‘America’s Got Talent’ judges rankings: Who is #1?

America’s Got Talent: All-Stars” kicks off on Monday January 1, 2023. This special edition of “AGT” pits acts from around the world against each other in a search for the best of the best. Sitting in judgement will be three of the four “America’s Got Talent” judges: Simon Cowell and Howie Mandel  who have been part of the panel for years plus Heidi Klum, who returned in season 15 as an “AGT” judge after a one-season break.

That same season also saw the introduction of the fourth member of the jury, “Modern Family” scene stealer Sofia Vergara. This in-demand actress was unable to attend the tapings of “America’s Got Talent: All-Stars.” That is such a shame as she is one of of our favorite judges.

But where does she land in our “America’s Got Talent” judges ranking? And how do each of three veterans fare among all the “AGT” judges ranked from worst to best?  How does of each of them compare to the original trio of judges (David Hasselhoff, Piers Morgan and Brandy Norwood)? And what about those one and done judges (Alesha Dixon, Julianne Hough, Gabrielle Union)?

SEE ‘American Idol’ judges rankings: All 14 judges ranked from worst to best

To find out, click the photo below to take a tour of our gallery of all 13 “America’s Got Talent” judges ranked from worst to best. And be sure to sound off in the comments sections with your own “America’s Got Talent” judges rankings.

SEE ‘America’s Got Talent’ winners: Where are they now updates for first 17 ‘AGT’ champions [PHOTOS]

Be warned: the length of a judge’s tenure on the panel does not necessarily mean that they ranked high on our list. Likewise, several of the short-lived panellists made a big impression on viewers. Who was your favorite among this lucky 13? Do you agree with our choice for the best (and worst) of the bunch? Let us know.

SIGN UP for Gold Derby’s free newsletter with latest predictions

More News from GoldDerby