Emmy spotlight: Will Ben Mendelsohn (‘The Outsider’) win again in another shocking upset?

Think twice before betting against Ben Mendelsohn.

An esteemed actor respected by peers and audiences alike, Mendelsohn is one of those actors who digs deep into a role, and when he is given one as complex as Det. Ralph Anderson on the Stephen King horror/crime thriller series “The Outsider,” you can count on the Australian actor to be back in the Emmy hunt.

Mendelsohn is, of course, no stranger to Emmy. In 2016, he scored a famed shocker of an upset victory against a phalanx of heavy hitters (Peter Dinklage, Jonathan Banks, Kit Harington, Michael Kelly, Jon Voight) to win as Best Drama Supporting Actor. It was for his performance as Danny Rayburn, the black sheep of a family riddled with secrets in the Netflix series “Bloodline.” (Mendelsohn also received a nomination the prior year for the same role.)


After several lucrative years as Talos in the Marvel films “Captain Marvel” and “Spider-Man: Far From Home,” Mendelsohn returned to TV for this HBO series, based on King’s 560-page novel “The Outsider.” His detective is a by-the-book cop in a small Georgia town who is investigating the brutal rape and murder of a local boy. All of the evidence, including video footage, points to the guilt of beloved Little League coach Terry Maitland (Jason Bateman), whom Anderson publicly and humiliatingly perp-walks out of a Little League game in front of all of his friends and neighbors.

The case of a murdered child is particularly personal to Anderson because he recently lost his own child to cancer, and bringing to life the detective’s own personal grief that this case brings to the fore is a specialty of Mendelsohn’s. Whenever he’s not playing heavies (and even sometimes when he is), there is a brooding quality to the actor’s performances that draws audiences in, wanting to know exactly what makes this character tick.

An added dimension to Mendelsohn’s work here is a crisis of conscience that Det. Anderson suddenly must confront when equally compelling evidence surfaces that Terry was out of town at a writers conference at the exact time of the murder. The complexities that this revelation has on Anderson only deepens just how compelling Mendelsohn’s work here truly is.

Mendelsohn is not the only potential Emmy contender from “The Outsider”. There’s dazzling writing by Richard Price (“The Wire,” “The Night Of”), strong direction in the first two episodes by Bateman and a powerful supporting performance from Oscar nominee Cynthia Erivo as a psychic detective who partners up with Anderson’s investigation.

Best Drama Series and Best Actor are tougher races to crack, but the Gold Derby series odds for “The Outsider” (currently ranking 11th) and Mendelsohn (who is in tenth place) place them both within striking distance for an Emmy nomination.

PREDICT the 2020 Emmy nominees now; change through July 28

Be sure to make your Emmy predictions today so that Hollywood insiders can see how their TV shows and performers are faring in our odds. You can keep changing your predictions as often as you like until just before the nominees are announced on July 28. And join in the fun debate over the 2020 Emmys taking place right now with Hollywood insiders in our television forums. Read more Gold Derby entertainment news.

SIGN UP for Gold Derby’s free newsletter with latest predictions

More News from GoldDerby