What’s your choice from the line-up of William Holden’s win?

[Madson Melo Joined: Jul 25th, 2011 Topics: 68 Posts: 3427 View Predictions]

#1203569521

Have you seen all the nominees? Who do you pick?

I’ve just rewatched ”Julius Caesar” and I know Brando enters halfway into the movie, but I’m really torned between Clift and him.

Reply

[arodfan Joined: Mar 25th, 2020 Topics: 4 Posts: 402 View Predictions]

#1203569781

Either of the two From Here to Eternity guys, but I’m leaning towards Clift.

ReplyCopy URL

[keithw Joined: Aug 17th, 2012 Topics: 37 Posts: 372 View Predictions]

#1203570418

William Holden deserved his Oscar. He was also excellent in Network.

ReplyCopy URL

[JayDF Joined: Sep 18th, 2011 Topics: 36 Posts: 17654 View Predictions]

#1203570697

Clift deserved the win for sure. Holden is 2nd and Brando 3rd. Brando should have been nominated for “The Wild One” though. I could have gone with different actors for the last two spots like Spencer Tracy in “The Actress” and Richard Widmark in “Pickup On South Street”.

ReplyCopy URL

[Owl-Always-watching Joined: Dec 13th, 2017 Topics: 7 Posts: 463 View Predictions]

#1203571240

Fine with Holden win. But Cliff right behind . Too bad he didn’t win in his career

ReplyCopy URL

[RobertPius Joined: Nov 22nd, 2012 Topics: 258 Posts: 1743 View Predictions]

#1203571394

Owl-Always-watching wrote:

Fine with Holden win. But Cliff right behind . Too bad he didn’t win in his career

Was Clift considered a possibility to win for Judgement at Nuremberg? I saw it a long time ago and don’t really remember if he was deserving.

I’ve heard George Chikaris’ win mocked as undeserving.

ReplyCopy URL

[arodfan Joined: Mar 25th, 2020 Topics: 4 Posts: 402 View Predictions]

#1203571409

RobertPius wrote:

Was Clift considered a possibility to win for Judgement at Nuremberg? I saw it a long time ago and don’t really remember if he was deserving. I’ve heard George Chikaris’ win mocked as undeserving.

I recall that the prize that year was between Gleason and Clift, yet Chakiris won in an upset, which was a really dumb choice. Clift and Gleason were both phenomenal, and Clift was way overdue as well. What were they thinking?

ReplyCopy URL

[Foolio Joined: Jan 24th, 2017 Topics: 4 Posts: 6580 View Predictions]

#1203571530

…All the way, all day.

Monty being snubbed four times is rather symbolic of his underdog status in general, wouldn’t you say? Yes, he was and is a celebrated icon, but he also never got the credit he deserved for revolutionizing both pop culture gender norms and the concept of on-screen acting.

He opened the bank for Dean and Brando and they walked away with the money.

ReplyCopy URL

[manakamana Joined: Jul 28th, 2011 Topics: 19 Posts: 1434 View Predictions]

#1203571646

Brando is actually my favorite performance of these, but I don’t have a problem with Holden’s win and I think Monty deserved it most for A Place in the Sun but he’s beautiful in FHTE as well and should have won at some point.

ReplyCopy URL

[JayDF Joined: Sep 18th, 2011 Topics: 36 Posts: 17654 View Predictions]

#1203571904

RobertPius wrote:

Was Clift considered a possibility to win for Judgement at Nuremberg? I saw it a long time ago and don’t really remember if he was deserving.

I’ve heard George Chikaris’ win mocked as undeserving.

Chakiris’ win is one of the worst of the category and not even because of the great performances he won over but just in general. He was a fine dancer but the performance otherwise was pedestrian. He got swept up in the glorification of WEST SIDE STORY, which other than it’s original score form the stage is way overrated IMO.

ReplyCopy URL

[Human Bartender Joined: Apr 24th, 2016 Topics: 53 Posts: 4605 View Predictions]

#1203571927

I disagree with the Chakiris dragging going on here. I thought he was wonderfully dangerous and seductive. And he wasn’t just dancing, there’s so much personality and character in his movements.

I love his win because performances like that aren’t usually embraced, likely due to being so heavy and music and dancing. His victory is unique, and I quite like it.

Let’s Go Bucks

ReplyCopy URL

[Owl-Always-watching Joined: Dec 13th, 2017 Topics: 7 Posts: 463 View Predictions]

#1203572927

Cliff and Garland were great in Nuremberg

ReplyCopy URL