Oscars and BAFTAs gender gap study: There are more male winners than female nominees

As we head into a brand new year that will feature a brand new Oscars ceremony, let’s take this moment to look back and remember Frances McDormand‘s acceptance speech for Best Actress at 2018’s Academy Awards. As she picked up her second Oscar for “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri.” McDormand asked all of the female nominees to stand up. She spoke passionately, urging them to share their projects with the industry and left the podium with a final two words: “Inclusion. Rider.”

This five-part study details gender inequality at both the Academy Awards and its British equivalent, the BAFTAs. We begin by looking at the overall number of nominations for men and woman at all 90 of the Academy Awards to date as well as those of the BAFTA Awards since 1969 (prior to that, the British academy had a bias to home-grown nominees).

We know that female-led films are much scarcer than male ones. That notion is cemented by the fact that only five women have ever been nominated for the Best Director Oscar (including Greta Gerwig in 2018 for “Lady Bird”). Only one of those has won: Kathryn Bigelow for “The Hurt Locker.” Ninety years of Oscars, one female Best Director winner.

While that statistic is often mentioned by those campaigning for greater gender-equality at awards ceremonies, that is but one example of the shocking disparity between men and women. To determine the extent of this gender gap, we’ve compiled the complete data of all the nominees and winners excluding the four gender-specific acting categories) from the 91 Academy Award ceremonies. And we’ve examined those who were in contention at the British equivalent, the BAFTAs, from 1969 onwards.

SIGN UP for Gold Derby’s free newsletter with latest predictions

The figures and patterns of the data reveal the history of gender inequality in Hollywood, its present state, whether or not any improvement has been made as of late and insights into the future.

Figure 1a details the total number of Oscar nominations and wins for both men and women from the 91 awards to date.

Seven times more men than women have been nominated – 10,510 to 1,369. Of the 11,879 people ever nominated, only 11.5% were female, which is a slight increase on the 11.3% after 2018’s tallies. It’s much the same story for all Oscar winners, also shown in figure 1a: 2,190 male winners to 272 female winners, meaning that only 11% of all Oscar winners are female. That is actually a drop from the 12% after 2018’s tallies. The societal skew towards men throughout every one of the nine decades of the academy’s history is evidenced by the fact that there have been more male winners than there have been female nominees.

It is much the same pattern across the pond in Britain, the BAFTAs since 1969 (shown below in figure 1b) show a slight improvement on their American counterparts’.

Figure 1b shows a total of 4,982 male nominees and 1027 female BAFTA nominees since 1969. That translates into just under five times more males than females. Again, there have been more male winners (1,180) than female nominees, with only 226 female winners. From 1969 to 2019, 17.1% of all BAFTA nominees have been female – almost double the percentage of female Oscar nominees. Likewise, 16.1% of all BAFTA winners have been female. That’s an eight percent increase over the comparable results at the Oscars. Unlike the Oscars’, both of these percentages have increased from 2018’s percentages.

As this BAFTA data dates only from 1969, it does not include the more overtly sexist decades of the 30’s, 40’s and 50’s, whereas that of the academy’s does. To take this into consideration and ensure that the two sets of data can be compared as fairly as possible, we’re going to focus on the averages of both awards groups in the upcoming part two of this study.

DISCUSS Oscars and BAFTAs with Hollywood insiders in our notorious forums

More News from GoldDerby