Home Forums Movies 2017 Goldderby Rankings!

2017 Goldderby Rankings!

CREATE A NEW TOPIC
CREATE A NEW POLL
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 140 total)
Created
11 months ago
Last Reply
10 months ago
139
replies
22315
views
41
users
pacinofan
25
Foolio
21
ETPhoneHome
19
  • ETPhoneHome
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jan 3rd, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467418

    Hi everyone,
    It’s time again for my favourite annual event, the Goldderby rankings! This is entirely different from the Goldderby awards, and though I’ve run it the past few years, it relies just as much on other forum posters like you to participate! It is also exceptional in that it goes far beyond a top ten list and lets you express a fuller spectrum of opinion on the year in film.
    For those who aren’t familiar with them, the Goldderby Rankings are based on the grades provided by users for ALL the films that came out in the past year, compiled into a top 10 list based on an average given to each film. Past winners include: Persepolis, Whiplash, The Hurt Locker, The Social Network, Her, Inside Out and last year’s OJ: Made in America.
    The film grades will be awarded points in the following way:
    A+ = 5
    A = 4.5
    A- = 4
    B+ = 3.75
    B = 3.5
    B- = 3
    C+ = 2.75
    C = 2.5
    C- = 2
    D+ = 1.75
    D = 1.5
    D- = 1.25
    F = 1
    Each weekend, the grades will be calculated, and on Sunday, I’ll reveal a running top 10 list, including it at the bottom of this post as well. The event will close on February 24th at midnight Pacific Time, and the results will be announced on February 25th, giving everyone over a month to see as many films as they can. Grades can be posted in this thread or PM’d to me. This event is open to all Goldderby members who have joined before 2017, or who have posted at least 25 times on the site (which should be fairly easy to get in the next month if you’re not already there). The more ratings we get, the better!
    A film must have at least 5 ratings in order to appear on the rankings, and I do ask that if you are adding ratings to your list, you either post it to the thread, or somehow mark the change in your post, to ensure I don’t miss it. That’s it, so get to viewing and send in those lists!

    Reply
    ETPhoneHome
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jan 3rd, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467421

    To demonstrate and to get it started, here are my rankings for this year:

    A Bad Moms Christmas – B-
    A Christmas Prince – B-
    A Dog’s Purpose – C
    Alien: Covenant – B+
    American Assassin – C+
    American Made – B-
    Atomic Blonde – D+
    Baby Driver – B
    Ballerina/Leap! – B-
    Battle of the Sexes – B
    Baywatch – D+
    Beauty and the Beast – C
    Birds Without Names – B-
    Blade Runner 2049 – B+
    Bon Cop Bad Cop 2 – B-
    Brigsby Bear – A-
    Buster’s Mal Heart – B+
    Call Me By Your Name – A-
    Captain Underpants: The First Epic Movie – A-
    Cars 3 – C-
    Certain Women – B-
    Coco – A-
    Colossal – A
    Columbus – B
    Daddy’s Home 2 – C+
    Darkest Hour – B-
    David Lynch: The Art Life – C+
    Detroit – A
    Downsizing – C-
    Dunkirk – B
    Fifty Shades Darker – D
    Free Fire – C-
    Geostorm – B-
    Get Out – A
    Ghost in the Shell – F
    Girls Trip – C
    Going in Style – B+
    Goon: Last of the Enforcers – C
    Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 – D
    Happy Death Day – B+
    Hitman’s Bodyguard – C
    Home Again – C+
    How to be a Latin Lover – C+
    It – B-
    Jigsaw – C
    John Wick 2 – B
    Journey’s End – C
    Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle – C
    Just Getting Started – B-
    Justice League – B-
    King Arthur: Legend of the Sword – D-
    Kingsman: The Golden Circle – C
    Kong: Skull Island – B-
    Lady Bird – B+
    Lady Macbeth – B
    Life – B-
    Logan – A
    Logan Lucky – B
    Loving Vincent – B
    Molly’s Game – A
    Mother! – B-
    Mudbound – B
    My Little Pony: The Movie – D
    Norman: The Moderate Rise and Tragic Fall of a New York Fixer – C
    Okja – A-
    Paddington 2 – B+
    Personal Shopper – B
    Phantom Thread – B
    Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales – C-
    Professor Marston and the Wonder Women – C
    Radiance – B
    Roman J Israel Esq – B
    Song to Song – C-
    Spider-Man Homecoming – B+
    Split – C+
    Star Wars: The Last Jedi – B
    Stronger – A-
    Sylvio – A+
    The Beguiled – C+
    The Big Sick – A-
    The Boss Baby – B-
    The Case for Christ – B-
    The Commune – B
    The Disaster Artist – B+
    The Emoji Movie – C-
    The Fate of the Furious – C
    The Florida Project – A+
    The Foreigner – C
    The Glass Castle – B
    The Greatest Showman – C-
    The Lego Batman Movie – B+
    The Man Who Invented Christmas – B-
    The Mummy – D+
    The Nut Job 2: Nutty By Nature – B-
    The Promise – B
    The Ritual – C
    The Shape of Water – B+
    The Snowman – C+
    The Space Between Us – B+
    The Star – C
    Thor: Ragnarok – B
    Three Billboards Outside Ebbing County Missouri – A-
    Transformers: The Last Knight – D+
    Un Sac de Billes – B
    Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets – C+
    Victoria and Abdul – B-
    War for the Planet of the Apes – B-
    Wind River – A+
    Wonder – A-
    Wonder Wheel – C
    Wonder Woman – B+
    Your Name. – A-

    ReplyCopy URL
    LaChienne
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jan 4th, 2017
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467429

    A Christmas Prince – B+
    A Ghost Story – A
    Alien: Covenant – C-
    American Assassin – B+
    Annabelle: Creation – C+
    Beach Rats – A-
    Beauty and the Beast – C
    Blade Runner 2049 – B+
    Call Me By Your Name – A+
    Dark Signal – C
    Detroit – C
    Dunkirk – A
    Get Out – B-
    Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 – C-
    Happy Death Day – B+
    In the Fade – D
    It – A-
    It Comes At Night – B+
    John Wick: Chapter 2 – B
    Justice League – B
    King Arthur: Legend of the Sword – D
    Kingsman: The Golden Circle – C-
    Lady Bird – B+
    Logan – A-
    Logan Lucky – B+
    Loving Vincent – A-
    mother! – C+
    Mudbound – B-
    Only the Brave – B+
    Spider-Man: Homecoming – B+
    Star Wars: The Last Jedi – B-
    The Beguiled – C
    The Big Sick – B
    The Disaster Artist – A
    The Emoji Movie – F
    The Greatest Showman – C+
    The Killing of a Sacred Deer – A
    The Meyerowitz Stories – B+
    The Mountain Between Us – D-
    The Mummy – D-
    The Post – C-
    The Shape of Water – B
    The Snowman – D
    Thor: Ragnarok – B+
    Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri – A+
    War for the Planet of the Apes – B
    Wind River – A-
    Woodshock – F
    Wonder Woman – B
    Your Name. – B+

    ReplyCopy URL
    pacinofan
    Participant
    Joined:
    Nov 28th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467679

    A Bad Moms Christmas – B-
    A Dog’s Purpose – C
    A Ghost Story – C+
    Alien: Covenant – B-
    American Assassin – C+
    American Made – B+
    Atomic Blonde – A-
    Baby Driver – B
    Battle of the Sexes – A-
    Baywatch – D+
    Beach Rats – A-
    Beauty and the Beast – C
    Blade Runner 2049 – A-
    Brigsby Bear – B+
    Call Me By Your Name – A+
    Captain Underpants: The First Epic Movie – C
    Coco – A
    Colossal – B+
    Darkest Hour – B
    Detroit – A
    Dunkirk – A
    Free Fire – C-
    Get Out – B+
    Girls Trip – B
    Going in Style – D+
    Goon: Last of the Enforcers – C+
    Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 – B-
    It – B-
    It Comes at Night – B
    I, Tonya – A-
    John Wick 2 – A-
    Kingsman: The Golden Circle – C+
    Kong: Skull Island – C+
    Lady Bird – A-
    Lady Macbeth – B+
    Life – B-
    Logan – A
    Logan Lucky – D
    Maudie – B+
    Molly’s Game – B+
    Mother! – C
    Mudbound – B
    Okja – B
    Only the Brave – B
    Personal Shopper – B-
    Spider-Man Homecoming – A-
    Split – C+
    Star Wars: The Last Jedi – A-
    Stronger – B-
    The Beguiled – B+
    The Big Sick – B
    The Boss Baby – C-
    The Disaster Artist – B-
    The Florida Project – A
    The Glass Castle – C+
    The Lego Batman Movie – A-
    The Meyerowitz Stories – B+
    The Mummy – D-
    The Post – B-
    The Shape of Water – A
    Thor: Ragnarok – B-
    Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri – B-
    Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets – B-
    War for the Planet of the Apes – B+
    Wind River – B+
    Wonder – B
    Wonder Woman – B
    Your Name. – B

    ReplyCopy URL
    CanadianFan
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jul 23rd, 2012
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467687

    Thanks for this, ET, always a great year-end ritual.

    I’ll post mine closer to the deadline once I’ve seen everything. Any way to see the top ten and their vote totals per year?

    • This reply was modified 11 months ago by  CanadianFan.
    ReplyCopy URL
    forwardswill
    Participant
    Joined:
    Apr 9th, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467696

    Thus far:

    A+
    Call Me by Your Name (MVP: Chalamet)

    A
    Dunkirk (MVP: Whitehead)
    Darkest Hour (MVP: Oldman)

    A-
    Three Billboards (MVP: McDormand)
    Lady Bird (MVP: Metcalf)
    The Post (MVP: Streep)

    B+
    Baby Driver (MVP: Elgort)
    I, Tonya (MVP: Stan)
    The Shape of Water (MVP: Hawkins)
    Their Finest (MVP: Arterton)
    Mudbound (MVP: Hedlund)

    B
    Beauty and the Beast (MVP: Stevens)
    The Big Sick (MVP: Hunter)
    Battle of the Sexes (MVP: Stone)
    God’s Own Country (MVP: O’Connor)
    Spiderman: Homecoming (MVP: Holland)
    The Florida Project (MVP: Vinaite)
    Logan Lucky (MVP: Craig)

    B-
    Victoria and Abdul (MVP: Dench)
    Kingsman: The Golden Circle (MVP: Firth)
    Star Wars: The Last Jedi (MVP: Ridley)
    Girls Trip (MVP: Hall)
    Wonder (MVP: Roberts)

    C+
    Murder on the Orient Express (MVP: Branagh)
    Breathe (MVP: Foy)

    C
    Atomic Blonde (MVP: McAvoy)
    Phantom Thread (MVP: Krieps)

    ReplyCopy URL
    sitizoner
    Participant
    Joined:
    Feb 25th, 2017
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467700

    Alien: Covenant – B-
    Atomic Blonde – B+
    Baby Driver – B
    Battle of the Sexes – A-
    Baywatch – D-

    Beach Rats – C
    Beauty and the Beast – C+
    Blade Runner 2049 – B+
    Call Me By Your Name – A
    Coco – A+
    Fifty Shades Darker – C-
    Geostorm – C+
    Get Out – A-
    Ghost in the Shell – D-
    Girls Trip – B
    Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 – C
    Happy Death Day – B-
    It – B+

    I, Tonya – A+
    Kingsman: The Golden Circle – B-
    Kong: Skull Island – C+
    Lady Bird – B
    Life – B-
    Mother! – A
    Okja – B+
    Spider-Man Homecoming – B+
    Split – D
    The Beguiled – B
    The Disaster Artist – C-
    The Fate of the Furious – D+
    The Florida Project – B-

    The Killing Of Sacred Deer – A
    The Mummy – C-
    The Shape of Water – A
    The Space Between Us – B-
    Three Billboards Outside Ebbing County Missouri – B+
    Wonder Wheel – D-
    Wonder Woman – C+

    ReplyCopy URL
    AWDubay
    Participant
    Joined:
    Aug 19th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467703

    Thanks for this, ET, always a great year-end ritual.

    I’ll post mine closer to the deadline once I’ve seen everything. Any way to see the top ten and their vote totals per year?

    just to clarify were ranking each movie we saw from the year

    Andrewsart.etsy.com

    Check out my online store 🙂

    ReplyCopy URL
    Anonymous
    Joined:
    Jan 1st, 1970
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467705

    1. Lady Bird- A (MVP- Saoirse Ronan)
    2. Call Me By Your Name- A (MVP- Timothee Chalamet)
    3. Coco- A (MVP- Gael Garcia Bernal)
    4. Get Out- A (MVP: Allison Williams)
    5. Logan- A (MVP: Hugh Jackman)

    6. Three Billboards Outside Ebbing Missouri- A- (MVP- Frances McDormand)
    7. Mudbound- A- (MVP- Garrett Hedlund)

    8. I, Tonya- B+ (MVP- Margot Robbie)
    9. It- B+ (MVP- Bill Skarsgard)
    10. Baby Driver- B+ (MVP: Ansel Elgort)
    11. The Florida Project- B+ (MVP- Bria Vinaite)
    12. The Shape of Water-B+ (MVP- Sally Hawkins)
    13. Girls Trip- B+ (MVP- Tiffany Haddish)

    14. All the Money in the World- B (MVP- Michelle Williams)

    15. Wonder- B- (MVP- Jacob Tremblay)
    16. The Square- B- (MVP- Claes Bang)
    17. Downsizing- B- (MVP- Hong Chau)
    18. Dunkirk- B- (MVP- Fionn Whitehead)
    19. War of the Planet of the Apes- B- (MVP: Andy Serkis)
    20. Star Wars: The Last Jedi- B- (MVP- Adam Driver)
    21. Wonder Woman- B- (MVP: Gal Gadot)
    22. Bladerunner 2049- B- (MVP- Harrison Ford)
    23. The Disaster Artist- B- (MVP- James Franco)
    24. The Big Sick- B- (MVP- Kumail Nanjiani)
    25. The Meyerowitz Stories- B- (MVP- Adam Sandler)
    26. Spiderman Homecoming- B- (MVP: Tom Holland)
    27. It Comes at Night- B- (Kelvin Harrison Jr.)
    28. Okja- B- (MVP: Tilda Swinton)
    29. Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle- B-

    30. God’s Own Country- C+ (MVP- Josh O’Connor)
    31. The Incredible Jessica James- C+ (MVP: Jessica Williams)
    32. Kong: Skull Island- C+ (MVP: John C. Reilly)

    33. Beauty and the Beast- C (MVP: Emma Watson)
    34. Thor Ragnarok- C (MVP- Jeff Goldblum)
    35. Guardians of the Galaxy Volume 2- C (MVP: Chris Pratt)

    36. The Greatest Showman- C- (MVP- Keala Settle)
    37. Marshall- C- (MVP- Sterling K Brown)

    38. Cars 3- D+ (MVP: Owen Wilson)
    39. Only the Brave- D+ (MVP- Jennifer Connelly)

    40. Split- D (MVP: James McAvoy)
    41. LBJ- D (MVP- Woody Harrelson)

    42. Transformers: The Last Knight- D- (MVP: Suicide)

    ReplyCopy URL
    forwardswill
    Participant
    Joined:
    Apr 9th, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467707

    Oh Hunter I am sooo stealing your MVP idea

    ReplyCopy URL
    ETPhoneHome
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jan 3rd, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467709

    Thanks for this, ET, always a great year-end ritual.

    I’ll post mine closer to the deadline once I’ve seen everything. Any way to see the top ten and their vote totals per year?

    I can pull my data from the years that I’ve done it, for sure! I’ll post those once I get home.

    just to clarify were ranking each movie we saw from the year

    Yes, any movie that was released in 2017, or is eligible for this year’s awards considerations. If you’re unsure, put it on the rankings as the only times I exclude a film is if it appeared on a prior ranking or definitely came out in 2018 (such as The Commuter, or Insidious etc.). Let me know if that’s still unclear! Thanks.

    ReplyCopy URL
    AWDubay
    Participant
    Joined:
    Aug 19th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467715

    Yes, any movie that was released in 2017, or is eligible for this year’s awards considerations. If you’re unsure, put it on the rankings as the only times I exclude a film is if it appeared on a prior ranking or definitely came out in 2018 (such as The Commuter, or Insidious etc.). Let me know if that’s still unclear! Thanks.

    thank i will make my list 🙂 thank god for letterboxd

    Andrewsart.etsy.com

    Check out my online store 🙂

    ReplyCopy URL
    pacinofan
    Participant
    Joined:
    Nov 28th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467722

    A Cure for Wellness B
    A Quiet Passion C+
    A United Kingdom B-
    Berlin Syndrome B-
    Dean C
    Everybody Loves Somebody B-
    Frantz B+
    I Am Michael C
    I Do… Until I Don’t D-
    Jungle C-
    Kedi B+
    Landline B
    Lemon C
    Little Evil C-
    My Cousin Rachel C
    Patti Cake$ B
    Raw A-
    Super Dark Times B+
    Their Finest B-
    The Devil’s Candy B-
    The Exception B+
    The Girl With All the Gifts B+
    The Lure B-
    The Lovers B+
    The Sense of an Ending C

    ReplyCopy URL
    H. H.
    Participant
    Joined:
    Dec 11th, 2017
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467726

    A Dog’s Purpose – C+
    Alien: Covenant – B-
    American Assassin – C
    American Made – B+
    Atomic Blonde – C
    Baby Driver – B+
    Ballerina/Leap! – B-
    Battle of the Sexes – B
    Baywatch – D+
    Beach Rats – B+
    Beauty and the Beast – C+
    Berlin Syndrome – B
    Blade Runner 2049 – B+
    Call Me By Your Name – A+
    Coco – A
    Colossal – A-
    Darkest Hour – C
    Downsizing – C
    Dunkirk – B
    Fifty Shades Darker – F
    Geostorm – D
    Get Out – A
    Ghost in the Shell – C-
    Girls Trip – C+
    Goon: Last of the Enforcers – C+
    Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 – B
    Happy Death Day – B
    Hitman’s Bodyguard – C-
    Home Again – D
    How to be a Latin Lover – C-
    I, Tonya – B+
    It – B+
    Jigsaw – C-
    John Wick 2 – B+
    Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle – B
    Just Getting Started – D-
    King Arthur: Legend of the Sword – D
    Kingsman: The Golden Circle – C
    Kong: Skull Island – B-
    Lady Bird – B+
    Lady Macbeth – B
    Life – C
    Logan – A-
    Logan Lucky – B+
    Molly’s Game – B
    Mother! – D
    Mudbound – B-
    Okja – A-
    Paddington 2 – B
    Personal Shopper – B-
    Phantom Thread – B
    Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales – D
    Raw- B+
    Spider-Man Homecoming – B
    Split – B-
    Star Wars: The Last Jedi – B
    Stronger – B+
    Super Dark Times – A-
    The Beguiled – C-
    The Big Sick – B+
    The Disaster Artist – B+
    The Florida Project – B-
    The Glass Castle – B-
    The Greatest Showman – C
    The Killing Of A Sacred Deer- B+
    The Post- C+
    The Shape of Water – A
    The Snowman – D
    Thor: Ragnarok – B+
    Three Billboards Outside Ebbing County Missouri – B
    Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets – C
    War for the Planet of the Apes – B
    Wind River – A
    Wonder – A-
    Wonder Woman – B
    Your Name – B+

     

     

    ReplyCopy URL
    Foolio
    Participant
    Joined:
    Jan 24th, 2017
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1202467776

    I will update as I see more movies.

    Abacus: Small Enough to Jail – A
    All the Money in the World – B-
    Baby Driver – B
    Baywatch – F
    Beauty and the Beast – B+
    The Beguiled – A-
    The Big Sick – A-
    Blade Runner 2049 – A-
    The Boss Baby – D-
    Call Me by Your Name – A+
    Coco – A
    Darkest Hour – B-
    The Disaster Artist – B+
    Downsizing – C+
    Dunkirk – B
    A Fantastic Woman – A
    The Florida Project – A+
    Get Out – A+
    Girls Trip – B-
    The Greatest Showman – D
    Guardians of the Galaxy, vol. 2 – D
    Icarus – A
    I, Tonya – A
    The Killing of a Sacred Deer – A
    Kong: Skull Island – D
    Lady Bird – A
    Logan – C
    Loving Vincent – B
    Manifesto – A-
    Marshall – B
    Molly’s Game – B+
    Mother! – B+
    Mudbound – A-
    Murder on the Orient Express – C-
    Phantom Thread – A
    The Post – B+
    Rough Night – C
    Roman J. Israel, Esq. – C+
    The Shape of Water – A+
    The Square – A
    Star Wars: the Last Jedi – B
    Strike a Pose – B+
    Strong Island – B
    Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri – A
    Tom of Finland – B+
    Victoria & Abdul – C
    War for the Planet of the Apes – D
    Whitney: Can I Be Me – B+
    Wonder – C+
    Wonder Woman – B+

    ReplyCopy URL
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 140 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Similar Topics
Freeman... - Dec 13, 2018
Movies
Citizen... - Dec 12, 2018
Movies
O´Hara - Dec 12, 2018
Movies