Justin Bieber ‘Changes’ reviews: Do critics think his new album is ‘Yummy’ or crummy?

Justin Bieber dropped his new album “Changes” on February 14 — Valentine’s Day. That’s fitting since the album contains odes to Hailey Baldwin, whom he married in 2018. Does it also mark a change in his musical style almost five years after the release of his last studio album, “Purpose”? And what do critics think of the creative direction he’s going in?

The reviews have been coming in, and as of this writing the album has a MetaCritic score of 58 based on seven reviews counted so far: three positive and four somewhat mixed, though none outright negative. That’s his lowest score yet not counting his 2011 holiday album “Under the Mistletoe.” But it’s actually not that far off of his usual critical standard. Consider that “Purpose” was his biggest commercial hit and a Grammy nominee for Album of the Year, but only scored five points higher on the review aggregator.

Some critics say “his R&B tendencies are natural and unforced.” He’s “honing a vocal approach that’s soothing, tender.” It’s “an effective album,” “subdued and unassuming,” and “he’s never sounded better.” But “Changes” has also been described as “tentative,” “uninspired,” and “strangely characterless” with “mostly average beats” and “seemingly random” guest artists including Post Malone, Travis Scott and Lil Dicky.

The lead single from the album, “Yummy,” was released on January 3 and debuted at number-two on the Billboard Hot 100 singles chart despite Bieber’s aggressive efforts to get it to number-one in that debut week. How will fans greet the rest of the album? It currently has a 6.1 user score on MetaCritic, which is not far off of its critical average, though there’s probably a good chance of a number-one debut for “Changes” even though that eluded “Yummy.” Check out some of the reviews below, and join the discussion on this and more with your fellow music fans here in our forums.

Jeremy Helligar (Variety): “That boy can sing. He’s a blue-eyed soul stirrer who somehow always has avoided sounding like a white guy trying to pass for black. His R&B tendencies are natural and unforced and, most importantly, never gratuitously flashy. And he’s never sounded better than he does on ‘Changes,’ his fifth studio album.”

Jon Caramanica (New York Times): “Can you be a superstar, and also in hiding? That’s what he’s attempting on ‘Changes,’ his sinuous, meditative and largely impressive fifth studio album … He finally stakes his claim, honing a vocal approach that’s soothing, tender although maybe slightly tentative, a middle ground between comfort and reluctance. It is an effective album, and also a deliberately unflashy one.”

Alexis Petridis (The Guardian): “You find yourself wondering if the man behind it really wants to be as successful as he was … It just feels subdued and unassuming, which are curious things for mainstream pop to be. It’s a tentative, rather than all-guns-blazing, return, with a by-any-means-necessary bubblegum single dutifully tacked on to throw his record label a bone.”

Roisin O’Connor (The Independent): “A number of songs about his new wife are so uninspired that he may as well be declaring his love for a household appliance … Even as he sings about the big themes – love, God … his love for God – that voice is strangely characterless … This isn’t so much an album that would rile you to the point of turning it off. Rather, it washes over you, with its mostly average beats (‘Forever’ is a rare exception) and seemingly random cluster of guest features.”

Be sure to vote today for our Gold Derby decade awards featuring the best of the best from 2010 to 2019. You can keep changing your ballot as often as you like until the event closes on February 21. All 1,500 candidates you’ll see across 22 categories were nominees at either the Oscars, annual Gold Derby Film Awards or both. And join in the fun debate over these contenders taking place right now with Hollywood insiders in our film forums. Read more Gold Derby entertainment news.

More News from GoldDerby