-
-
This is one of the highlights of the Oscar season for me. The shorts are finally premiering this weekend in wide release. See them soon, b/c with the truncated Oscar season this year, I don’t expect them to air past next weekend, sadly.
The nominees are:
SHORT FILM (ANIMATED)
DCERA (DAUGHTER)
Daria KashcheevaHAIR LOVE
Matthew A. Cherry and Karen Rupert ToliverKITBULL
Rosana Sullivan and Kathryn HendricksonMEMORABLE
Bruno Collet and Jean-François Le CorreSISTER
Siqi SongSHORT FILM (LIVE ACTION)
BROTHERHOOD
Meryam Joobeur and Maria Gracia TurgeonNEFTA FOOTBALL CLUB
Yves Piat and Damien MegherbiTHE NEIGHBORS’ WINDOW
Marshall CurrySARIA
Bryan Buckley and Matt LefebvreA SISTER
Delphine GirardDOCUMENTARY (SHORT SUBJECT)
IN THE ABSENCE
Yi Seung-Jun and Gary Byung-Seok KamLEARNING TO SKATEBOARD IN A WARZONE (IF YOU’RE A GIRL)
Carol Dysinger and Elena AndreichevaLIFE OVERTAKES ME
John Haptas and Kristine SamuelsonST. LOUIS SUPERMAN
Smriti Mundhra and Sami KhanWALK RUN CHA-CHA
Laura Nix and Colette SandstedtDiscuss.
ReplyPredictions and rankings:
Live-Action:
Will Win: Saria
Personal Ranking:
1. Brotherhood
2. The Neighbors’ Window
3. A Sister
4. Nefta Football Club
5. SariaAnimated:
Will Win: Hair Love
Personal Ranking:
1. Memorable
2. Kitbull
3. Dcera (Daughter)
4. Hair Love
5. SisterDocumentary:
Will Win: Learning to Skateboard in a Warzone (If You’re a Girl)
Personal Ranking:
1. In the Absence
2. Life Overtakes Me
3. Learning to Skateboard in a Warzone
4. Walk Run Cha-ChaDoes anybody have link to St. Louis Superman?
ReplyCopy URL^Could you explain why you are thinking Saria will win? I have Brotherhood in my predictions. Haven’t seen any of them yet, just wondering what reasoning there is for Saria?
Nefta Football Club was nominated for a Cesar award this past Wednesday.
I have Hair Love and Learning To Skateboard In A Warzone in my predictions too. Hoping I can get 2 out of 3 after last year’s fiasco of getting zero right due to letting my own opinions get in my way (I disliked Period. End of Sentence and Skin immensely).
ReplyCopy URL^Could you explain why you are thinking Saria will win? I have Brotherhood in my predictions. Haven’t seen any of them yet, just wondering what reasoning there is for Saria?
Nefta Football Club was nominated for a Cesar award this past Wednesday.
I have Hair Love and Learning To Skateboard In A Warzone in my predictions too. Hoping I can get 2 out of 3 after last year’s fiasco of getting zero right due to letting my own opinions get in my way (I disliked Period. End of Sentence and Skin immensely).
I don’t have some special explanation for my Saria prediction tbh. I just checked audience score and they’re pretty good, and the movie is about children which is what frequently wins. Brotherhood is my fav, but really it doesn’t feel like their cup of tea. Nefta Football Club is a comedy, which also don’t usually win here.
ReplyCopy URLWhy people think Brotherhood will win here…? I don’t understand these predictions. It’s very good, visually stunning but just too challenging for most members i think. Such films just never win in this category. So i’m kinda baffled it’s odds on to win on GD.
I think it’s between Neighbors Window and Saria. Leaning former
-
This reply was modified 8 months ago by
.
-
This reply was modified 8 months ago by .
-
This reply was modified 8 months ago by .
Ah yes, the nebulous Short Film categories that never seem to go to the frontrunner and always mess uk my predictions. I think this year I will just employ the strategy if voting for the 2nd place in each of these categories, except for Animated Short: I’m confident Hair Love will win that one.
ReplyCopy URLStream After Hours and In Your Eyes (Remix)
^Could you explain why you are thinking Saria will win? I have Brotherhood in my predictions. Haven’t seen any of them yet, just wondering what reasoning there is for Saria? Nefta Football Club was nominated for a Cesar award this past Wednesday. I have Hair Love and Learning To Skateboard In A Warzone in my predictions too. Hoping I can get 2 out of 3 after last year’s fiasco of getting zero right due to letting my own opinions get in my way (I disliked Period. End of Sentence and Skin immensely).
It’s not a good short imo but might win because of the tragic subject matter.
ReplyCopy URLLIVE ACTION SHORT FILMS
Not the best roster I’ve seen since these films started being released wide. I wouldn’t have nominated either “Nefta Football Club” or “Brotherhood,” and I’d be pretty disappointed if the latter ended up winning based solely on topical content. Both of these shorts were slight and unengaging to me. If the serious route is what Academy voters will take, there’s “Saria” right there instead that accomplishes similar modern-day political messaging with a tighter, more interesting real-life story. I was unnerved by the tense “A Sister,” but I think the nomination is the reward for it. I’m predicting “The Neighbors’ Window” to win the Oscar. Many times it’s the apple in a sea of oranges that wins out here, like “God of Love,” “Stutterer,” and “The New Tenants.” This one has both levity and drama, stars a known Hollywood actress (I instantly recognized her from “Orange Is the New Black,” but she’s been acting in films for a long time), and being one of the more relatable US entries will also help. I think the race is between the two US nominees, which is sort of rare. I wouldn’t be surprised if “Saria” wins over “The Neighbors’ Window,” but anything else winning would be unfortunate.
Rankings:
1. “The Neighbors’ Window” (USA)
ReplyCopy URL
2. “Saria” (USA)
3. “A Sister” (Belgium)
4. “Brotherhood” (Tunisia/Canada/etc.)
5. “Nefta Football Club” (France)Predictions and rankings:
Live-Action:
Will Win: Saria
Personal Ranking:
1. Brotherhood
2. The Neighbors’ Window
3. A Sister
4. Nefta Football Club
5. SariaAnimated:
Will Win: Hair Love
Personal Ranking:
1. Memorable
2. Kitbull
3. Dcera (Daughter)
4. Hair Love
5. SisterDocumentary:
Will Win: Learning to Skateboard in a Warzone (If You’re a Girl)
Personal Ranking:
1. In the Absence
2. Life Overtakes Me
3. Learning to Skateboard in a Warzone
4. Walk Run Cha-ChaDoes anybody have link to St. Louis Superman?
This could’ve been easily written by me, since I agree with everything you said here, haha.
I also have a really strong feeling that Saria is going to take this, even if it’s the only of the nominees that haven’t taken any awards yet. It seems just like the only option for the Academy’s profile here, but I could see an upset by Nefta Football Club here.
ReplyCopy URLANIMATED SHORT FILMS
Much stronger field, thankfully, than the live action shorts this year. There is even a “Highly Commended” short that I would have nominated over what was actually nominated. The race seems to be “Hair Love”‘s to lose, and maybe the recent resurgence of #OscsrsSoWhite will push this over the edge. It was middle of the pack for me, even though the overall message of familial support was a heartwarming one. I was much more taken by two very moving and depressing shorts instead (not too common for this category). “Sister” is a compelling short about a Chinese man vividly imagining what it would have been like to have a sister during China’s “one child only” era. It was amazing both visually and stylistically and deeply resonated with me. Czech Republic’s “Dcera [Daughter]” had the most striking animation of the field in a touching story about a grown daughter’s estrangement with her father on his deathbed. The two I didn’t like all that much were “Mémorable,” a scattered and unwieldy impressionistic take on an old couple dealing with Alzheimer’s, and the silly “Kitbull,” a short about the friendship between a cat and a dog. I’d replace either one with the striking “Henrietta Bulkowski,” a lovely American short about a woman with a hunchback who wants to fly planes, but takes flight in another way instead. It starred Christina Hendricks and Chris Cooper, so that kind of high-profile voice talent is usually enough for an Oscar nomination. Anyways, going out on a limb and picking “Sister” to upset, knowing that “Hair Love” is the supposed frontrunner. We’ll find out the results soon enough.
Rankings:
1. “Sister” (China/USA)
ReplyCopy URL
2. “Dcera [Daughter]” (Czech Republic)
3. “Hair Love” (USA)
4. “Mémorable” (France)
5. “Kitbull” (USA)Ranked Predictions:
Live Action:
1. Nefta Football Club
2. The Neighbors’ Window
3. Saria
4. Brotherhood
5. A SisterWould be a little surprised if the winner isn’t out of the first two. A Sister is something those of us who watch to shorts have seen before, it isn’t the most effective version of it and they usually lose. Brotherhood is fine, I don’t know who is motivated to vote for it though. Saria has a call to arms kind of message but is tonally uneven. The Neighbor’s Window has the advantage of English and it’s a good short, a nice mix of new ideas and emotions. I do think the ending was lacking something more. I think Nefta wins as a story with beginning, middle and an unforeseen ending (which they love). Child actors help. It’s funny without being out-and-out comedy. It does remind me a lot of Sing which won in 2016.
ReplyCopy URLI’m actually seeing them this year which is exciting. The last few years, and I’ve had success with this, I just pick the ones which have the names which stick out to me/seem like they’d be important. For me, this year that’s:
Nefta Football Club
Saria
Hair Love
Learning to Skateboard in a Warzone
St. Louis SupermanReplyCopy URLTop 3 Films of the Year: Parasite, The Farewell, OUATIH
-
This reply was modified 8 months ago by
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
