Home Forums Movies 2015 Goldderby Rankings – results announced!

2015 Goldderby Rankings – results announced!

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 82 total)
5 years ago
Last Reply
5 years ago
( +2 hidden )
  • Profile picture
    Jan 3rd, 2013

    Hello all,

    It is my pleasure to
    announce the beginning of the 2015 Goldderby rankings!
    In case you don’t know, the
    Goldderby Rankings are an annual event, comprising of a ranked list of movies from the past year based on the
    grades provided by users for all the films
    that came out, compiled into a top 10 list based on an average given to each
    film. Past winners include: “Whiplash”,
    “Persepolis”, “WALL-E”, “The Hurt Locker”,
    “The Social Network”, and “Her”.

    The film grades will be awarded points in the
    following way:

    A+ = 5
    A = 4.5
    A- = 4
    B+ = 3.75
    B = 3.5
    B- = 3
    C+ = 2.75
    C = 2.5
    C- = 2
    D+ = 1.75
    D = 1.5
    D- = 1.25
    F = 1

    Each weekend, the grades will be calculated, and
    on Sunday, I’ll reveal a running top 10 list. The event will close on February
    27th, and the results will be announced on February 28th on the morning before the Oscars, giving everyone over
    a month to see as many films as they can. Grades can be posted in this thread
    or PM’d to me. This event is open to all Goldderby members who have joined in
    2015 or before, or who have posted at least 50 times on the site (which should
    be fairly easy to get in the next month if you’re not already there).

    A film must have at least 5 ratings in order to
    appear on the rankings, and I do ask that if you are adding ratings to your
    list, you either PM or post it separately to the thread, or somehow mark the change in your
    post, to ensure I don’t miss it. That’s all for now, so get to viewing and send in those

    Profile picture
    Jan 3rd, 2013

    To demonstrate and to start it off, here is my list (though I’m sure I missed a few here and there):

    The Big Short – A
    Bridge of Spies – B+
    Brooklyn – A-
    Clouds of Sils Maria – B-
    Daddy’s Home – C+
    The Duff – C+
    The End of the Tour – A-
    Ex Machina – A
    Fantastic Four – B-
    Far From the Madding Crowd – A-
    Furious Seven – B-
    The Gift – A+
    The Good Dinosaur – B-
    Grandma – C+
    The Hateful Eight – A
    Home – B-
    The Hunger Games – Mockingjay Part 2 – B-
    Inside Out – A+
    Irrational Man – B+
    Jupiter Ascending – C-
    Jurassic World – B
    Kingsman: The Secret Service – A-
    Labyrinth of Lies – A-
    The Last Five Years – C-
    Love and Mercy – B
    Macbeth – A-
    Mad Max: Fury Road – A
    The Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials – B-
    Me, Earl and the Dying Girl – A
    Minions – C-
    Mission Impossible: Rogue Nation – C
    Mistress America – B
    Mr. Holmes – A
    Paddington – B+
    Pitch Perfect 2 – C
    Point Break – B
    Ricki and the Flash – B
    Room – A-
    San Andreas – D+
    Shaun the Sheep Movie – A
    Sicario – B+
    Sisters – B-
    Spectre – C+
    Spotlight – A-
    Spy – A
    Star Wars: The Force Awakens – B
    Steve Jobs – A
    Ted 2 – C
    Tomorrowland – B-
    True Story – C-
    Truth – C
    Unfinished Business – D
    Unfriended – B-
    The Visit – B+
    A Walk in the Woods – C+
    What We did on Our Holiday – A-
    What We Do in the Shadows – A+
    While We’re Young – B+
    The Woman in Gold – B

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    May 20th, 2011

    I saw an unusally high amount of them this year so I’m happy to say that lol.

    Blackhat: B+

    The Intern: A+

    The Scorch Trials: B

    Kingsman: A+

    Unfriended: B (how this movie isn’t the poster for anti bullying right now is beyond me)

    Regression: F

    Pan: F

    Hotel Translyvana 2: C

    The Walk: B+

    Bridge of Spies: A+

    Goosebumps: B

    Burnt: C

    Crimson Peak: D

    Woodlawn: C

    Rock the Kasbah: D

    Jem and Holograms: F

    Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension: C

    Spectre: B

    The Peanuts Movie: A

    Mockingjay Part 2: B+

    Love the Coopers: B

    By the Sea: D

    The Good Dinosaur: A

    Creed: B

    My All American: B

    Secret in their eyes: A

    Star Wars: TFA: A+

    In the Heart of the Sea: C

    The Big Short: A+

    Alvin and the Chipmunks: the Road Chip: D

    Sisters: C

    Joy: A

    Concussion: A

    Daddy’s Home: A

    The Hateful eight: C

    Point Break: C+

    The Revenant: A+

    Victor Frankenstein: C

    Mad Max: Fury Road: A+

    Hot Pursuit: A+ (Love this movie)

    Tommorrowland: A

    Son of Saul: A+

    Me Earl and the Dying Girl: B+

    The Hallow: B+

    Brooklyn: A

    Jupitor Ascending: D

    The Spongebob Movie: Sponge out of Water: B

    45 Years: B

    Mr. Holmes: B

    Fifty Shades of Grey: F

    Focus: D

    Chappie: F

    The Second Best Exotic Margigold Hotel: B

    Unfinished Business: B

    Run All Night: B

    Trainwreck: B

    Insurgent: A

    Danny Collins: A

    Furious 7: B+

    Get Hard: C- (if the ending didn’t stink it would have been a C)

    Life: B

    Wild Card: B

    Spare Parts: C

    The Wedding Ringer: D

    Ex Machina: B+

    A Walk in the Woods: C

    Mortdechai: D

    Strange Magic: C

    The Boy Next Door: D

    The D Train: C+

    The End of the Tour: B

    Dope: D

    Mississipi Grind: B

    The Duff: B

    Cinderella: A

    Woman in Gold: B

    Dark Places: B

    The Avengers Age of Ultron: A

    The Longest Ride: A+ (I dont know why I like this movie so much)

    Monkey Kingdom: A+

    Far From the Maddening Crowd: C-

    True Story: C-

    Pitch Perfect 2: C

    Maggie: C

    The Water Diviner: C+

    Spy: A

    Carol: A+

    Irrational Man: C-

    Inside Out: A+

    Sciario: C+

    Mustang: B

    Youth: C+

    The Assasin: B

    Poltergeist: B

    Aloha: D

    Macbeth: C+

    Entourage: A

    San Andreas: A

    Jurassic World: A

    Insidious 3: B

    Minions: A+

    Southpaw: A

    Survivor: B

    Amy: B+

    Terminator Genysis: C-

    Everest: C (the single biggest disapointement of the year for me)

    Ted 2: C+

    Magic Mike XXL: F

    Max: A

    The Gallows: C

    Ant Man: A+

    Self/less: D

    Mission Impossible: Rogue Nation: A

    Paper Towns: C+

    Pixels: F

    Vacation: F

    The Gift: A

    Fantastic Four: F

    The 33: B

    Ricki and The Flash: B

    The Man From Uncle: F

    Straight out of Compton: B

    No Escape: C

    American Ultra: B

    Hitman: Agent 47: D

    Sinister 2: C

    We Are your friends: F

    Beasts of No Nation: B+

    Spotlight: A+

    Anomiisa: C-

    Black Mass: A

    Room: A

    The Transporter Refuled: D

    He Named me Malala: A+

    Steve Jobs: C

    The Danish Girl: A+

    The Visit: C-

    Legend: C-

    Where to Invade Next: C-

    90 Minutes in Heaven: C-

    Our Brand is Crisis: C+

    The Martian: A+

    Pawn Sacrifice: A

    Miss You Already: C

    Trumbo: B

    Truth: C-

    The Lady in the Van: B

    Freehold: B+

    The Dressmaker: C

    Caretel Land: B

    The Age of Adaline: B+

    Hot Tub Time Machine 2: F

    McFarland USA: C

    Shaun the Sheep Movie: B

    Sleeping with Other People: B


    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Oct 21st, 2013

    Inside Out: A+
    Room: A+
    Spotlight: A
    Me and Earl and the Dying Girl: A
    Spy: A
    Bridge of Spies: A
    Love & Mercy: A
    The Big Short: A
    Star Wars: The Force Awakens: A
    Mistress America: A
    Kingsman: The Secret Service: A-
    Cinderella: A-
    Ex Machina: A-
    Mad Max: Fury Road: A-
    Trainwreck: A-
    The Danish Girl: B+
    The Martian: B+
    Brooklyn: B+
    Danny Collins: B+
    Anomalisa: B+
    Sisters: B+
    The Peanuts Movie: B+
    Going Clear: B+
    The Gift: B+
    The Revenant: B
    Shaun the Sheep Movie: B
    Freeheld: B
    Steve Jobs: B
    Creed: B
    The Hunger Games Mockingjay Part 2: B
    Mission Impossible Rogue Nation: B
    Home: B
    The End of the Tour: B
    Mommy: B-
    What We Do in the Shadows: B-
    Tomorrowland: B-
    The Intern: B-
    Trumbo: B-
    The Good Dinosaur: B-
    Tom at the Farm: C+
    Black Mass: C
    Sicario: C
    Pitch Perfect 2: C
    The Hateful Eight: C-
    Jurassic World: C-
    Duke of Burgundy: D+
    SpongeBob Sponge Out of Water: D

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Nov 12th, 2013

    It’s funny, whenever I tell people how many movies I’ve seen this year they tell me I’m crazy, then I look at a thread like this and I feel like I’m seriously slacking.

    Here’s what I’ve seen so far (will definitely see more):

    Ant-Man C+
    The Avengers: Age of Ultron 
    Beasts of No Nation 
    The Big Short B+
    Black Mass B-
    Bone Tomahawk C+
    Bridge of Spies 
    Chappie C-
    Creed A-
    Crimson Peak B-
    The Death of Superman Lives: What Happened? B
    Entertainment D+
    Ex Machina A-
    Furious 7 B
    Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison of Belief A-
    The Good Dinosaur C+
    The Hateful Eight A
    Hot Tub Time Machine D 
    Inside Out A-
    In the Heart of the Sea C+
    Jurassic World B
    Kingsman: The Secret Service B
    Legend B-
    Mad Max: Fury Road A
    The Martian B+
    Mission: Impossible – Rogue Nation B
    The Overnight C+
    The Revenant A
    Room A-
    Sicario B+
    Slow West B+
    Spectre B+
    Spotlight A
    Star Wars: The Force Awakens 
    Steve Jobs A-
    Straight Outta Compton B
    Tomorrowland B-
    Trainwreck B-
    The Walk B+
    What We Do In the Shadows B
    The Wolfpack B

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Oct 14th, 2014

    The Big Short – A-
    Brooklyn – A
    The End of the Tour – A-
    Ex Machina – A
    The Hateful Eight – A
    The Hunger Games – Mockingjay Part 2 – B-
    Inside Out – A+
    Kingsman: The Secret Service – B+
    Love and Mercy – B+
    Macbeth – A-
    Mad Max: Fury Road – A+
    The Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials – B-
    Mr. Holmes – B
    Room – A-
    Shaun the Sheep Movie – A
    Sicario – C+
    Spectre – B
    Spotlight – A-
    Steve Jobs – B+
    What We Do in the Shadows – A-
    The Danish Girl – D+
    The Revenant – C+
    Carol – A-
    Slow West – A-
    Creed – A-
    Avengers: Age of Ultron – C+
    Fifty Shades of Grey – F
    A Girl Walk Home Alone At Night (2015 release in UK) – B 

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Jul 10th, 2013

    99 Homes – C
    Ant-Man – B
    Avengers: Age of Ultron – C+
    The Big Short – A
    Black Mass – C+
    Bone Tomahawk – B+
    Bridge of Spies – B-
    Creed – A
    Ex Machina – A
    Furious 7 – C
    The Gift – C+
    Going Clear – B+
    The Hateful Eight – A+
    Inside Out – A
    It Follows – A-
    Jurassic World – C
    Kingsman: The Secret Service – B-
    Love & Mercy – B+
    Mad Max: Fury Road – A+
    The Martian – B
    Mission Impossible: Rogue Nation – B+
    Mr. Holmes – C+
    Nightingale – C
    Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension – F
    The Revenant – B+
    Room – B-
    Sicario – B+
    Slow West – B
    Southpaw – B
    Spotlight – B+
    Spy – B-
    Star Wars: The Force Awakens – B+
    Steve Jobs – A- 
    Tomorrowland – C-
    Trainwreck – D+
    Unfriended – C 

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Hunter Logan
    Feb 17th, 2015

    The Revenant: A+
    Star Wars: The Force Awakens: A+
    Spotlight: A
    Carol: A
    The Martian: A
    Inside Out: A
    Steve Jobs: A
    Beasts of No Nation: A
    Room: A
    Bridge of Spies: A-
    Mad Max: Fury Road: A-
    Ex Machina: A-
    The Big Short: A-
    Creed: A-
    Love & Mercy: A-
    Anomalisa: B+
    Brooklyn: B+
    Macbeth: B+
    The End of the Tour: B+
    45 Years: B+
    The Danish Girl: B+
    Trumbo: B+
    Phoenix: B
    Me and Earl and the Dying Girl: B
    Sicario: B
    The Hateful Eight: B
    The Hunger Games: Mockingjay – Part 2: B
    Mission: Impossible – Rogue Nation: B 
    Straight Outta Compton: B
    Black Mass: B-
    Mr. Holmes: B-
    Spy: B-
    Ant-Man: B-
    The Peanuts Movie: B-
    The Gift: B-
    Joy: C+
    The Man from U.N.C.L.E.: C+
    Kingsman: The Secret Service: C+
    Slow West: C+
    A Brilliant Young Mind: C+
    The Good Dinosaur: C
    Trainwreck: C
    Youth: C-
    Avengers: Age of Ultron: C-
    Spectre: C-
    Jurassic World: D+
    Tomorrowland: D+
    The Visit: D+
    Ted 2: D
    Pan: D-
    Vacation: D-
    Fantastic Four: F

    Only film left I NEED to see: Son of Saul

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Jan 17th, 2016

    Mad Max- A+
    The Martian-A
    Hateful Eight-B-
    Star Wars-C
    Cinderella- D
    Inside Out- B+
    Avengers- D
    Unfriended- C
    Jurassic World- C
    Any Man- B
    Jupiter Ascending- F-
    Southpaw- B
    Furious 7- C
    Spectre- B
    Train wreck- C
    The Visit- C-
    Lady in Black 2- F
    No Escape- D
    Minions- C

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Nov 16th, 2012

    (How I do things, A for me is my 5/5) (I’ll update if I see more stuff)
    “Inside Out”– A
    – A
    – A
    “Mad Max: Fury Road”
    – A
    – A

    “The Martian”
    – A-
    “Far From the Madding Crowd”
    – A-
    “The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 2”
    – A-

    “Going Clear: Scientology and the Prison Belief”
    – B+
    – B+
    “The Peanuts Movie”
    – B+
    – B+
    “The SpongeBob Movie: Sponge Out of Water”– B+

    “Straight Outta Compton”
    – B
    “Ex Machina”
    – B
    “Kingsman: The Secret Service”
    – B
    “Ant-Man”– B

    “Jupiter Ascending”
    – B-

    – C+
    “Avengers: Age of Ultron”
    – C+

    – C

    “Jurassic World”
    – C- 

    “Blackhat”– D+

    “The Divergent Series: Insurgent”
    – D
    “Fifty Shades of Grey”– D 

    “Mortdecai”– D- 

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Sep 20th, 2012

    My Running Scores So Far:

    45 Years = A
    99 Homes = B-
    Anomalisa = C+
    Beasts of No Nation = A+
    The Big Short = B
    Black Mass = B-
    Bridge of Spies = A
    Brooklyn = A+
    By The Sea = C+
    Carol = A+
    Cinderella = C
    Concussion = C
    Creed = C
    The Danish Girl = B
    The DUFF = B+
    The End of The Tour = B+
    Everest = B-
    Ex Machina = A
    Fast & Furious 7 = F
    Fifty Shades of Grey = B+
    The Good Dinosaur = B
    The Hateful Eight = A
    HOME = C+
    Inside Out = A+
    The Intern = B-
    Joy = A
    Jurassic World = C
    Kingsman: The Secret Service = A
    The Lady In The Van = A-
    Legend = A
    The Lobster = C-
    Love & Mercy = B
    Macbeth = B-
    Mad Max: Fury Road = C+
    Man Up = D-
    The Martian = A+
    Me & Earl & The Dying Girl = C
    Minions = C
    Mr Holmes = B
    Our Brand Is Crisis = C
    Paper Towns = B+
    Pitch Perfect 2 = A
    The Program = B
    The Revenant = A
    Ricki & The Flash = C
    Room = A+
    The Second Best Exotic Marigold Hotel = C+
    Sicario = A
    Slow West = B-
    Southpaw = C+
    Spectre = A
    Spotlight = A-
    Spy = B-
    Steve Jobs = A
    Suffragette = A-
    Tangerine = C-
    Ted 2 = D
    Trainwreck = B-
    Trumbo = B
    Truth = B-
    The Walk = C+
    Welcome To Me = F
    While We’re Young = D+
    Youth = A-
    Z For Zacariah = C+

    Check out more of my thoughts on Twitter (@AMG_Review) and Instagram (amg_reviews)

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Jul 3rd, 2012

    45 Years – A+
    50 Feet from Syria – C
    Amy – D-
    Anomalisa – B
    Ant-Man – D-
    The Assassin – A+
    Ballet 422 – F
    Beasts of No Nation – A
    Best of Enemies – F
    The Big Short – A-
    Black Mass – D-
    Bone Tomahawk – D
    Boy and the World – A-
    The Brand New Testament – A-
    Bridge of Spies – D-
    Brooklyn – B+
    Burnt – D+
    By the Sea – D+
    Carol – A+
    Cartel Land – B-
    Chi-Raq – C+
    Cinderella – F
    Clouds of Sils Maria – D
    Creed – B+
    Crimson Peak – A-
    The D Train – D
    The Danish Girl – C+
    Dark Places – F
    Dior and I – C-
    Do I Sound Gay? – F
    Dope – A-
    The Duke of Burgundy – D
    Eden – D+
    Ex Machina – B-
    Everest – B
    Far from the Madding Crowd – A
    The Fencer – C+
    Fifty Shades of Grey – F
    The Gift – C+
    Going Clear: Scientology… – D+
    The Good Dinosaur – F
    Goodnight Mommy – D
    Grandma – B+
    The Green Inferno – F
    The Hateful Eight – A-
    Heaven Knows What – C+
    The Hunting Ground – D
    Inside Out – A-
    Insurgent – F
    Iris – C
    It Follows – B+
    Jauja – C+
    Joy – F
    Jurassic World – F
    Kingsman: The Secret Service – B
    Kumiko the Treasure Hunter – D+
    Lava – F
    Life – F
    Listen to Me Marlon – A
    Love & Mercy – C-
    The Look of Silence – A+
    Macbeth – C
    Madame Bovary – C-
    Mad Max: Fury Road – A
    Magic Mike XXL – A-
    The Man from U.N.C.L.E. – C+
    The Martian – D+
    Maps to the Stars – C-
    Maze Runner: The Scorch Trials – F
    Minions – F
    Mommy – C+
    Mr. Holmes – A-
    Mustang – A-
    My Enemy, My Brother – D-
    Pan – F
    The Peanuts Movie – F
    Phoenix – A+
    Queen of Earth – F
    Results – D-
    The Revenant – B
    Room – F
    A Pigeon Sat on a Branch… – A-
    Sanjay’s Super Team – F
    The Second Mother – A-
    Serena – F
    Shaun the Sheep Movie – A
    Sicario – A
    Slow West – C
    Son of Saul – A+
    Southern Rites – C-
    Southpaw – C
    Spotlight – C+
    The Standford Prison Experiment – D+
    Star Wars: The Force Awakens – C-
    Steve Jobs – B-
    Straight Outta Compton – C+
    Suffragette – F
    Tales of the Grim Sleeper – D+
    Tangerine – D-
    Testament of Youth – B
    Tig – C
    Timbuktu – A
    Time Out of Mind – C-
    Tom at the Farm – D
    Tomorrowland – C
    Trainwrekc – F
    True Story – F
    Trumbo – F
    Truth – F
    The Walk – F
    Welcome to Me – C-
    What Happened, Miss Simone? – B
    The Wolfpack – B+
    World of Tomorrow – B
    Xenia – D+
    Youth – B 

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Jul 23rd, 2012

    Love this, will edit soon.

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Apr 15th, 2015

    Slow West- A

    Mistress America- A

    Room- A

    Beasts Of No Nation- A-

    Spotlight- A-

    The Gift- A-

    It Follows- B+

    The Danish Girl- B+

    The Walk- B+

    Carol- B+

    The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Pt. 2- B+

    Steve Jobs- B

    Inside Out- B

    Straight Outta Compton- B

    A Brilliant Young Mind (x+y)- B

    45 Years- B-

    Clouds of Sils Maria- C+

    Amy- C

    The Martian- C-

    The End of The Tour- C-

    Star Wars- F

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Nov 12th, 2013


    Carol A
    Electric Boogaloo: The Wild, Untold Story of Cannon Films B-

    Thanks for doing this ET. I love seeing how these rankings end up looking. 

    ReplyCopy URL
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 82 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Similar Topics
wolfali - Nov 23, 2020
Heptapod - Nov 22, 2020
Chris B... - Nov 22, 2020