Top 16 most surprising Daytime Emmy nominees of 2019: Tyler Christopher, Jacqueline MacInnes Wood and more

Hundreds of Gold Derby users predicted the nominees and winners in seven Daytime Emmys acting categories, and when the nominees were finally unveiled on Wednesday, March 20, our official racetrack odds correctly picked 20 out of 36 contenders (56% accuracy). We were right 21 times if you count Kassie DePaiva (“Days of Our Lives”), who ranked sixth in our nomination predictions for Best Supporting Actress, where there ended up being six nominees due to a tie. So who were the 16 contenders who surprised us? Scroll down for the complete list.

The biggest surprises can be summed up in four words: “Days of Our Lives.” Overall, our odds indicated that the NBC soap would earn 6 acting nominations, but instead it got 15! That includes four performers we were so underestimating that we all but dismissed them with 100/1 odds: Tyler Christopher (Best Actor), Linsey Godfrey and Martha Madison (Best Supporting Actress) and Philip Anthony-Rodriguez (Best Guest Performer).

In hindsight, we shouldn’t have dismissed them so easily. For instance, while Christopher had never been nominated for his “Days” role as Stefan DiMera, he previously earned four bids as Nikolas Cassadine on “General Hospital,” including a Best Actor win in 2016. Similarly, Godfrey is a first-time nominee for her current role as Sarah Horton on “Days,” but she earned three bids as Caroline Spencer on “The Bold and the Beautiful.”

Speaking of “B&B,” we were also underestimating Jacqueline MacInnes Wood in the race for Best Actress for playing Steffy Forrester on the CBS soap. She previously earned two nominations for Best Younger Actress (2012-2013) and one for Best Supporting Actress (2018), so now she joins an elite club of soap actors who have been nominated at all three levels: younger, supporting and lead. That list also includes her “B&B” co-stars Heather Tom and Scott Clifton, the aforementioned Tyler Christopher and the late Kristoff St. John (“The Young and the Restless”), among others.

See who else took us off guard below, and discuss this and more with your fellow daytime TV fans in our forums.

These nominees were so unexpected we gave them 100/1 odds.

Best Actor
Tyler Christopher, “Days of Our Lives”

Best Supporting Actress
Linsey Godfrey, “Days of Our Lives”
Martha Madison, “Days of Our Lives”

Best Guest Performer
Philip Anthony-Rodriguez, “Days of Our Lives”

We knew these contenders had a shot, but they weren’t among our predicted nominees.

Best Actor
Billy Flynn, “Days of Our Lives”

Best Actress
Jacqueline MacInnes Wood, “The Bold and the Beautiful”
Heather Tom, “The Bold and the Beautiful”

Best Supporting Actor
Bryton James, “The Young and the Restless”
Eric Martsolf, “Days of Our Lives”

Best Supporting Actress
Kassie DePaiva, “Days of Our Lives”
Vernee Watson, “General Hospital”

Best Younger Actor
William Lipton, “General Hospital”
Kyler Pettis, “Days of Our Lives”

Best Younger Actress
Victoria Konefal, “Days of Our Lives”
Eden McCoy, “General Hospital”

Best Guest Performer
Patricia Bethune, “General Hospital”

Be sure to make your Daytime Emmy predictions so that Hollywood insiders can see how their shows and performers are faring in our odds. You can keep changing your predictions until winners are announced on May 5. And join in the fierce debate over the 2019 Daytime Emmys taking place right now with Hollywood insiders in our daytime TV forums. Read more Gold Derby entertainment news.

More News from GoldDerby