2018 Goldderby Rankings! (RESULTS ANNOUNCED)

[ETPhoneHomeParticipant Joined: Jan 3rd, 2013 Topics: 40 Posts: 3055 View Predictions]

#1202736105

Hi everyone,
It’s time again for my favourite annual event, the Goldderby rankings! This is entirely different from the Goldderby awards, and though I’ve run it the past few years, it relies just as much on other forum posters like you to participate! It is also exceptional in that it goes far beyond a top ten list and lets you express a fuller spectrum of opinion on the year in film.
For those who aren’t familiar with them, the Goldderby Rankings are based on the grades provided by users for ALL the films that came out in the past year, compiled into a top 10 list based on an average given to each film. Past winners include: Persepolis, Whiplash, The Social Network, Her, Inside Out, OJ: Made in America, and last year’s Call Me By Your Name.
The film grades will be awarded points in the following way:
A+ = 5
A = 4.5
A- = 4
B+ = 3.75
B = 3.5
B- = 3
C+ = 2.75
C = 2.5
C- = 2
D+ = 1.75
D = 1.5
D- = 1.25
F = 1
Each weekend, the grades will be calculated, and on Sunday, I’ll reveal a running top 10 list, including it at the bottom of this post as well. The event will close on March 2nd at midnight Pacific Time, and the results will be announced on March 3rd, giving everyone over a month to see as many films as they can. Grades can be posted in this thread or PM’d to me. This event is open to all Goldderby members who have joined before 2018, or who have posted at least 25 times on the site (which should be fairly easy to get in the next month if you’re not already there). The more ratings we get, the better!
A film must have at least 5 ratings in order to appear on the rankings, and I do ask that if you are adding ratings to your list, you either post it to the thread, or somehow mark the change in your post, to ensure I don’t miss it. That’s it, so get to viewing and send in those lists!

• This topic was modified 7 months, 2 weeks ago by  ETPhoneHome.

Reply

[ETPhoneHomeParticipant Joined: Jan 3rd, 2013 Topics: 40 Posts: 3055 View Predictions]

#1202736108

To demonstrate and to get it started, here is my list for 2018:

Annihilation – B
Anthropocene: The Human Epoch – B
Apostle – B+
Aquaman – C+
At Eternity’s Gate – B-
Avengers: Infinity War – B-
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs – B-
Black Panther – B+
BlackkKlansman – A
Blockers – C+
Bohemian Rhapsody – C+
Book Club – C-
Burning – A
Cam – A-
Christmas Prince: Royal Wedding – C
Crazy Rich Asians – B
Deadpool 2 – C
The Death of Stalin – B
Death Wish – C
Destination Wedding – B
Early Man – B+
Eighth Grade – A
Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald – F
Finding Big Country – A
First Man – A-
Game Night – A-
God’s Not Dead: A Light in Darkness – B-
Green Book – A-
Hereditary – C+
I Feel Pretty – B-
If Beale Street Could Talk – A+
The Incredibles 2 – B+
Isle of Dogs – B
Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom – D
The Leisure Seeker – B-
Little Italy – C-
Love, Simon – A-
Maze Runner: The Death Cure – B-
Meditation Park A+
The Meg – A+
Midnight Sun – C-
Mirai – A+
The Miseducation of Cameron Post – B+
Mission Impossible: Fallout – B
Mouthpiece – B-
Ocean’s Eight – B
On Chesil Beach – D
Pacific Rim: Uprising – C
Peter Rabbit – C
A Quiet Place – A-
Rampage – C-
Ready Player One – C+
The Rider – B
Roads in February – A
Shoplifters – A
Show Dogs – B-
A Simple Favor – A
The Sisters Brothers – D-
Skyscraper – A-
Sorry to Bother You – A-
Spider-Man: Into the Spider-verse – A
A Star is Born – B-
Thoroughbreds – B+
Tomb Raider – B-
Venom – B+
Widows – A-
The Wife – B+
A Wrinkle in Time – B-
You Are Here: A Come From Away Story – A-
You Were Never Really Here – B+

ReplyCopy URL

[MukundParticipant Joined: May 27th, 2018 Topics: 4 Posts: 2290 View Predictions]

#1202736111

ETPhoneHome wrote:

Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald – F

Yikes.

ReplyCopy URL

[forwardswillParticipant Joined: Apr 9th, 2013 Topics: 19 Posts: 3138 View Predictions]

#1202736113

A
If Beale Street Could Talk
The Favourite
A Star is Born
Mary Poppins Returns
A Quiet Place

A-
Can You Ever Forgive Me?
Mary Queen of Scots
Vice
First Man

B+
Ben is Back
Wildlife
Green Book
Roma
BlacKkKlansman

B
Game Night
Boy Erased
Eighth Grade
Widows
Incredibles 2

B-
Private Life
Collette
Mamma Mia: Here We Go Again
Crazy Rich Asians

C+
Bohemian Rhapsody
The Wife
Ocean’s Eight

C
The Children Act
Love Simon

D
Beautiful Boy

For Your GoldDerby Decade Awards Consideration:

Downton Abbey in Series, Supporting Actress and Ensemble. Glee in Supporting Actress, Guest Actor and Guest Actress.

Claire Foy and Lisa Kudrow in Drama and Comedy Actress respectively.

ReplyCopy URL

[EsOSParticipant Joined: Dec 9th, 2018 Topics: 8 Posts: 2634 View Predictions]

#1202736114

Widows A-
A star is born A
First man B+
Blackkklansman A
Eighth grade A+
Leave No Trace B+
The spy who dumped me C
Game night B+
Support the girls A-
Mamma Mia 2 B
The incredibles 2 A-
A quiet place A+
Crazy Rich Asians A
Oceans 8 B
Can you ever forgive me A
Roma A
Black Panther B
Instant family B-
I feel pretty B
The favourite A+
Mary Poppins returns B
The hate u give A+
Green Book B
Bad times at the El Royale B
Dumplin C+
If Beale Street could talk A-
To all the boys I loved before B
Bohemian Rhapsody C

• This reply was modified 9 months ago by  EsOS.

FYC: Octavia Spencer (Luce) - Best Supporting Actress

ReplyCopy URL

[LaChienneParticipant Joined: Jan 4th, 2017 Topics: 3 Posts: 7697 View Predictions]

#1202736146

22 July: C
Ant-Man and the Wasp: C-
Apostle: B-
Aquaman: B-
A Quiet Place: A-
A Star is Born: A
Avengers — Infinity War: A-
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs: C+
Beautiful Boy: B-
Bird Box: C
Black Mirror — Bandersnatch: B+
Black Panther: C+
Bohemian Rhapsody: B+
The Cakemaker: C+
A Christmas Prince: C-
Crazy Rich Asians: B-
Creed 2: B+
Deadpool 2: B-
Dumplin’: C
Eighth Grade: B+
Fantastic Beasts — The Crimes of Grindelwald: D+
The Favourite: B+
First Man: A-
First Reformed: B+
Green Book: D
Halloween: A-
Hereditary: A
The Incredibles 2: C+
Insidious — The Last Key: D+
Isle of Dogs: A+
Life Itself: F
Malevolent: F
Minding the Gap: A+
Mission: Impossible — Fallout: A
The Mule: C
The Nun: D-
Pacific Rim — Uprising: F
The Princess Switch: D+
Private Life: B+
Rampage: F
Roma: A+
Shirkers: B+
Sicario — Day of the Soldado: B-
Solo — A Star Wars Story: C+
Spider-Man — Into the Spiderverse: A
Tomb Raider: D-
Unsane: D-
Vice: D
You Were Never Really Here: A-
Wildlife: A

ReplyCopy URL

[NikhilParticipant Joined: Dec 9th, 2015 Topics: 6 Posts: 198 View Predictions]

#1202736213

A+
Hereditary

A
Searching
Crazy Rich Asians
Annihilation
Green Book

A-
First Man
Widows

B+
Avengers- Infinity War
The Favourite

B
A Star is Born
Black Panther
Game Night
Blockers

B-
The Sisters Brothers
Mid 90’s
A Quiet Place
Mission Impossible- Fallout
Roma

C+
Blackkklansman
Set it Up

C
Bad Times at the El Royale

C-
Vice
Spider Man- Into the Spider Verse
Ready Player One
Venom

D
Bohemian Rhapsody
Fantastic Beasts 2
Aquaman
Solo – A Star Wars Story
Isle of Dogs

D-
Hot Summer Nights
Thoroughbreads
White Boy Rick
Deadpool 2

F
Sorry to Bother You

My personal Top 10 of the 2019 so far:
1) Parasite 2) The Farewell 3) Joker 4) Once Upon a Time in Hollywood 5) The Peanut Butter Falcon 6) Marriage Story 7) Luce 8) Yesterday 9) Hotel Mumbai 10) Avengers: Endgame

ReplyCopy URL

[RicosMamaParticipant Joined: Jan 7th, 2013 Topics: 0 Posts: 137 View Predictions]

#1202736232

A Star is Born – A+
Avengers: Infinity War – B
Bad Times at the El Royale – A
Beautiful Boy – C
Black Panther – C
BlackkKlansman – B+
Black Mirror — Bandersnatch – B-
Blockers – C
Bohemian Rhapsody – B
Crazy Rich Asians – C
Deadpool 2 – B-
Early Man – B-
First Man – A-
First Reformed – C
Game Night – B-
Green Book – B+
Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom – F
Mission Impossible: Fallout – B
Ocean’s Eight – C
Paddington 2 – A
Ralph Breaks the Internet – B-
Roma – B-
Set It Up – B+
Sicario — Day of the Soldado – B-
The Favourite – B+
Three Identical Strangers – B-
Venom – B
Vice – F
The Wife – D-
A Wrinkle in Time – C
Won’t You Be My Neighbour – B

ReplyCopy URL

[FoolioParticipant Joined: Jan 24th, 2017 Topics: 3 Posts: 6358 View Predictions]

#1202736237

Alex Strangelove – C
At Eternity’s Gate – C-
Avengers: Infinity War – D
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs – C
Beautiful Boy – C+
Black Panther – A-
BlackkKlansman – A+
Bohemian Rhapsody – C
Book Club – C-
Can You Ever Forgive Me? – A+
Christopher Robin – C-
Cold War – A
Colette – C+
Crazy Rich Asians – B
Disobedience – B+
Eighth Grade – A
Euthanizer – C+
The Favourite – A
First Man – A
First Reformed – A-
Free Solo – B+
Green Book – B
Hale County This Morning, This Evening A
Hereditary – B+
If Beale Street Could Talk – A+
Incredibles 2 – B+
Isle of Dogs – C+
Love, Simon – A-
Mamma Mia: Here We Go Again – C+
Mary Poppins Returns – B
Mary Queen of Scots – C-
Minding the Gap – A+
Mirai – A
Mission Impossible: Fallout – B
Ocean’s Eight – D+
The Party – B-
Private Life – A
A Quiet Place – B-
Ralph Breaks the Internet B-
RBG – B+
Ready Player One – B-
Roma – A
Shoplifters – A-
Solo: a Star Wars Story – D
Sorry to Bother You – A+
Spider-Man: Into the Spider-verse – A
A Star is Born – B-
The Tale – A+
Tully – A
Vice – B-
What Will People Say? – A
Whitney – B+
Widows – B+
The Wife – C+

ReplyCopy URL

[pacinofanParticipant Joined: Nov 28th, 2011 Topics: 8 Posts: 4154 View Predictions]

#1202736282

Alex Strangelove – B
Alpha – B
Annihilation – B+
At Eternity’s Gate – B+
Avengers: Infinity War – B
Bad Times at the El Royale – B
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs – B-
Beautiful Boy – C+
Ben Is Back – C
Bird Box – B-
Black Panther – A-
BlackkKlansman – B+
Blockers – B
Bohemian Rhapsody – B
Boy Erased – B+
Cam – B-
Can You Ever Forgive Me – B+
Colette – C+
Crazy Rich Asians – A
Creed 2 – B
Deadpool 2 – B
The Death of Stalin – A-
Destination Wedding – C+
Disney’s Christopher Robin – B
Disobedience – B+
Dr. Seuss’ The Grinch – C
Dumplin – B-
Early Man – B-
Eighth Grade – A+
Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald – D+
The Favourite – A-
First Man – B-
First Reformed – C+
Game Night – B+
Green Book – B+
Halloween – B
The Happytime Murders – C+
The Hate U Give – B+
Hereditary – A
Hot Summer Nights – D-
The House With a Clock In Its Walls – C+
I Feel Pretty – B-
If Beale Street Could Talk – A
The Incredibles 2 – B
Isle of Dogs – A
Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom – B-
Love, Simon – B
Mamma Mia!: Here We Go Again – B-
Mary Poppins Returns – B+
Mary: Queen of Scots – C+
The Meg – C
Mid90s – B
Mission Impossible: Fallout – A
The Mule – C-
Ocean’s Eight – B
On Chesil Beach – B
Paddington 2 – A-
Peter Rabbit – C
A Quiet Place – B-
Ralph Breaks the Internet – A-
Rampage – C-
Ready Player One – C
The Rider – B
Roma – B+
Searching- C+
Set It Up – B+
Shoplifters – A
A Simple Favor – B
The Sisters Brothers – B-
Skyscraper – C-
Solo: A Star Wars Story – B-
Sorry to Bother You – B-
Spider-Man: Into the Spider-verse – A-
A Star is Born – A
Suspiria – C
Thoroughbreds – B
Three Identical Strangers – B
To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before – B+
Tomb Raider – C-
Tully – A-
Unsane B
Vice- B
White Boy Rick- C+
Widows – B
The Wife – B-
Won’t You Be My Neighbor – A
A Wrinkle in Time – C
You Were Never Really Here – B-

ReplyCopy URL

[vinnyParticipant Joined: May 20th, 2011 Topics: 12 Posts: 59307 View Predictions]

#1202736334

Didn’t see a lot this year (mostly by choice):
Insidious: The Last Key: B+
The Ballad of Buster Scruggs: B+
The Commuter: B+
Unsane: B+
The First Purge: B+
Ant-Man and the Wasp: B+
Solo: A Star Wars Story: B+
Second Act: B+
American Animals: B+
Ocean’s 8: B+
Incredibles 2: B+
Tag: B+
On Chesil Beach: B+
Won’t You Be My Neighbor?: B+
Love, Simon: B+
Black Panther: B
Christopher Robin: B
Bohemian Rhapsody: B
Birdbox: B
6 Balloons: B
Cargo: B
Billionaire Boys Club: B
BlacKkKlansman: B
Annihilation: B
Red Sparrow: B
Vice: B
Early Man: B
A Quiet Place: B
Widows: B
Ready Player One: C
Proud Mary: C
Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom: C
12 Strong: C
Sicario: Day of the Soldado: C
I Feel Pretty: C
Disobedience: C
The Grinch: C
The Girl in the Spider’s Web: C
Life of the Party: C
Deadpool 2: C
First Reformed: C
Rampage: C
Peter Rabbit: C
Pacific Rim Uprising: C
Isle of Dogs: C
Den of Thieves: A+
Avengers: Infinity War: A+
Gringo: A+
Mary Poppins Returns: A+
Sierra Burgess Is a Loser: A+
A Christmas Prince: The Royal Wedding: A+
The American Meme: A+
The Bleeding Edge: A+
Aquaman: A+
Truth or Dare: A+
Beirut: A+
Outlaw King: A+
Apostle: A+
The Angel: A+
Hold The Dark: A+
Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again: A+
Unfriended: Dark Web: A+
Mission: Impossible – Fallout: A+
The Hurricane Heist: A+
Searching: A+
The Nun: A+
White Boy Rick: A+
Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald: A+
Roma: A+
The Favourite: A+
Mowgli: Legend of the Jungle: A+
Tomb Raider: A+
Winchester: C+
Mile 22: C+
The House with a Clock in Its Walls: C+
Ralph Breaks the Internet: C+
Robin Hood: C+
Green Book: C+
The Nutcracker and the Four Realms: C+
Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse: C+
The 15:17 to Paris: F
Blockers: F
A Wrinkle in Time: F
Bumblebee: F
Welcome to Marwen: F
A Futile and Stupid Gesture: F
The Cloverfield Paradox: F
The Week Of: F
Hereditary: A
Slender Man: A
To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before: A
If Beale Street Could Talk: A
When We First Met: A
Happy Anniversary: A
Dude: A
The Kissing Booth: A
Father of the Year: A
The Meg: A
Mary Queen of Scots: A
Crazy Rich Asians: A
Black Mirror: Bandersnatch: A
The Wife: A
Venom: A
A Star Is Born: A
The Hate U Give: A
First Man: A
Beautiful Boy: A
Halloween: A

• This reply was modified 9 months ago by  vinny.
• This reply was modified 9 months ago by  vinny.
• This reply was modified 9 months ago by  vinny.

ReplyCopy URL

[kellisParticipant Joined: Jul 30th, 2017 Topics: 2 Posts: 3160 View Predictions]

#1202736345

vinny wrote:

Didn’t see a lot this year (mostly by choice):
Insidious: The Last Key: B+
The Commuter: B+
Unsane: B+
The First Purge: B+
Ant-Man and the Wasp: B+
Solo: A Star Wars Story: B+
Second Act: B+
American Animals: B+
Ocean’s 8: B+
Incredibles 2: B+
Tag: B+
On Chesil Beach: B+
Won’t You Be My Neighbor?: B+
Love, Simon: B+
Black Panther: B
Christopher Robin: B
Bohemian Rhapsody: B
Billionaire Boys Club: B
BlacKkKlansman: B
Annihilation: B
Red Sparrow: B
Vice: B
Early Man: B
A Quiet Place: B
Widows: B
Ready Player One: C
Proud Mary: C
Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom: C
12 Strong: C
Sicario: Day of the Soldado: C
I Feel Pretty: C
Disobedience: C
The Grinch: C
The Girl in the Spider’s Web: C
Life of the Party: C
Deadpool 2: C
First Reformed: C
Rampage: C
Peter Rabbit: C
Pacific Rim Uprising: C
Isle of Dogs: C
Den of Thieves: A+
Avengers: Infinity War: A+
Gringo: A+
Mary Poppins Returns: A+
Aquaman: A+
Truth or Dare: A+
Beirut: A+
Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again: A+
Unfriended: Dark Web: A+
Mission: Impossible – Fallout: A+
The Hurricane Heist: A+
Searching: A+
The Nun: A+
White Boy Rick: A+
Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald: A+
Roma: A+
The Favourite: A+
Mowgli: Legend of the Jungle: A+
Tomb Raider: A+
Winchester: C+
Mile 22: C+
The House with a Clock in Its Walls: C+
Ralph Breaks the Internet: C+
Robin Hood: C+
Green Book: C+
The Nutcracker and the Four Realms: C+
Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse
The 15:17 to Paris: F
Blockers: F
A Wrinkle in Time: F
Bumblebee: F
Welcome to Marwen: F
The Cloverfield Paradox: F
Hereditary: A
Slender Man: A
If Beale Street Could Talk: A
The Meg: A
Mary Queen of Scots: A
Crazy Rich Asians: A
Black Mirror: Bandersnatch: A
The Wife: A
Venom: A
A Star Is Born: A
The Hate U Give: A
First Man: A
Beautiful Boy: A
Halloween: A

You don’t consider this a lot? Jan, what? Lol

“No user starts this shady” - someone culturally relevant.

ReplyCopy URL

[vinnyParticipant Joined: May 20th, 2011 Topics: 12 Posts: 59307 View Predictions]

#1202736357

kellis wrote:

You don’t consider this a lot? Jan, what? Lol

I usually see a lot more. This year was an off one for me.

ReplyCopy URL

[kellisParticipant Joined: Jul 30th, 2017 Topics: 2 Posts: 3160 View Predictions]

#1202736363

vinny wrote:

I usually see a lot more. This year was an off one for me.

Well, bless your bank account lol.

“No user starts this shady” - someone culturally relevant.

ReplyCopy URL

[vinnyParticipant Joined: May 20th, 2011 Topics: 12 Posts: 59307 View Predictions]

#1202736367

kellis wrote:

Well, bless your bank account lol.

More like Bless my rewards card at the movie theater 🙂 And Netflix, HBO, Starz, and Showtime. But seriously bless my rewards card and the perfect timing when I got it sine I have points saved up since 2003. Most of the time I literally don’t pay and the ticket is only like 25 points

• This reply was modified 9 months ago by  vinny.
• This reply was modified 9 months ago by  vinny.

ReplyCopy URL