Rank the Supporting Actress Nominees Who Didn’t Win (2010s)

[DrewN92 Joined: Jan 4th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 734 View Predictions]

#1203700674

wolfali wrote:

I love Alison Janney and her performance was deserving but she shouldn’t have swept for that. Laurie Metcalf literally (imo) gives one of the best supporting actress performances OF ALL TIME in Lady Bird.

I’ve rewatched Lady Bird twice since this Oscar season and I completely agree. It’s the definition of what a supporting role and performance should be. Definitely one of my all time favorites.

ReplyCopy URL

[wolfali Joined: Sep 4th, 2018 Topics: 262 Posts: 18518 View Predictions]

#1203700747

I mean imo both performers gave a masterclass in acting but Metcalf literally gave a game-changing performance.

I hope she can win eventually. One of the greatest actors of her generation.

FYC OSCARS : PROMISING YOUNG WOMAN IN ALL CATEGORIES (ESP. ACTRESS – Carey Mulligan AND ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY — EMERALD FENNELL), VANESSA KIRBY FOR "PIECES OF A WOMAN", ESSIE DAVIS FOR "BABYTEETH"

ReplyCopy URL

[JayDF Joined: Sep 18th, 2011 Topics: 36 Posts: 19711 View Predictions]

#1203700892

01. Jennifer Jason Leigh, The Hateful Eight
02. Melissa McCarthy, Bridesmaids
03. Rachel Weisz, The Favourite
04. Meryl Streep, Into the Woods
05. Florence Pugh, Little Women
06. Sally Hawkins, Blue Jasmine
07. Emma Stone, The Favourite
08. Octavia Spencer, The Shape of Water
09. Margot Robbie, Bombshell
10. Laurie Metclaf, Lady Bird
11. Jessica Chastain, The Help
12. Kathy Bates, Richard Jewell
13. Jacki Weaver, Animal Kingdom
14. Michelle Williams, Manchester by the Sea
15. Amy Adams, The Master
16. Kate Winslet, Steve Jobs
17. Scarlett Johansson, Jojo Rabbit
18. Rooney Mara, Carol
19. Rachel McAdams, Spotlight
20. Amy Adams, The Fighter
21. Naomie Harris, Moonlight
22. Janet McTeer, Albert Nobbs
23. Lesley Manville, Phantom Thread
24. Helena Bonham Carter, The King’s Speech
25. Laura Dern, Wild
26. Emma Stone, Birdman
27. Hailee Steinfeld, True Grit
28. Jennifer Lawrence, American Hustle
29. June Squibb, Nebraska
30. Marina deTavira, Roma
31. Amy Adams, Vice
32. Berenice Bejo, The Artist
33. Octavia Spencer, Hidden Figures
34. Nicole Kidman, Lion
35. Jacki Weaver, Silver Linings Playbook
36. Keira Knightley, The Imitation Game
37. Sally Field, Lincoln
38. Helen Hunt, The Sessions
39. Mary J. Blige, Mudbound
40. Julia Roberts, August: Osage County

ReplyCopy URL

[wolfali Joined: Sep 4th, 2018 Topics: 262 Posts: 18518 View Predictions]

#1203703179

So I’ve decided to count these ballots so we can eliminate 25 contenders and do a second round choosing ten candidates from the top 15 (same rules apply and if you rank them at #10 it is still counted as 31 points and #1 as 40 because otherwise some have absolutely no chance of making it through).

The results of the top 15 below :

15) Kate Winslet, Steve Jobs – 189 points

14) Marina de Tavira, Roma – 190 points

13) Scarlett Johansson, Jojo Rabbit – 195 points

12) Rooney Mara, Carol – 206 points

12) Florence Pugh, Little Women – 206 points

10) Jessica Chastain, The Help – 228 points

9) Melissa McCarthy, Bridesmaids – 229 points

8) Lesley Manville, Phantom Thread – 238 points

7) Sally Hawkins, Blue Jasmine – 254 points

6) Amy Adams, The Master – 261 points

5) Naomie Harris, Moonlight – 336 points

4) Michelle Williams, Manchester by the Sea – 341 points

3) Emma Stone, The Favourite – 378 points

2) Rachel Weisz, The Favourite – 435 points

1) Laurie Metcalf, Lady Bird – 531 points

Eliminated :

17) Amy Adams, The Fighter – 155 points
17) Jennifer Lawrence, American Hustle – 155 points
18) Jacki Weaver, Animal Kingdom – 142 points
19) Margot Robbie, Bombshell – 131 points
20) June Squibb, Nebraska – 128 points
21) Hailee Steinfeld, True Grit – 99 points
22) Rachel McAdams, Spotlight – 81 points
24) Sally Field, Lincoln – 80 points
24) Meryl Streep, Into the Woods – 80 points
25) Jennifer Jason Leigh, The Hateful Eight – 79 points
26) Octavia Spencer, The Shape of Water – 73 points
28) Nicole Kidman, Lion – 71 points
28) Emma Stone, Birdman – 71 points
29) Helen Hunt, The Sessions – 69 points
30) Amy Adams., Vice – 67 points
31) Berenice Bejo, The Artist – 61 points
32) Helena Bonham Carter, The King’s Speech – 46 points
33) Laura Dern, Wild – 45 points
34) Keira Knightley, The Imitation Game – 42 points
35) Julia Roberts, August : Osage County – 34 points
36) Janet McTeer, Albert Nobbs – 32 points
37) Kathy Bates, Richard Jewell – 29 points
38) Octavia Spencer, Hidden Figures – 23 points
39) Jacki Weaver, Silver Linings Playbook – 14 points
40) Mary J. Blige, Mudbound – 2 points

FYC OSCARS : PROMISING YOUNG WOMAN IN ALL CATEGORIES (ESP. ACTRESS – Carey Mulligan AND ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY — EMERALD FENNELL), VANESSA KIRBY FOR "PIECES OF A WOMAN", ESSIE DAVIS FOR "BABYTEETH"

ReplyCopy URL

[wolfali Joined: Sep 4th, 2018 Topics: 262 Posts: 18518 View Predictions]

#1203703187

1. Scarlett Johansson, Jojo Rabbit
2. Florence Pugh, Little Women
3. Laurie Metcalf, Lady Bird
4. Rachel Weisz, The Favourite
5. Emma Stone, The Favourite
6. Marina de Tavira, Roma
7. Amy Adams, The Master
8. Naomie Harris, Moonlight
9. Michelle Williams, Manchester by the Sea
10. Kate Winslet, Steve Jobs

FYC OSCARS : PROMISING YOUNG WOMAN IN ALL CATEGORIES (ESP. ACTRESS – Carey Mulligan AND ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY — EMERALD FENNELL), VANESSA KIRBY FOR "PIECES OF A WOMAN", ESSIE DAVIS FOR "BABYTEETH"

ReplyCopy URL

[JayDF Joined: Sep 18th, 2011 Topics: 36 Posts: 19711 View Predictions]

#1203703198

Latest round top ten favs…

01. Melissa McCarthy, Bridesmaids
02. Rachel Weisz, The Favourite
03. Florence Pugh, Little Women
04. Sally Hawkins, Blue Jasmine
05. Emma Stone, The Favourite
06. Laurie Metclaf, Lady Bird
07. Jessica Chastain, The Help
08. Michelle Williams, Manchester by the Sea
09. Amy Adams, The Master
10. Kate Winslet, Steve Jobs

ReplyCopy URL

[ArtIsntEasy Joined: Dec 17th, 2011 Topics: 3 Posts: 1162 View Predictions]

#1203703214

I do still find it interesting how Allison Janney managed to surge through the televised awards. I guess the love for her in the business just is that palpable. It certainly isn’t a bad performance (far from it)…in fact, I would even say it’s worthy overall. However, it is still basically a one note performance in many ways.

Metcalf, however, was a revelation. Funny and stubborn and she felt so real. Considering how Ladybird had the stronger critical pedigree and got key nominations that I TONYA didn’t, you’d think Metcalf would’ve been a good way to honor the film.

I’ll go ahead and rank my choices based on the top 15 above.

#15-Melissa McCarthy
#14-Marina del Tavira
#13-Kate Winslet
#12-Scarlett Johannson
#11-Jessica Chastain
#10-Rooney Mara (such blatant fraud, I did rank her a smidge lower for that reason)
#9-Lesley Manville
#8-Sally Hawkins
#7-Amy Adams, THE MASTER
#6-Emma Stone (blatant category fraud but she was still great)
#5-Rachel Weisz
#4-Michelle Williams
#3-Florence Pugh
#2-Naomie Harris
#1-Laurie Metcalf

“The art of making art is putting it together...”

ReplyCopy URL

[Diamonds Joined: Oct 24th, 2018 Topics: 1 Posts: 3184 View Predictions]

#1203703236

Ok, so just based on the Top 15…

1. Rachel Weisz – The Favourite
2. Naomie Harris – Moonlight
3. Laurie Metcalf – Lady Bird
4. Emma Stone – The Favourite
5. Jessica Chastain – The Help
6. Melissa McCarthy – Bridesmaids
7. Amy Adams – The Master
8. Sally Hawkins – Blue Jasmine
9. Lesley Manville – Phantom Thread
10. Michelle Williams – Manchester by the Sea
11. Rooney Mara – Carol
12. Marina de Tavira – Roma
13. Florence Pugh – Little Women
14. Kate Winslet – Steve Jobs
15. Scarlett Johansson – Jojo Rabbit

Totally sad that Jacki Weaver is out for Animal Kingdom already, probably the best (or second best) of this group.

ReplyCopy URL

[Kelvin Joined: Mar 10th, 2020 Topics: 5 Posts: 471 View Predictions]

#1203703391

1. Rooney Mara – Carol
2. Sally Hawkins – Blue Jasmine
3. Emma Stone – The Favourite
4. Michelle Williams – Manchester by the Sea
5. Laurie Metcalf -Lady Bird
6. Florence Pugh – Little Women
7. Naomi Harris – Moonlight
8. Octavia Spencer – The Shape of Water
9. Rachel Weisz – The Favourite
10 Jessica Chastain – The Help

Out of the top 15
1. Rooney Mara – Carol
2. Sally Hawkins – Blue Jasmine
3. Emma Stone – The Favourite
4. Michelle Williams – Manchester by the Sea
5. Laurie Metcalf – Lady Bird
6. Florence Pugh – Little Women
7. Naomie Harris – Moonlight
8. Rachel Weizs– The Favourite
9. Jessica Chastain – The Help
10. Melissa McCarthy – Bridesmaids
11. Marina de Tavira – Roma
12. Kate Winslet – Steve Jobs
13. Scarlett Johansson – Jojo Rabbit

ReplyCopy URL

[Brayfers Joined: Oct 19th, 2018 Topics: 4 Posts: 405 View Predictions]

#1203703499

1. Laurie Metcalf, Lady Bird
2. Emma Stone, The Favourite
3. Rachel Weisz, The Favourite
4. Naomie Harris, Moonlight
5. Jessica Chastain, The Help
6. Kate Winslet, Steve Jobs
7. Michelle Williams, Manchester by the Sea
8. Amy Adams, The Master
9. Sally Hawkins, Blue Jasmine
10. Florence Pugh, Little Women

Letterboxd: Brayfers

ReplyCopy URL

[Wanda Joined: Feb 16th, 2019 Topics: 42 Posts: 3496 View Predictions]

#1203703536

Ranking the top 15 except Kate Winslet whom I have not seen. Very good choices btw!

1. Jessica Chastain, The Help
2. Michelle Williams, Manchester By The Sea
3. Rooney Mara, Carol
4. Laurie Metcalf, Lady Bird
5. Sally Hawkins, Blue Jasmine
6. Marina De Tavira, Roma
7. Naomie Harris, Moonlight
8. Amy Adams, The Master
9. Lesley Manville, Phantom Thread
10. Emma Stone, The Favourite
11. Florence Pugh, Little Women
12. Melissa McCarthy, Bridesmaids
13. Rachel Weisz, The Favourite
14. Scarlett Johansson, Jojo Rabbit

ReplyCopy URL

[Eddy Q Joined: Oct 13th, 2012 Topics: 23 Posts: 4688 View Predictions]

#1203703911

Diamonds wrote:

Totally sad that Jacki Weaver is out for Animal Kingdom already, probably the best (or second best) of this group.

Probably due to recency bias and lack of other nominations for the film that would give it must-see status. And yeah, it sucks that not enough people have seen her in it but I can’t really talk as I still have two blind spots from this list myself.

ReplyCopy URL

[Atypical Joined: Dec 1st, 2011 Topics: 355 Posts: 21785 View Predictions]

#1203703942

No Jacki Weaver for “Animal Kingdom” is complete BS.

ReplyCopy URL

[William Gillquist Joined: Jan 1st, 2020 Topics: 10 Posts: 623 View Predictions]

#1203704103

My ranking of the Top 15

1. Metcalf

2. Harris

3. Adams

4. Williams

5. Weisz

6. Stone

7. Johansson

8. de Tavira

9. McCarthy

10. Chastain

I have not seen Blue Jasmine, Phantom Thread, Carol, Little Women, or Steve Jobs.

FYC Oscars: Soul (Best Picture, Original Screenplay, and Original Score), Regina King (Best Director), Delroy Lindo (Best Actor), Viola Davis (Best Actress), Leslie Odom Jr. (Best Supporting Actor)

ReplyCopy URL

[Miles Joined: Oct 22nd, 2016 Topics: 22 Posts: 3868 View Predictions]

#1203704293

1. Michelle Williams, Manchester by the Sea
2. Laurie Metcalf, Lady Bird
3. Naomie Harris, Moonlight
4. Sally Hawkins, Blue Jasmine
5. June Squibb, Nebraska
6. Margot Robbie, Bombshell
7. Nicole Kidman, Lion
8. Melissa McCarthy, Bridesmaids
9. Jennifer Lawrence, American Hustle
10. Marina de Tavira, Roma

ReplyCopy URL