Home Forums Reality TV American Idol Season 18

American Idol Season 18

CREATE A NEW TOPIC
CREATE A NEW POLL
Viewing 11 posts - 31 through 41 (of 41 total)
Created
8 months ago
Last Reply
4 months ago
40
replies
4704
views
8
users
vinny
17
Tyler The Awe..
8
TVLUVAH
5
  • Profile picture
    vinny
    Joined:
    May 20th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203476048

    Gonna tackle this round by round and then my predictions for the 5

    Disney:
    1. Arthur Gunn: Nailed it.
    2. Jonny West: Nailed it.
    3. Francisco Martin: Nailed it.
    4. Just Sam: Her weakest so far.
    5. Dilion James: Eh
    6. Louis Knight: Yikes. That was not great.
    7. Julia Gargano: Eh

    Moms:
    1. Francisco Martin: Nailed it.
    2. Arthur Gunn: Nailed it.
    3. Jonny West: Nailed it.
    4. Just Sam: Nailed it.
    5. Julia Gargano: Nailed it.
    6. Dilion James: Nailed it.
    7. Louis Knight: Not his night….this wasn’t great.

    Five Predictions:
    1. Arthur Gunn
    2. Francisco Martin
    3. Just Sam
    4. Jonny West
    5. Dilion James

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Jennifer Wright
    Joined:
    May 21st, 2018
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203477185

    Going to update this as people go trough and bolding my favs: My thoughts on the ones that went through in Episode One: Doug Kiker: He is good but I wasn’t wowed by him either. Camryn Leigh Smith: Going to sound a bit mean here but I didn’t really think she was that great. Nick Merico: He annoys me because of his ego but he has a great voice. Torn on this one. Francisco Martin: This bundle of nerves can do that?! A front runner in my opinion. Dibesh Rokharel (Arthur Gunn): Another front runner in my opinion. WOW. He sounds a lot like Phillip Phillips…..will America mind that though? Louis Knight: Wow! Also a bit underwhelming all at once so this is a weird one. He reminds me of Jesse McCartney and Louis from One Direction had a love child. Meghan Fitton: I liked her…..didn’t wow me either but she has a lot of potential. Samantha Diaz (Just Sam): Unpopular opinion probably but I wasn’t in love with this one. She sounded good on the second song though. Episode 2: Cyniah Elise: Great voice but at the same time I need to hear more to really see if she is just a ballad singer. Kay Genyse: Ugh. Just no. Kyle Tanguay: He was a pleasant surprise. Jovin Webb: Unpopular opinion but wasn’t wowed by him Margie Mays: My fav odd person came back calm? Johnny West: Another front runner for me. Sarah Isen: Eh. Wasn’t wowed. Julia Gargano: Loved her. Hannah Prestridge: Loved her. Kimmy Gabriela: Liked her. Lauren Mascitti: Eh. She sounded ok but wasn’t wowed either. Courtney Timmons: Wasn’t wowed but she reminded me if Fantasia meets Jordyn Spark. Lauren Spencer Smith: Eh Genavieve Linkowski: Loved her Etta James song choice person: Liked her. Dillon James: Not the strongest vocally but I liked it. DeWayne Crocker Jr: Loved it. Episode 3: Mosean Wilson: Good. Faith Becnel: I really like her voice but not her. Kat Luna: She was great. Boring but great. Space Cowboy: I am iffy. He can sing but isn’t as good as his girlfriend and is equally as dull. There were three that went through rapidly and we didn’t see a lot of so there is that. Sophia Wackerman: Wasn’t a fan Jimmy Levy: no lol just no Ren Patrick: I loved her Zack Dobbins: Loved him Marna Michele: loved her Olivia Ximines: I loved her. Danny La Rota: Eh. Great potential though. Devon Alexnder: Good. Makayla Phillips: She is the one from AGT if I recall correctly. Did great. Last Audiotion Episode (I feel like I wrote the Name wrong for a few so correct me if so and I will fix): Robert Tyler: Meh. Franklin Boone: Not sure if I like him as a singer yet but as a person I am a fan. Roselyn Carter: Not bad. Megan Knight: Nope lol Jordan Moyes: Liked him Demi Rae: YES Makayla Brownlee: Yeah….iffy Amber Fiedler: I don’t get why…..she isn’t that good Jahzan: Has a lot of potential. Gilberto Rivera: He has potential Aliana Jester: Loved her Grace Leer: Loved her

    vote Julie gargano

     

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Jennifer Wright
    Joined:
    May 21st, 2018
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203477190

    I pieced together as much as I could but here are the top 40 (Going to bold my favs): Aliana Jester Amber Fiedler Amelia Joyce Bilaal Avaz Cameron Havens Cyniah Elise Demi Rae Moreno Dewayne Crocker Devon Alexander Dibesh Rokharel (Arthur Gunn) Dillon James Elyjuh Rene Faith Becnel Francisco Martin Franklin Boone Geena Fontanella Genavieve Linkowski Grace Leer Grace Lundy Jeb Vonderbruegge Jonny West Jordan Jones Jovin Webb Julia Gargano Kimmy Gabriela Lauren Mascitti Lauren Spencer Smith Louie Knight Makayla Phillips Makayla Brownlee Natalie Jane Nick Merico Olivia Ximines Perrin York Robert Taylor Samantha Diaz Sophia Wackerman Shannon Gibbons Travis Finlay Did I miss anyone?

    vote Julie gargano

    Going to update this as people go trough and bolding my favs: My thoughts on the ones that went through in Episode One: Doug Kiker: He is good but I wasn’t wowed by him either. Camryn Leigh Smith: Going to sound a bit mean here but I didn’t really think she was that great. Nick Merico: He annoys me because of his ego but he has a great voice. Torn on this one. Francisco Martin: This bundle of nerves can do that?! A front runner in my opinion. Dibesh Rokharel (Arthur Gunn): Another front runner in my opinion. WOW. He sounds a lot like Phillip Phillips…..will America mind that though? Louis Knight: Wow! Also a bit underwhelming all at once so this is a weird one. He reminds me of Jesse McCartney and Louis from One Direction had a love child. Meghan Fitton: I liked her…..didn’t wow me either but she has a lot of potential. Samantha Diaz (Just Sam): Unpopular opinion probably but I wasn’t in love with this one. She sounded good on the second song though. Episode 2: Cyniah Elise: Great voice but at the same time I need to hear more to really see if she is just a ballad singer. Kay Genyse: Ugh. Just no. Kyle Tanguay: He was a pleasant surprise. Jovin Webb: Unpopular opinion but wasn’t wowed by him Margie Mays: My fav odd person came back calm? Johnny West: Another front runner for me. Sarah Isen: Eh. Wasn’t wowed. Julia Gargano: Loved her. Hannah Prestridge: Loved her. Kimmy Gabriela: Liked her. Lauren Mascitti: Eh. She sounded ok but wasn’t wowed either. Courtney Timmons: Wasn’t wowed but she reminded me if Fantasia meets Jordyn Spark. Lauren Spencer Smith: Eh Genavieve Linkowski: Loved her Etta James song choice person: Liked her. Dillon James: Not the strongest vocally but I liked it. DeWayne Crocker Jr: Loved it. Episode 3: Mosean Wilson: Good. Faith Becnel: I really like her voice but not her. Kat Luna: She was great. Boring but great. Space Cowboy: I am iffy. He can sing but isn’t as good as his girlfriend and is equally as dull. There were three that went through rapidly and we didn’t see a lot of so there is that. Sophia Wackerman: Wasn’t a fan Jimmy Levy: no lol just no Ren Patrick: I loved her Zack Dobbins: Loved him Marna Michele: loved her Olivia Ximines: I loved her. Danny La Rota: Eh. Great potential though. Devon Alexnder: Good. Makayla Phillips: She is the one from AGT if I recall correctly. Did great. Last Audiotion Episode (I feel like I wrote the Name wrong for a few so correct me if so and I will fix): Robert Tyler: Meh. Franklin Boone: Not sure if I like him as a singer yet but as a person I am a fan. Roselyn Carter: Not bad. Megan Knight: Nope lol Jordan Moyes: Liked him Demi Rae: YES Makayla Brownlee: Yeah….iffy Amber Fiedler: I don’t get why…..she isn’t that good Jahzan: Has a lot of potential. Gilberto Rivera: He has potential Aliana Jester: Loved her Grace Leer: Loved her

    vote Julie gargano

     

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    alokin
    Joined:
    Jun 23rd, 2012
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203486713

    It’s crazy that the winner will already be crowned tonight with seven contestants still remaining! But maybe it just feels that way because this season has somehow flown by faster than previous ones. This is a very strong and talented group, and I could see anyone take it. What’s interesting is that with the (unprecedented) new format to the show, it was really anybody’s guess as to who the weekly top and bottom vote-getters were, which makes it that much harder to predict where everyone will place in the finale. Of course, I’m rooting for Louis Knight (from my viewing area and who I first heard perform his original song, “Change”, last summer on The Q, a local broadcast entertainment show, and I immediately knew then he was something special) but Arthur Gunn has such a unique voice and artistic style that I have a feeling he will prevail. Just Sam and Francisco Martin are my dark horse picks who could steal it away.

    Much luck to everyone tonight!

    Final predictions:
    1. Arthur Gunn
    2. Louis Knight
    3. (TIE!) Just Sam and Francisco Martin

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    TVLUVAH
    Joined:
    Feb 1st, 2018
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203487289

    I’m beyond thrilled the actual correct person actually won. Yay for Just Sam!

    I would’ve ranked them like this:
    1. Just Sam
    2. Francisco
    3. Dillon
    4. Arthur
    5. Jonny

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    WildforFilm
    Joined:
    Jun 20th, 2013
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203487496

    Would have preferred Francisco winning, but the talent in the Top 10 was really good this year, so I can’t complain too much. He could still have a career.

    Any word on Ryan Seacrest? I’m worried about his health after he came back from that commercial break with the droopy eye and the disoriented speech…

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    vinny
    Joined:
    May 20th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203487590

    I am happy that she won since I figured it was between her and Arthur….just had the order reversed lol.
    Just Sam: PERFECT night
    Francisco: Nailed the first performance but not the second
    Jonny: Perfect night
    Arthur: Pefect night
    Dillon: Great 2nd performance

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    TVLUVAH
    Joined:
    Feb 1st, 2018
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203488493

    Would have preferred Francisco winning, but the talent in the Top 10 was really good this year, so I can’t complain too much. He could still have a career.

    Any word on Ryan Seacrest? I’m worried about his health after he came back from that commercial break with the droopy eye and the disoriented speech…

    Ryan tweeted out that he is fine thankfully… According to press, he was just over exhausted and stressed, plus there was some confusion on what was happening at the very end (ie: who he was gonna talk to and when), just some production stuff. He’s such a pro, so it was probably just all of that rolled into one.

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    Sade
    Joined:
    Dec 1st, 2019
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203499146

    Honey, I am surprised someone black won this white ass show.

    These contestants were awful. It’s time for this show to hang it up. No one cares anymore. BARF!

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    vinny
    Joined:
    May 20th, 2011
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203499781

    Honey, I am surprised someone black won this white ass show.

    These contestants were awful. It’s time for this show to hang it up. No one cares anymore. BARF!

    3 things:
    1)RENEWED and ratings were great so clearly people care
    2)Not everything is about race with Idol like you seem to think it is (Gucci it’s clearly u)….she was one of the three best and deserved the win
    3)U Don’t like it… don’t watch the show simple as that.

    ReplyCopy URL
    Profile picture
    alokin
    Joined:
    Jun 23rd, 2012
    Topics:
    Posts:
    #1203500998

    Congrats to Just Sam! Would love to see her work on a future duet with Lionel Richie; I think their voices complement each other really well.

    Speaking of Lionel, I was very moved by that powerful ending montage of the finale set to his “We Are the World” collaboration with this year’s top contenders and noteworthy Idol contestants of years past. It was beautifully pieced together.

    ReplyCopy URL
Viewing 11 posts - 31 through 41 (of 41 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Similar Topics
AWDubay - Sep 11, 2020
Reality TV
lvigario - Sep 10, 2020
Reality TV
Awardsf... - Sep 8, 2020
Reality TV