Sean Penn vs Mickey Rourke

[babypook Joined: Nov 4th, 2010 Topics: 143 Posts: 17017 View Predictions]

#1203154667

I noticed that The Wrestler was on the tube so I watched it again.

Rourke and Penn were neck and neck that year (2008).
Penn gave a technically perfect performance in Milk and imo was very much “better” than he was for his first win.

Rourke on the other hand gave a performance straight from his heart in a film which mirrored his own life. He truly broke my heart.
But Mickey isn’t the most personable guy and my guess is, this hurt him in the end.

Anyways, I still can’t decide which of them was more deserving of Oscar.

I’d love to hear what y’all think.

Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?
Philip K Dick Blade Runner

Reply

[estrelas Joined: Jul 25th, 2018 Topics: 2 Posts: 1849 View Predictions]

#1203154676

Mickey Rourke all the way!!! Even though Sean Penn gave his best performance since Dead Man Walking, Mickey was just something else. He gave one of those rare performances that you just don’t see every year. A performance that truly came from the heart and soul.

FYC Emmys: Helena Bonham Carter (Drama Supporting Actress), Olivia Colman (Drama Actress), Jodie Comer and Sandra Oh (Drama Actress), Fiona Shaw (Drama Supporting Actress), Zendaya (Drama Actress), Alexis Bledel (Drama Guest Actress)

ReplyCopy URL

[Keth Joined: Dec 2nd, 2011 Topics: 0 Posts: 555 View Predictions]

#1203154724

babypook wrote:

I noticed that The Wrestler was on the tube so I watched it again.

Rourke and Penn were neck and neck that year (2008).
Penn gave a technically perfect performance in Milk and imo was very much “better” than he was for his first win.

Rourke on the other hand gave a performance straight from his heart in a film which mirrored his own life. He truly broke my heart.
But Mickey isn’t the most personable guy and my guess is, this hurt him in the end.

Anyways, I still can’t decide which of them was more deserving of Oscar.

I’d love to hear what y’all think.

Sometimes I wish the Oscars would award outstanding performances instead of one actor in each of the four acting categories. Both Rourke and Penn deserved Oscars for their performances in “The Wrestler” and “Milk.” Just like Hunter and Bassett for “The Piano” and “What’s Love Got to Do with It”. Just like Burstyn and Mason and Streisand for “The Exorcist” and “Cinderella Liberty” and “The Way We Were.” Yes, I think three actresses deserved Oscars that year. And I could go on and on and on. That way we wouldn’t have actors winning overdue Oscars over a more deserving actor. Sorry to get off track, but I really think both Rourke and Penn should have tied that year.

ReplyCopy URL

[theexterminator Joined: Dec 15th, 2016 Topics: 4 Posts: 449 View Predictions]

#1203154728

Rourke

ReplyCopy URL

[babypook Joined: Nov 4th, 2010 Topics: 143 Posts: 17017 View Predictions]

#1203154733

Keth wrote:

Sometimes I wish the Oscars would award outstanding performances instead of one actor in each of the four acting categories. Both Rourke and Penn deserved Oscars for their performances in “The Wrestler” and “Milk.” Just like Hunter and Bassett for “The Piano” and “What’s Love Got to Do with It”. Just like Burstyn and Mason and Streisand for “The Exorcist” and “Cinderella Liberty” and “The Way We Were.” Yes, I think three actresses deserved Oscars that year. And I could go on and on and on. That way we wouldn’t have actors winning overdue Oscars over a more deserving actor. Sorry to get off track, but I really think both Rourke and Penn should have tied that year.

And very much like Adam and Joaquin (thus far).
I wonder if, given the logistics, a tie is even possible nowadays.

So glad you mentioned Bassett. What a revelation she is in that role!

Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?
Philip K Dick Blade Runner

ReplyCopy URL

[Joined: Jan 1st, 1970 Topics: 22 Posts: 9848 View Predictions]

#1203154745

This post was found to be inappropriate by the moderators and has been removed.

[M: The Original Joined: Aug 5th, 2014 Topics: 57 Posts: 6495 View Predictions]

#1203154753

Penn won for two reasons: the passage of Prop 8 in California that allowed for a ban on gay marriage, and Rourke’s legacy of burning bridges with Hollywood power players throughout the years squandering whatever goodwill it’d ever have in the business.

ReplyCopy URL

[Emmyfan Joined: Nov 26th, 2010 Topics: 74 Posts: 4454 View Predictions]

#1203154769

I do think that Rourke was slightly more deserving than Sean Penn.

I also think that some voters were thinking Rourke did this and did that to me back in the 80s and 90s and held that against him.

ReplyCopy URL

[David Guarnieri Joined: Mar 29th, 2016 Topics: 0 Posts: 3 View Predictions]

#1203154859

Mickey Rourke.

ReplyCopy URL

[MrGoodWood Joined: Dec 14th, 2013 Topics: 5 Posts: 609 View Predictions]

#1203154933

It’s insane how similar Mickey Rourke’s loss is to Michael Keaton’s. Both were riding on a comeback narrative, both were playing characters that are similar to themselves. Both were early frontrunners and won the Globe and BAFTA, but then lost SAG and ultimately the Oscar to a more typical baity performance of a real person.

ReplyCopy URL

[24fanatic Joined: Nov 6th, 2010 Topics: 1 Posts: 1198 View Predictions]

#1203154944

I wanted Rourke to win so bad! Can’t blame Penn for winning though.

ReplyCopy URL

[Mukund Joined: May 27th, 2018 Topics: 5 Posts: 2555 View Predictions]

#1203154949

Keaton lost BAFTA actually.

ReplyCopy URL

[MrGoodWood Joined: Dec 14th, 2013 Topics: 5 Posts: 609 View Predictions]

#1203154991

Mukund wrote:

Keaton lost BAFTA actually.

Ah damn, you’re right, my bad. Still, a very similar road for them.

ReplyCopy URL

[Joined: Jan 1st, 1970 Topics: 9 Posts: 1077 View Predictions]

#1203154998

This post was found to be inappropriate by the moderators and has been removed.

[Thatcher, Prime Minister of GoldDerby Joined: Jan 3rd, 2018 Topics: 8 Posts: 2292 View Predictions]

#1203155207

Darlings, Gay Penn outacted. Rourke was disgusting.

 

As a famous singer said, "ain't nobody gonna Thatcher, Thatcher, Thatcher!"

ReplyCopy URL