2019 Goldderby Rankings

[ETPhoneHome Joined: Jan 3rd, 2013 Topics: 41 Posts: 3072 View Predictions]

#1203270921

Hi everyone,
It’s time again for my favourite annual event, the Goldderby rankings! This is entirely different from the Goldderby awards, and though I’ve run it the past few years, it relies just as much on other forum posters like you to participate! It is also exceptional in that it goes far beyond a top ten list and lets you express a fuller spectrum of opinion on the year in film.
For those who aren’t familiar with them, the Goldderby Rankings are based on the grades provided by users for ALL the films that came out in the past year, compiled into a top 10 list based on an average given to each film. Past winners include: Persepolis, Whiplash, Her, Inside Out, OJ: Made in America, Call Me By Your Name and last year’s Minding the Gap.
The film grades will be awarded points in the following way:
A+ = 5
A = 4.5
A- = 4
B+ = 3.75
B = 3.5
B- = 3
C+ = 2.75
C = 2.5
C- = 2
D+ = 1.75
D = 1.5
D- = 1.25
F = 1
Each weekend the grades will be calculated, and on Sundays I’ll reveal a running top 10 list, including it at the bottom of this post as well. The event will close on February 29th at midnight Pacific Time, and the results will be announced on March 1st, giving everyone over a month to see as many films as they can. Grades can be posted in this thread or PM’d to me. This event is open to all Goldderby members who have joined before 2019, or who have posted at least 25 times on the site (which should be fairly easy to get in the next month if you’re not already there). The more ratings we get, the better!
A film must have at least 5 ratings in order to appear on the rankings, and I do ask that if you are adding ratings to your list, you either post it to the thread, or somehow mark the change in your post, to ensure I don’t miss it. That’s it, so get to viewing and send in those lists!

Reply

[ETPhoneHome Joined: Jan 3rd, 2013 Topics: 41 Posts: 3072 View Predictions]

#1203270924

To get us started and to demonstrate the rankings post format, here are my rankings. I’m likely missing some that I have seen but I’ll add them as I go along.

A Beautiful Day in the Neighbourhood – B-
Always Be My Maybe – B-
Arctic – B
Ash is the Purest White – B+
Avengers: Endgame – B
Beanpole – A
Black Mirror: Bandersnatch – C
Blinded By the Light – B
Booksmart – B+
Cats – F
Christmas Prince 3: The Royal Baby – D+
Dark Phoenix – D
Detective Pikachu – C+
Dora and the Lost City of Gold – A-
Dragon Ball Super Broly – B
Everybody Knows – B+
Farewell, The – A-
First Love – B+
Ford vs. Ferrari – A
Frozen II – B+
Fyre: The Greatest Party That Never Happened – B-
Godzilla: King of Monsters – A-
Greener Grass, The – A-
Grizzlies, The – A
Her Smell – A-
Hobbs and Shaw – C-
How to Train Your Dragon 3 – B
I Lost My Body – C
Irishman, The – B
Isn’t it Romantic – C-
John Wick 3 – A-
Jojo Rabbit – A+
Joker – C
Knives Out – B+
Last Christmas – B
Laundromat, The – C
Lego Movie 2: The Second Part – C
Lighthouse, The – B
Marriage Story – A
Mary Magdalene – B-
Men in Black International – C
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood – B-
Pachamama – A-
Pain and Glory – A+
Parasite – A+
Polar – C-
Prospect – C+
Ready or Not – B
Shazam! – B-
Sound of Metal, The – A
Souvenir, The – B
Spider Man: Far From Home – C+
Star Wars: Rise of Skywalker – C
Synchronic – B-
To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before – B
Two Popes – B+
Us – A
Waves – A-
Weathering With You – A-
Who Let the Dogs Out – A+
Yesterday – B

ReplyCopy URL

[Luca Joined: Jun 23rd, 2017 Topics: 33 Posts: 6524 View Predictions]

#1203270927

• Booksmart: A
• The Farewell: A
• Us: A
• Frozen: A-
• Hustlers: A-
• Marriage Story: A-
• Midsommar: B+
• Joker: B
• Once Upon a Time in Hollywood: B-
• The Lion King: C-

And that’s all I’ve been able to see thus far.

Emmys FYC - "Unbelievable" and "The Handmaid's Tale" in all categories; Viola Davis in Best Drama Actress for the final season of "HTGAWM;" "Ozark:" Drama Series, Laura Linney (Best Actress) and Julia Garner (Best Supporting Actress)

ReplyCopy URL

[Foolio Joined: Jan 24th, 2017 Topics: 4 Posts: 6534 View Predictions]

#1203270961

1917 A-
Ad Astra A-
Always Be My Maybe B-
Amazing Grace B+
American Factory A-
Apollo 11 B
Atlantique / Atlantics A
A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood B+
Bombshell B
Booksmart A
Captain Marvel C+
The Dirt D+
Dolemite Is My Name A-
Dolor y gloria / Pain and Glory A
Downton Abbey C+
Dumbo D
The Edge of Democracy A
Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile B-
The Farewell A+
Ford v Ferrari B-
Frozen II B+
Gloria Bell B+
Guava Island B
Harriet C+
Her Smell B-
Honeyland A-
Hustlers A
I Lost My Body A-
The Irishman B+
Isn’t It Romantic B-
Joker B+
Judy B-
Knives Out A-
Knock Down the House A
The Last Black Man in San Francisco A-
Late Night A-
The Lighthouse B+
Little Women A
Luce A+
Madonna and the Breakfast Club D
Marianne & Leonard: Words of Love B+
Marriage Story A+
Midsommar A-
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood A+
Parasite A+
The Perfection B-
Portrait of a Lady on Fire A
Rocketman A-
Someone Great B-
Spider-Man: Far From Home B
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker C-
Toy Story 4 A-
The Two Popes B+
Uncut Gems A
The Unicorn Store C+
To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before C+
Us A
Velvet Buzzsaw D
Wild Rose A-

ReplyCopy URL

[gabarnes43]

#1203270973

1917- A+
Bombshell- A-
The Hustle- C
Isnt It Romantic- B+
Jojo Rabbit- A+
Joker- B+
Last Christmas- B-
The Laundromat- C-
The Lion King- B
Little Women- A+
Long Shot- A
Marriage Story- A-
Murder Mystery- B
Rocketman- A-
Someone Great- C+

Going to try and watch a bunch of films this week before Oscar nominations

• This reply was modified 5 months, 4 weeks ago by gabarnes43.
• This reply was modified 5 months, 2 weeks ago by gabarnes43.
• This reply was modified 5 months ago by gabarnes43.

FYC Emmys-
Limited-
UNBELIEVABLE, Quiz, Years and Years, Defending Jacob in all Categories
Merritt Wever, Toni Collette, Matthew Macfadyen, Emma Thompson, Chris Evans & Michelle Dockery

Drama-
STRANGER THINGS, The Morning Show, Big Little Lies, The Crown, Killing Eve
- Jennifer Aniston, VIOLA DAVIS, Jodie Comer, Sandra Oh, Nicole Kidman, Olivia Colman
- FIONA SHAW, HBC

Comedy-
SCHITTS CREEK, Dead to Me, Sex Education
- Catherine O’Hara, Annie Murphy, Christina Applegate, Linda Ca

ReplyCopy URL

[pacinofan Joined: Nov 28th, 2011 Topics: 8 Posts: 4214 View Predictions]

#1203271012

A Beautiful Day in the Neighbourhood – A
Always Be My Maybe – B-
Arctic – B-
Avengers: Endgame – B
Black Mirror: Bandersnatch – B
Blinded By the Light – A-
Booksmart – A-
Detective Pikachu – C+
Everybody Knows – C
Farewell, The – A
Ford vs. Ferrari – A
Frozen II – C
Godzilla: King of Monsters –C
Her Smell – C+
Hobbs and Shaw – B-
How to Train Your Dragon 3 – A-
Hustlers – B
I Lost My Body – C
Irishman, The – B+
Isn’t it Romantic – B-
John Wick 3 – B+
Jojo Rabbit – A
Joker – A-
Knives Out – B
Lego Movie 2: The Second Part – C
Lighthouse, The – B
Lion King, The – B
Little Women – A+
Marriage Story – A
Men in Black International – C+
Midsommar – B+
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood – C+
Pain and Glory – B
Parasite – A
Pet Sematary – C
Ready or Not – B
Rocketman – B+
Shazam! – B
Spider Man: Far From Home – B
To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before – B
Toy Story 4 – A-
Two Popes – B-
Uncut Gems – A
Us – B-
Yesterday – B

ReplyCopy URL

[pacinofan Joined: Nov 28th, 2011 Topics: 8 Posts: 4214 View Predictions]

#1203271027

Ad Astra C-
Black Christmas D
Bombshell B
Charlie’s Angels A-
Crawl B-
Doctor Sleep B
Downton Abbey C
Good Boys A-
Honey Boy A
It: Chapter Two B
Jumanji: The Next Level B
The Peanut Butter Falcon A
Richard Jewell B-
Scary Stories to Tell In the Dark B-
Skin B-
Terminator: Dark Fate B
Zombieland: Double Tap C

ReplyCopy URL

[pacinofan Joined: Nov 28th, 2011 Topics: 8 Posts: 4214 View Predictions]

#1203271031

Long Shot B

ReplyCopy URL

[forwardswill Joined: Apr 9th, 2013 Topics: 26 Posts: 4486 View Predictions]

#1203271159

A+
Parasite
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
Knives Out

A
Booksmart
Little Women
Downton Abbey

A-
1917
Rocketman
Ad Astra

B+
Jojo Rabbit
Marriage Story
Hustlers
Dolemite is My Name
Isn’t it Romantic

B
Bombshell
Wild Rose
Late Night
The Gentlemen
Judy
Last Christmas

B-
Ford v. Ferrari
The Two Popes
Harriet
Toy Story 4

C+
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker

C
The Good Liar

C-
Joker

ReplyCopy URL

[jman02 Joined: Jan 31st, 2015 Topics: 0 Posts: 134 View Predictions]

#1203271165

A Beautiful Day in the Neighbourhood – A-
American Factory – B+
And Then We Danced – A
Apollo 11 – A-
Avengers: Endgame – B
Captain Marvel – B-
Dark Phoenix – D
Detective Pikachu – C-
Dolemite Is My Name – A
Downton Abbey – B
Dumbo – B-
Farewell, The – A-
Ford vs. Ferrari – B+
For Sama – A-
Frozen II – C-
Honeyland – C+
How to Train Your Dragon 3: The Hidden World – B+
Hustlers – B
I Lost My Body – A-
Irishman, The – B
It: Chapter 2 – B-
Jojo Rabbit – A
Joker – B
Judy – B-
Klaus – B+
Knives Out – A-
Lego Movie 2: The Second Part – C+
Lion King, The – C
Marriage Story – A
Missing Link – B-
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood – B-
One Child Nation – B+
Pain and Glory – A-
Parasite – A+
Portrait of a Lady on Fire – A
Rocketman – B
Shazam! – B
Spider Man: Far From Home – B
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker – C
Toy Story 4 – B+
Transit – A-
Two Popes, The – A
Us – B
Zombieland: Double Tap – B

ReplyCopy URL

[Nikhil Joined: Dec 9th, 2015 Topics: 6 Posts: 435 View Predictions]

#1203271173

Aladdin: C+
Avengers- Endgame: B-
Bombshell: C+
Booksmart: D
Captain Marvel: D-
Detective Pikachu: D
Doctor Sleep: B+
The Farewell: A
Ford v. Ferrari: B
Good Boys: D-
Honey Boy: F
Hotel Mumbai: B
Hustlers: F
The Irishman: B
It Chapter 2: C-
John Wick 3: F
Jojo Rabbit: A-
Joker: A-
Knives Out: A-
Late Night: C
The Lighthouse: B-
The Lion King: D+
Little Women: A-
Long Shot: C
Luce: B
Marriage Story: B
Midsommar: B-
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood: A
Parasite: A+
The Peanut Butter Falcon: B+
The Perfection: F
Spider Man Far From Home: B
Star Wars- The Rise of Skywalker: D+
Uncut Gems: A
Us: C
Yesterday: B

Top 3 Films of the Year: Parasite, The Farewell, OUATIH

ReplyCopy URL

[L Hawks]

#1203271187

A+ = 5
Avengers: Endgame
I Lost My Body
Knives Out
Little Women
Luce
Marriage Story
Midsommar
Parasite
The Farewell
Us

A = 4.5
Dolemite is My Name
Ford v Ferrari
Joker
Jumanji: The Next Level
Richard Jewell

A- = 4
Doctor Sleep
Hobbs & Shaw
Ready or Not
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark
The Irishman

B+ = 3.75
A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood
Hustlers
Jojo Rabbit
Rocketman
The Report
The Two Popes
Toy Story 4

B = 3.5
Escape Room
Frozen II
Greta
Happy Death Day 2U
Isn’t It Romantic
It: Chapter Two
The Addams Family
The Aeronauts

B- = 3
21 Bridges
Ad Astra
Godzilla: King of the Monsters
Pokemon Detective Pikachu
Spider-Man: Far from Home

C = 2.5
Alita: Battle Angel
Atlantics
Cats
Dumbo
Glass
Harriet
Maleficent: Mistress of Evil
Midway
Pet Sematary
What Men Want

D = 1.5
Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
The King

D- = 1.25
Aladdin
Captain Marvel
Dora and the Lost City of Gold
Downton Abbey
Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile
In the Shadow of the Moon
Serenity
The Lion King
UglyDolls
Velvet Buzzsaw

F = 1
Captive State
Dark Phoenix
Jacob’s Ladder
Late Night
Point Blank
The Curse of La Llorona
The Laundromat

• This reply was modified 5 months, 4 weeks ago by L Hawks.
• This reply was modified 5 months, 4 weeks ago by L Hawks.

I just love movies. And awards.

ReplyCopy URL

[AmnistY21 Joined: Jan 1st, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 210 View Predictions]

#1203271211

1917 A
Atlantics A+
Ash is the Purest White A-
Avengers: Endgame B
A Hidden Life A-
Booksmart A
Bombshell B-
Charlie’s Angels C+
Captain Marvel C+
Dolemite Is My Name A-
Doctor Sleep A-
Escape Room B
Ford vs Ferrari A
Farewell, The A
Fyre: The Greatest Party That Never Happened A-
Good Liar, The B
Her Smell C+
Hustlers B+
Honey Boy A
Irishman, The B
It: Chapter Two C-
Jumanji: The Next Level B-
John Wick 3 A-
Jojo Rabbit B+
Joker A-
Judy B
Knives Out B+
Lighthouse, The B
Little Women A-
Luce A
Late Night B
Last Christman C+
Laundromat, The C-
Maleficent: Mistress of Evil C
Marriage Story A-
Men in Black International – D
Midsommar A
Once Upon A Time In Hollywood B+
Parasite A+
Ready Or Not A-
Rocketman B+
Shazam! B+
Someone Great B-
Terminator Dark Fate B
To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before B+
The Two Popes A-
Us A
Waves A
Yesterday B
Zombieland: Double Tap C

 

ReplyCopy URL

[pacinofan]

#1203271224

The Aeronauts B-
Captain Marvel B+
The Curse of La Llorona C-
Dolemite Is My Name B
Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile C
Gloria Bell B+
Happy Death Day 2 U B
Judy B
The Kid C-
Klaus C-
The Last Black Man In San Francisco A
Late Night B
Missing Link B+
The Report A-
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker B
The Unicorn Store C+
Velvet Buzzsaw C+

• This reply was modified 5 months, 4 weeks ago by pacinofan.
• This reply was modified 5 months, 4 weeks ago by pacinofan.

ReplyCopy URL

[Ruby Sparks]

#1203271287

Ad Astra: C
Always Be My Maybe: B+
Avengers: Endgame: A-
Bombshell: B+
Booksmart: A-
Captain Marvel: B+
Dolemite Is My Name: B
Dumbo: C-
The Farewell: A-
Frozen II: B-
Good Boys: A-
How To Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World: B+
Hustlers: A-
The Irishman: A-
Isn’t It Romantic: B
It Chapter Two: B-
Jojo Rabbit: A
Joker: A-
Judy: B-
Klaus: B+
Late Night: B+
The Lego Movie 2: The Second Part: A-
The Lion King: C+
Little Women: B
Long Shot: A
Luce: A-
Marriage Story: A-
Missing Link: B
Once Upon A Time in Hollywood: B-
Parasite: A+
Pokemon Detective Pikachu: A-
Queen & Slim: B-
Ready or Not: A
Rocketman: A
Shazam!: B
Spider-Man: Far From Home: B+
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker: B
Toy Story 4: A
Us: A+
Yesterday: C

• This reply was modified 5 months, 4 weeks ago by Ruby Sparks.
• This reply was modified 5 months, 4 weeks ago by Ruby Sparks.

ReplyCopy URL