for the actors to chew on by themselves, whether it’s Jay (Ed O’Neill) coming to terms with his old age during a yearly camping trip; Alex (Ariel Winter) seeking advice from Gloria (Sofia Vergara) on how to dress sexy for her boyfriend Bill (Jimmy Tatro); Mitchell waging war against a vengeful courtroom sketch artist (guest star Dan Levy); Cameron overseeing a disastrous high school graduation; Phil (Burrell) trying to impress his son Luke (Nolan Gould), Dylan and Bill with a boy’s night; or Gloria dealing with Manny’s (Rico Rodriguez) obnoxious new girlfriend Sherry (Hillary Anne Matthews).

Given the wealth of options in the Best Comedy Series category, “Modern Family” has a steep hill to climb in order to get back in. But if Emmy voters are still watching, they’ll quickly be reminded of why they used to shower this program with gold not so long ago.

PREDICT the Emmys now; change them until July 16

Be sure to make your 2019 Emmy predictions today so that Hollywood insiders can see how their TV shows and performers are faring in our odds. You can keep changing your predictions as often as you like until just before nominations are announced on July 16. And join in the fun debate over the 2019 Emmy taking place right now with Hollywood insiders in our television forums. Read more Gold Derby entertainment news.

SIGN UP for Gold Derby’s free newsletter with latest predictions

More News from GoldDerby

Loading